Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Cooling flow — where it appears

The slow inward drift predicted for hot cluster gas whose central cooling time is shorter than the age of the cluster. A steady flow would deposit hundreds of solar masses a year. X-ray spectra show that most of that gas never cools, so some heating must prevent it.

Named by 2 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Gas outweighs stars 6:1, and the baryons come to 15%. Above: enclosed mass against radius for a 7-keV cluster with a beta-model gas profile, β = 0.65 and a 250-kpc core. The total is from hydrostatic equilibrium — the same equation that holds up a star, with the mass following from the density and temperature gradients and from nothing else — and comes to 9.98·10¹⁴ solar masses inside 2 megaparsecs. The gas, integrated from the same profile, is 1.6·10¹⁴; the stars in all the galaxies are 2.5·10¹³, 6 times less. Most of a cluster's ordinary matter is not in anything anybody would call an object. The two total-mass curves differ by the 15 per cent hydrostatic bias: some of the pressure holding the gas up is turbulence left from the last merger rather than heat, and a mass computed from the thermal pressure alone is low by about that — the assumption that makes the measurement possible is the one that biases it. With the correction, the baryons come to 15 per cent of the total, against the 15.7 per cent the microwave background gives for the universe as a whole. A cluster is large enough to have kept everything it started with, so its own accounting is a cosmological measurement. Below: the same gas seen two ways. X-ray surface brightness falls as (1+z)⁻⁴, so a cluster at redshift one is 16 times fainter per unit sky than the same cluster nearby; the Sunyaev–Zel'dovich distortion of the microwave background does not fall at all, because it is a fraction of a background whose own brightness rises by exactly the same factor. That is why a millimetre survey finds clusters at any distance and an X-ray survey finds the near ones.

The baryons that are not in the galaxies

The stars in a cluster are about a seventh of its ordinary matter. The rest is ten-million-kelvin gas that is invisible optically and dominant in X-rays — and weighing it with hydrostatic equilibrium biases the answer low by exactly the amount the assumption is wrong by.

galaxies · Clusters The middle of a cluster cools faster than the universe ages. The time the gas of a cool-core cluster, of central electron density 0.05 per cubic centimetre, would take to radiate its heat at constant pressure, against radius, both logarithmic. Inside 76 kiloparsecs it is less than 7.7 billion years, the time since a redshift of about one when the cluster's core is thought to have settled, and at 10 kiloparsecs it is 0.8 billion years. Beyond a few hundred kiloparsecs it is longer than the age of the universe, and the gas is simply hot.

A cooling flow that never arrives

The gas at the centre of a rich cluster radiates its heat in under a billion years, so it should be sinking inward and turning into stars at hundreds of solar masses a year. For two decades that was the accepted picture and it was treated as a measurement. Then X-ray spectra looked for the gas on its way down and found that it stops at a third of the temperature it began with, while the galaxy in the middle forms stars a hundred times too slowly. Something pays the radiative bill, and bubbles of the right size are visible in the X-ray images.

galaxies · Clusters

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

BremsstrahlungIntracluster mediumAGN feedbackBaryon fractionBeta modelCluster mass functionCool-coreCooling timeGas fractionHydrostatic biasRadio bubbleThe Sunyaev–Zel'dovich effect

All concepts