Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Visibility function — where it appears

Fringe contrast as a function of aperture separation, and by the same name the chance that a photon last scattered at a given redshift. The two senses share a name and nothing else, and which is meant is settled by whether the argument is a baseline or a redshift.

Named by 6 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Fringe visibility for a 47 mas disc at 575 nm. Fringe visibility against the separation of the two apertures, for a disc 47 milliarcseconds across seen at 575 nm. The solid curve is a uniform disc, |2J₁(x)/x| with x = πθB/λ; it is exactly one at zero baseline, where both apertures see the same wavefront, and falls to zero at 3.08 m — read off the drawn samples, and equal to 1.21967 λ/θ to better than one part in a million. That is the measurement: not a brightness, a baseline. The dashed curve is the same disc with linear limb darkening u = 0.4, whose null is 4.9% further out at 3.23 m — so the same observed null implies 47 mas as a uniform disc and 49.3 mas limb-darkened, and a diameter quoted without its model is a number without a unit. At the 2.54 m aperture of the telescope this was done on, the visibility is still 0.17: one mirror cannot reach the null, which is the same statement as saying it cannot resolve the star.

An angle of five hundredths of an arcsecond

No telescope has ever resolved a star other than the Sun, and stellar diameters are measured anyway — by finding the separation of two apertures at which the star's interference fringes vanish. What that returns is an angle; the radius arrives only when a distance is brought in, and the distance is the worse-known half.

starlight · Angular diameter One ionising photon per atom, and where that happens. The number of photons energetic enough to ionise hydrogen, per baryon, against temperature — with temperature falling to the right, so the universe ages to the right. The quantity is the fraction of a Planck distribution above 13.6 eV, integrated numerically, divided by the 6.13·10⁻¹⁰ baryons there are per photon. It crosses one at 5,844 K, which is z = 2143, and it falls by 19 orders of magnitude across the plot because it is the tail of an exponential. That crossing is the answer to why recombination waits until three thousand kelvin. At hydrogen's own ionisation temperature of 157,803 K there are two billion ionising photons per atom and the gas has no chance; the temperature has to fall by a factor of forty before the supply runs out, and it runs out suddenly because an exponential tail does. The number that sets the factor of forty is not an energy at all — it is the photon-to-baryon ratio, which is to say the entropy per baryon, which is to say a number fixed long before any of this and measured today from the second acoustic peak and from deuterium alike.

The surface the background actually is

Hydrogen ionises at 157,800 kelvin and the universe became transparent at 3,000. The factor of fifty between them is not an error, and it is not about energy — it is about there being two billion photons for every atom, so the far tail of the distribution can keep the gas ionised long after the typical photon has become useless.

cosmology · Microwave background The damping tail measures a thickness: ℓ_D = 1400 for a shell 80 deep in redshift. The suppression of small-scale structure in the microwave background, against multipole, on logarithmic axes. Every other feature of the power spectrum measures the last-scattering surface as a surface — its distance, the sound horizon written on it, the ruler it provides. This one measures how thick it is. Recombination takes time: the ionised fraction falls over a range of redshift rather than all at once, and while it is falling the photons are still scattering, so each one random-walks. A photon taking N steps of a mean free path λ diffuses √N λ, which is much further than a single step and much less than the whole interval, and any temperature fluctuation smaller than that distance is mixed away before it can be frozen in. What is left is a Gaussian cut-off, drawn here for three shell thicknesses. A thicker shell means more steps and a longer walk, so it damps at a smaller multipole: Δz = 40 gives ℓ_D = 1980, Δz = 80 gives ℓ_D = 1400, Δz = 160 gives ℓ_D = 990. The observed cut-off is near ℓ = 1400, corresponding to a diffusion length of about 0.03 proper megaparsecs at the time — a scale the reader should compare with the sound horizon, some hundred and fifty comoving megaparsecs, which is what the peaks measure. The tail is therefore a genuine probe of the inside of the transition rather than of its position, and because the damping depends on the free-electron density it is also one of the cleanest constraints on anything that changes it: extra relativistic species, a varying fine-structure constant, or an early energy injection all move ℓ_D while leaving the peak positions nearly alone. The normalisation here is set once by the observed value, so what the figure claims is the scaling with thickness and the shape of the cut-off, not the absolute number.

A blur that measures a depth

Every other feature of the microwave background measures the last-scattering surface as a surface — its distance, the ruler written on it, the geometry between. The damping of its small-scale structure measures how thick it is, because a photon random-walking through a finite transition smears away anything smaller than its walk.

cosmology · Microwave background A few per cent of diameter, hidden in the second lobe. Visibility against baseline in the natural variable πθB/λ, for stars with linear limb-darkening coefficients of 0, 0.3, 0.6, 0.9, each rescaled to the uniform disc that best fits its own first lobe. In the first lobe the four curves are within 0.72 per cent of one another; past the first null they differ by up to 4.2 per cent. That is the whole difficulty of measuring a stellar diameter. A limb-darkened star has a faint edge, so a uniform-disc fit returns a diameter 9.7 per cent too small at u = 0.9 and 2.5 per cent too small at u = 0.3 — and the information needed to tell which is in a region where the visibility is under five per cent and the calibration errors of a real interferometer are comparable to the signal. The correction from what is measured to what is wanted is taken from a model atmosphere, because the observation that would supply it is the hardest one there is. The fit here is done by least squares on the drawn curves rather than read from a conversion table, and the zero-coefficient case returns the uniform disc to 0.00 per cent, which is the fit checking itself.

A diameter that depends on a model atmosphere

An interferometer measures fringe visibilities and somebody fits a disc. A uniform disc and a limb-darkened one agree to within a per cent across the whole of the first lobe and differ by five in the second — where the visibility is under five per cent and the calibration errors are the same size.

starlight · Angular diameter A clumped plasma recombines earlier. The fraction of hydrogen still ionised against redshift, decreasing to the right, on a logarithmic axis, from Peebles's three-level atom: for a smooth plasma (solid), and for one whose baryons are clumped into two equal volumes at 1.71 and 0.29 times the mean density, a clumping factor of 0.5 (thick dashed, averaged by mass; thin dashed, each zone alone). Recombination goes as the density squared, so the dense zone recombines first and carries most of the mass; the average ionisation falls through one half at redshift 1292 instead of 1273, and at redshift 1100 it is 0.123 against 0.145. The photons cannot see the individual patches, which are smaller than their mean free path; they see only the average, and the average recombines earlier.

A field that would have moved the ruler

A magnetic field left over from the early universe, too weak to matter to any galaxy, could still have pushed the baryons into small clumps before the universe became transparent. Clumped hydrogen recombines earlier, the sound waves in the plasma stop sooner, and the ruler that the microwave background is read with comes out shorter — which raises the Hubble constant the background implies, in the direction of the disagreement that has resisted every other explanation.

cosmology · Primordial fields The polarisation peaks sit in the temperature troughs. A tight-coupling sketch of the two acoustic sources against multipole, each scaled to its own maximum: the temperature, from the compression of the photon–baryon fluid at last scattering plus its Doppler term, and the E-mode polarisation, which is driven by the fluid's velocity gradient. The sound horizon and the distance to last scattering put the acoustic scale at ℓ = 302, the measured phase of the peaks is 0.267 and the damping scale is ℓ = 1400; the baryons' weight, which changes the heights of the temperature peaks and not their places, is left out. The temperature peaks fall at ℓ ≈ 218, 515, 813, 1110, 1408; the polarisation peaks at ℓ ≈ 130, 391, 681, 975, 1272, between them, because a compression is at its extreme when the fluid is momentarily still, and the velocity is largest a quarter of a cycle later. The model has no projection, no decaying potentials and no thickness, so it places the peaks and says nothing about their shapes.

Polarised only where the glow was lopsided

An electron bathed in light from every side scatters it unpolarised, and so does one bathed in light brighter on one side. Only a glow brighter along one axis than across it leaves a polarisation behind, and in the microwave background that glow existed for a short time, in a thin part of a thin shell, because the plasma was moving.

cosmology · Microwave background

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

RecombinationThomson scatteringAcoustic peaksAngular diameterEffective temperatureLast scattering surfaceLimb darkeningMean free pathOptical depthReionisationSilk dampingSound horizon

All concepts