Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Residual — where it appears

What is left of a measurement once every known term has been subtracted, trustworthy only to the accuracy of the largest thing removed. Neptune was found in one, general relativity was confirmed in one, and every planet detected by radial velocity is one.

Named by 4 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

An impulse delivered inside 0.5 AU, and a comet 2050 hours early. Above: Marsden's outgassing law, the factor g(r) that scales a comet's non-gravitational acceleration, against distance from the Sun over one orbit of a comet with perihelion at 0.336 AU and aphelion at 4.09. It is close to an inverse square inside the water snow line and then falls off a cliff, because water ice that is not being heated does not sublimate. Half the whole revolution's impulse is delivered inside 0.55 AU — a few weeks out of a 3.3-year orbit — so the force is effectively a kick at perihelion rather than a perturbation spread around the path. Below: what a kick of that kind does to the timekeeping. A transverse component changes the semi-major axis and so the period, by 2.5 hours per revolution here, and a constant change in the period accumulates as the square of the number of revolutions rather than in proportion to it. After 40 returns the comet arrives 2050 hours — more than 85.4 days — before an orbit fitted without the term predicts, and doubling the number of returns multiplies the discrepancy by 3.90. That is why the effect was found in the eighteen-twenties from nothing but arrival times, and a century and a half before anyone photographed a jet.

A comet that arrives a day early

Encke's comet returned two and a half hours ahead of prediction, every revolution, for decades before anybody could say what was pushing it. The force is a rocket — a few tonnes a second of vapour leaving the sunward side of a rotating nucleus, delivered almost entirely in the few weeks around perihelion, and it accumulates in the arrival time as the square of the number of returns.

orbits · Non-gravitational forces Mercury's perihelion, term by term. The observed advance of Mercury's perihelion is 5600 arcseconds per century against the equinox. Almost all of it is the equinox: the coordinate frame itself turns, and removing it leaves 574. Subtracting the perturbations of the other planets — computed by Le Verrier in 1859 and refined many times since — leaves 42.98 arcseconds a century that nothing in Newtonian gravitation accounts for. The bars are logarithmic in nothing; they are the real proportions, which is why the residual is barely visible beside the frame term.

Forty-three arcseconds, after everything else

Mercury's perihelion moves through 5,600 arcseconds a century. Nearly all of that is the coordinate system turning, and almost all of the rest is the other planets. What was left over was 43 — under one per cent of the raw number, and the most consequential residual in the history of the subject.

gravitation · Relativistic orbits PSR B1913+16: 45 years of periastron arriving 88 seconds early. The cumulative shift of periastron passage for PSR B1913+16, Δt = ½(Ṗ_b/P_b)T², over 45 years from its discovery in 1975. The orbital period is 0.322997449 days and is measured to be shortening at 2.423e-12 seconds per second — a change in the twelfth decimal place, which over a career accumulates to 87.5 seconds. That is the whole reason the effect is measurable. Ṗ_b is taken here as a measured quantity and no radiated power is derived from it; the parabola is the general-relativistic prediction as published, and the points are that prediction scaled by the published ratio of observed to predicted decay, 0.997 ± 0.002 (Hulse & Taylor 1975; Weisberg & Huckins 2016), which is how the agreement is quoted. The error bars are drawn: at the last point the bar is 1.25 px tall against a dot 9 pixels across, so they are invisible, and their invisibility is the result. The campaign has run 45 years.

An orbit measured to be shrinking

A 7.75-hour orbital period that shortens by 68 nanoseconds each turn is beyond any single measurement, and unmissable after fifty thousand of them, because the shift accumulates as the square of the elapsed time. Forty-five years of pulse arrival times have made it 87.5 seconds, which is why the rate is a measured quantity rather than an inferred one.

gravitation · Relativistic orbits Four known pieces of hardware, and the anomaly is the sum of them. The reported anomalous acceleration of a deep-space probe, in units of 10⁻¹⁰ metres per second squared, built up from the heat the spacecraft was known to be radiating. The generators put out about two and a half kilowatts of waste heat and sit on booms beside a large dish that reflects a share of it backwards, which is 62 per cent of the total on its own; the instrument compartment radiates through louvres on one face; the radio transmitter beams eight watts at the Earth, which is a torch pointing the wrong way. Sunlight is negligible this far out and is drawn to show that it is. The four sum to 8.65 against a measured 8.74 ± 1.33, and the agreement is the answer. What makes the episode worth keeping is that none of these numbers was discovered later: every one was in the spacecraft's own thermal documentation from before launch, and the model that produced the anomaly was a model of a point mass.

An acceleration that was the spacecraft's own heat

Two probes leaving the solar system were tracked for thirty years and both drifted from their predicted paths by a tenth of a nanometre per second squared. The residual was real, it was constant, and it was the same on both. It was also the waste heat of the reactors that powered them, radiating slightly more one way than the other.

orbits · Non-gravitational forces

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Apsidal precessionBinary pulsarEccentricityGeneral relativityNon-gravitational accelerationAnisotropic emissionBarycentreComet nucleusDoppler trackingEffective potentialGauss planetary equationsInverse square law

All concepts