Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Stellar evolution — where it appears

The sequence of structures a star passes through as its fuel changes, and the models that predict a radius and a luminosity from mass, composition and age. Its predictions are calibrated against eclipsing binaries and against star clusters, which are the only populations supplying a mass or an age independently.

Named by 9 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Two radial-velocity curves, and one mass ratio. The line-of-sight velocity of each star through one orbit of AI Phoenicis. Both curves are computed from the two masses and the period; what a spectrograph delivers is the reverse. The ratio of the amplitudes is the inverse ratio of the masses — 48.2 to 50.3 kilometres a second, so the heavier star moves more slowly — and the sum of the amplitudes with the period gives the mass sum, 2.437 solar masses, once the inclination is known from the eclipses.

The only stars whose masses are known

A star's mass cannot be measured by looking at it. It can be measured by watching two stars pull on each other, and if the pair also eclipses, the same observations give both radii as well — with no stellar model anywhere in the chain. A few hundred such systems calibrate everything else.

stars · Binary stars A furnace with the thermostat taken out. Left, the two pressures in a red giant's helium core at 10⁶ g/cm³. The ideal-gas pressure rises with temperature, as the whole regulation of a star depends on it doing; the degenerate electron pressure is a horizontal line, because the exclusion principle does not know the temperature. At the ignition point near 10⁸ K the degenerate term is 5.1 times the gas term, so a temperature rise there raises the total pressure by almost nothing and the core does not expand. Right, what that costs. Both curves start at the same temperature with the same triple-alpha rate, whose logarithmic slope is 41 — the famous T⁴⁰, differentiated here rather than quoted. The regulated core settles; the degenerate one, with nowhere to put the extra energy, goes vertical. The flash reaches 10¹⁰ solar luminosities for a few seconds and not one photon of it is seen: every erg goes into lifting the degeneracy, and the star's visible response is to become fainter and settle on the horizontal branch.

The resonance that had to exist

Three alpha particles cannot meet at once, and the two-body intermediate falls apart in 8×10⁻¹⁷ seconds. That is a hundred thousand times longer than a crossing time, which is just enough — provided a nuclear level sits at 7.65 MeV. Hoyle argued from the existence of carbon to the existence of the level, and it was found where he said.

stars · Fusion From 1.667 to 1.343, and the limit is in the second number. The local slope Γ = d ln P / d ln ρ of the exact degenerate electron equation of state, against density, differentiated numerically from the drawn pressure rather than quoted. It is 1.6666 at 10⁴ kg/m³ — the 5/3 of a non-relativistic Fermi gas — and 1.3430 at 10¹² — the 4/3 of a relativistic one — falling monotonically between, and passing 1.5 at 3.63·10⁹ kg/m³. Nothing gives way at either end; the electrons simply run out of room to go faster, because they are already near c. The mass limit is in the exponent and not in the strength. Hydrostatic balance for a polytrope of index Γ gives M ∝ ρ_c^(3Γ−4)/2, so at Γ = 4/3 the exponent is zero: the mass no longer depends on the central density at all, and there is exactly one mass a fully relativistic degenerate star can have — 1.459 M☉ at μ_e = 2. Above it, squeezing harder buys pressure that rises more slowly than gravity does, and there is nothing left to stop at.

The mass a cold star cannot exceed

A degenerate star's radius falls as its mass rises, and nothing in that relation suggests a limit. Making the electrons relativistic softens the pressure law until pressure and gravity scale the same way with radius — and the radius drops out of the balance, leaving one mass and no room to argue.

stars · Degeneracy Three clusters, three ages, one diagram. Isochrones for populations of 100 Myr, 1 Gyr, 12 Gyr, each drawn as the main sequence up to its own turnoff and then the post-main-sequence track of the turnoff mass. The turnoffs are at 5.52 M☉, 2.20 M☉, 0.94 M☉, from t = 10¹⁰ M/L with this file's own mass–luminosity relation. Nothing here is a track along which a star moves. Every point is a different star of a different mass, all the same age, and the bend is simply where the population runs out of stars that have had time to leave. That is why a cluster has an age and a field star does not: the bend needs a population, and one star is not one. The oldest globular clusters sit near the 12 Gyr line, and in the 1990s the same construction gave them ages of 16 to 18 Gyr against a universe measured at 10 — a two-standard-deviation contradiction that was resolved from the distance side, by Hipparcos, and not from this one.

An age read off a bend

A cluster is a population of one age and many masses, so the place where its stars leave the main sequence is a clock. The bend needs a population — which is why a cluster has an age and a single star does not.

stars · The HR diagram The mirror: an envelope 62 times larger around a core 1.48 times smaller. Envelope radius and core radius against helium-core mass for a 1 solar-mass star, both in solar radii on one logarithmic axis. Two curves with opposite slopes at every point: the envelope grows from 2.0 to 122 solar radii — 0.57 astronomical units — while the degenerate core contracts from 13,848 to 9,368 kilometres, and the two are separated by a factor of 364 in the middle of the range. The figure is drawn from two stated relations rather than from a stellar model: a core-mass–luminosity law of the sixth power, calibrated to 2,500 solar luminosities at 0.48 solar masses of core, and a Hayashi temperature falling from 5000 to 3700 kelvin across the range. Everything else follows exactly — the radius by the Stefan–Boltzmann law, the core radius by the cold degenerate relation R ∝ M⁻¹ᐟ³. Note what the tip radius is and is not: it is the red-giant branch, and the later asymptotic-giant tip is a different and larger number.

The star that swells because its centre shrank

A helium core contracts, and the envelope around it expands by a factor of sixty. The central density rises at the same time as the radius, which is the opposite of what a self-gravitating body is expected to do, and a burning shell between the two is the whole reason it happens.

stars · Stellar evolution 14 radial orders of the Sun, at 135.1 μHz apart. The p-mode spectrum of the Sun — 1 solar mass in 1 solar radius — from the asymptotic relation with its second-order term, drawn as 14 radial orders of ℓ = 0, 1 and 2 under a Gaussian envelope centred on ν_max = 3,090 μHz. Two numbers are marked and they do very different work. The large separation, 135.1 μHz, is the spacing between consecutive ℓ = 0 modes and fixes the mean density. The small separation, 9.00 μHz, is 2.7 pixels on this axis — it fixes the age, and it is why the échelle diagram exists rather than being a convenience. The vertical axis is the measurement: each mode moves the surface by about 20.0 cm s⁻¹ at the peak, and brightens it by a few parts per million, which is why this was impossible before a decade-long velocity series. Each mode is one line: its true width is set by its lifetime and is far below a pixel here.

The interior read from a comb of frequencies

A star's surface moves by about twenty centimetres a second, in thousands of overlapping sound modes at once. Two numbers off that spectrum give a mass and a radius with almost no stellar model in the chain, and a third gives an age.

stars · Asteroseismology The most pressure a core can supply, and what its envelope asks for. The pressure at the boundary of a star's isothermal core, on a logarithmic scale, against the fraction of the star's mass the core holds. The coloured curves are the most pressure a core of that mass can supply at its edge — the maximum of the isothermal sphere, 1.40 c⁸/(G³M²) for a core of mass M — for cores of mean molecular weight 0.6, 1.0, 4/3; the flat grey line is the pressure the envelope, of molecular weight 0.6, exerts on the core at the same temperature. The core's ceiling falls as the square of its mass, and it can hold the envelope up only while it lies above the line. The curves cross it at core fractions of 0.370, 0.133, 0.075: a core of the same molecular weight as its envelope could hold 37 per cent of the star, and a fully ionised helium core, μ = 4/3, under this envelope only 7.5 per cent. The limit exists because the core is heavier per particle than the gas it has to hold up.

A core too heavy for the gas around it

When a star's centre runs out of hydrogen, the helium left behind stops making energy, settles to one temperature, and becomes the one member of the polytrope family with no surface of its own. It can hold up the envelope around it only while it is less than about a tenth of the star. Past that there is no balance to be had, and the star crosses to the giant branch in a few per cent of its lifetime — which is why that part of the diagram is empty.

stars · Polytropes How long a star lives on the main sequence, down to the smallest stars. Main-sequence lifetime against mass, on logarithmic axes, as the hydrogen a star burns divided by its luminosity, scaled so that the Sun lives ten billion years. The dashed line assumes every star burns a tenth of its hydrogen, as the Sun does; the solid line lets stars below about a third of a solar mass, which are convective throughout, burn nearly all of it. The horizontal line is the age of the universe, 13.8 billion years: every star lighter than 0.90 solar masses that has ever formed is still on the main sequence. A star of a tenth of a solar mass lives about 8 trillion years — 597 times the present age of the universe — and its life so far is a few thousandths of one per cent of it.

A lifetime that is still a forecast

No star lighter than nine-tenths of the Sun has ever died, because none has had time. The smallest are convective to their centres, burn almost all their hydrogen rather than a tenth of it, and will shine for trillions of years. Most of the stars in the Galaxy therefore have a life history no observation has tested, and only one in thirteen stars ever born has finished.

stars · Stellar lifetimes The core's neutrino luminosity against its temperature, and the star's light. The luminosity carried off by neutrinos from pair annihilation in a burning core of 3 solar masses, in erg per second on a logarithmic axis, against the core's temperature in billions of kelvin, along a rough track on which the density rises as the cube of the temperature, with each burning stage marked at its own published temperature, density and core mass. The horizontal line is the star's light, about 1.5 × 10⁵ times the Sun's, nearly constant through all the late stages. The neutrino luminosity rises roughly as the ninth power of the temperature and overtakes the light at about 0.60 billion kelvin — between helium and carbon burning. From carbon burning on, carbon 76, neon 3·10⁴, oxygen 10⁵, silicon 7·10⁵ times the light is lost as neutrinos. The core is no longer cooled by the surface it shines through; it is cooled directly, from inside, by particles that leave without interacting.

The last fuels burn for the neutrinos

A massive star burns hydrogen for millions of years and silicon for about a day. The collapse in duration is not because the late fuels are poorer; it is because, from carbon burning on, the core loses more energy to neutrinos than the whole star gives out as light, and the neutrino losses rise as the ninth power of the temperature.

stars · Fusion

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Hydrostatic equilibriumColour magnitude diagramConvectionDegeneracyDegeneracy pressureEclipsing binaryHelium flashThe HR diagramKelvin helmholtz timescaleMain-sequence lifetimePolytropeShell burning

All concepts