Generator

The induction generator

The field a collapse would arrive with, and the one it has

Field strength against hydrogen density, both logarithmic, over the eight decades between diffuse gas and a protostellar core. The steeper line is what perfect flux freezing demands: a sphere collapsing conserves both mass and flux, so B goes as R⁻² while ρ goes as R⁻³, and therefore B goes as the two-thirds power of the density exactly — an exponent with no free parameter in it. The shallower locus is what Zeeman measurements find: a flat branch at about 10 µG up to 300 per cubic centimetre, where the density is rising and the field is not, and a rise as the 0.65 power of the density above it. By the density of a core the two differ by a factor of 1, and a star built at the frozen-flux value would carry a field four orders of magnitude beyond anything measured on one. The flat branch is the important half: it says the gas is moving along field lines without dragging them, which is what gravity does to a cloud that is still magnetically supported, and it locates where the freezing has to break.

13 essays call induction. The drawing above is what it returns with no arguments at all; every call below passes it something, because a placement that passes nothing draws whichever member of the family the generator happens to default to rather than the one its essay argues about.

Where it is called

Every figure listed here is the same construction drawn at different numbers, so a correction to one is a correction to all of them.

A field that would have arrived ten thousand times too strong

A collapsing cloud carries its magnetic field with it, and the arithmetic of that is not negotiable — the field grows as the two-thirds power of the density. Run it from a diffuse cloud to a protostellar core and the answer is four orders of magnitude above anything measured on a young star.

The energy at which the sky begins to point. Gyroradius against energy for a singly charged particle, in three field strengths, with the thickness of the galactic disc and the size of its halo marked. A cosmic ray is not an image of anything: its path is a helix about a field line, and by the time it arrives the direction it came from has been erased. The erasure is quantitative. At 3 µG a proton's gyroradius equals the disc's half-thickness at 4.2·10¹⁷ electronvolts and the halo's radius at 4.2·10¹⁹, so below the first the particle is stored and stirred for tens of millions of years, and only above the second does it travel in something like a straight line. The measured spectrum has a break — the knee — at about 3×10¹⁵ eV, which is within a factor of a few of the first of those; the sky only starts showing structure above 10¹⁹, which is the second. Two features of a spectrum measured on the ground, both located by one straight line on this plot.

The energy at which a sky begins to point

A cosmic ray arrives from a direction that has nothing to do with where it came from. Its path is a helix about a galactic field line, and only above the energy at which that helix is bigger than the galaxy does the arrival direction start to mean anything — which is one particle per square kilometre per century.

Thirty e-foldings erase the memory of a seed. Field strength against time for three seed fields 8 orders of magnitude apart, amplified at one e-folding every 3·10⁸ years — a galactic dynamo's measured turnover rate — and stopped at the 3·10⁻⁶ gauss the disc actually has. In 10 billion years the budget is 33 e-foldings, which is a factor of 3·10¹⁴. That is the finding: the three tracks reach the same ceiling within 5.5 billion years of one another, so the field a galaxy has today carries essentially no information about the field it started with. Any seed above about 10⁻²⁰ gauss will do, and mechanisms that produce far less than that are the only ones ruled out. The measurement that does constrain a seed has to be made where no dynamo ever ran, which means the voids between clusters — and the limit there comes from gamma rays that never arrived.

The seed that cannot be remembered

A galactic dynamo affords something like thirty e-foldings over the age of a galaxy, which multiplies any seed field above a ten-thousandth of a billionth of a microgauss up to the microgauss actually observed. The field a galaxy has today therefore says nothing about the field it started with, and the only place a seed survives unamplified is the emptiness between clusters.

The observed sky

The flare that arrives from somewhere else

The solar wind blows radially outward and the Sun rotates, so the field frozen into the wind is wound into a spiral making forty-five degrees to the radius at the Earth. Energetic particles follow the field rather than the line of sight, which is why the flares that deliver particle storms are the ones on the western limb rather than the ones facing the planet.

The same flux in three sizes

A few per cent of hot main-sequence stars carry kilogauss fields that do not change over decades. So do a similar share of white dwarfs, at a million times the strength, and of young neutron stars, at a hundred billion times it. Multiply each field by its star's area and the three classes carry nearly the same magnetic flux — what a field frozen into a star would keep as the star shrank by a factor of a hundred thousand. A collapse makes a field enormous, but it cannot make it important.

How far a void field turns the leptons that make each cascade photon. The deflection angle of a cascade lepton over its cooling length, in radians on a logarithmic scale, against the energy of the cascade photon it produces, for fields of 10⁻¹⁸ G, 10⁻¹⁷ G, 10⁻¹⁶ G, 10⁻¹⁵ G, 10⁻¹⁴ G coherent over at least that length. The angle falls as the square of the lepton energy, so as the inverse of the photon energy: the gigaelectronvolt halo is made by the slowest leptons, which are turned most. At 1 GeV the deflections are 1e-3, 0.01, 0.11, 1.06, 10.62 rad. The dashed line is the jet's half-opening angle, 0.1 rad; a lepton turned further than that sends its photons away from the observer, and the halo at that energy disappears.

A lower limit made of three lengths and a missing echo

The only measurement of a magnetic field in the empty space between galaxies is a lower limit, and it comes from light that did not arrive. Teraelectronvolt gamma rays from distant blazars make electron pairs in intergalactic space, the pairs should re-emit the energy at gigaelectronvolts in a halo around each source, and the halos are missing. Whether that absence weighs a field of a ten-thousandth of a billionth of a microgauss depends on three lengths, the field's own tangle, and how long the blazar has been shining.

The intergalactic temperature against density, with and without blazar heating. The temperature of the intergalactic gas against its density relative to the cosmic mean, both logarithmic, near a redshift of two. Photoheating by the ultraviolet background alone (dashed) gives a power law with denser gas hotter, T = 12,000 K at mean density rising as the density to the 0.6. Heating by the pair beams of distant blazars, if they lose their energy to the plasma rather than to scattering, is deposited per unit volume, so each particle in a void gets more of it: adding increments of 3,000, 10,000, 30,000 K at mean density turns the relation over below densities of 0.58, 1.23, 2.44 times the mean, and the emptiest gas becomes the hottest. That inversion is what a void heated from the inside looks like, and it would happen whether or not the void holds a magnetic field.

A void heated from the inside

The missing gamma-ray halos around distant blazars are read as a magnetic field in the voids — unless the electron–positron pairs that should make the halos lose their energy to the plasma first. Then the voids are being heated, the heat goes preferentially to the emptiest gas, and the intergalactic medium's temperature–density relation turns over, with the voids hotter than the filaments. The field and the heating predict different skies, and the Lyman-α forest is where they part.

The anisotropy each slope of escape predicts. The dipole anisotropy of cosmic rays diffusing out of a halo 4 kpc high, 3D/(cH), against energy, for diffusion slopes of ⅓, 0.5, 0.6, each normalised to the boron-to-carbon grammage at 10 GV — so all three agree at low energy and part above it. The shaded box is the range of dipole amplitudes measured between 1 and 100 TeV, a few parts in ten thousand to about a part in a thousand. At 10 TeV the three predict 0.0043, 0.014, 0.027: the slope that would let shocks inject an index of two overshoots the measurement by 27 times, and even Kolmogorov's ⅓ by 4. The normalisation of the prediction is uncertain by a factor of a few, through the arrangement of the sources and the shape of the halo; its rise with energy is not, because it is the same slope that the spectrum and the secondary ratio require.

One slope read twice, and the reading that disagrees

How fast cosmic rays leak out of the Galaxy depends on their energy through a single power, and that power is measured twice: in the falling ratio of boron to carbon, and in how unevenly the particles arrive across the sky. The first reading says one-third. The second, taken at face value, says the leak must be slower still — and neither leaves room for the spectrum shock acceleration predicts.

How far an electron can have come, by its energy. The distance an electron or positron can diffuse in its radiative lifetime, 2√(∫D dt), against its energy, for the diffusion coefficient fitted to the nuclei with slopes ⅓ and 0.6, and 1 eV/cm³ of field and radiation. At 100 GeV the horizon is 2.7 or 4.7 kpc; at 1 TeV, 1.24 or 2.95; at 10 TeV, 0.57 or 1.86. The marks are the distances to the nearest middle-aged pulsars and to the Galactic centre. Above a teraelectronvolt the electrons and positrons arriving at the Earth were made within about a kiloparsec — inside the Sun's own neighbourhood of the disc — and a feature in their spectrum is a feature of a handful of nearby sources, not of the Galaxy.

A positron that cannot have come far

A proton at a teraelectronvolt can wander the Galaxy for millions of years. An electron or a positron at the same energy radiates its energy away in a few hundred thousand, and in that time it can diffuse about a kiloparsec. So the rising fraction of positrons among high-energy cosmic rays is not a fact about the Galaxy. It is a fact about a few objects within a thousand parsecs of the Sun.

$The share of white dwarfs whose centres have begun to freeze. The fraction of a population of carbon–oxygen white dwarfs, with masses spread as a Gaussian of mean 0.62 and width 0.12 M☉, whose centres have begun to crystallise, against cooling age, overall and in three mass ranges, in the toy model of the other figures. If a field appears when freezing begins, this is the shape its incidence must take: it switches on first among the heaviest white dwarfs, half of which have begun freezing by 0.5 Gyr, and last among the typical ones near 0.6 M☉, by 2.5 Gyr. A fossil field, present from the white dwarf's birth, would show no such delay and no such ordering by mass.$ Stars

A field that waits for the core to freeze

A field inherited from the parent star would be present from a white dwarf's birth. Yet magnetic white dwarfs of ordinary mass are rare among the young and common among the old, as if their fields were switched on later. The proposed switch is the freezing of the carbon–oxygen core, which stirs the liquid above it. If that is right, the delay is set by when each mass begins to freeze, and the heaviest should go first.

The echo of a one-day flare, for four void fields. The 1–10 GeV flux of the cascade echo against the time since the start of a one-day teraelectronvolt flare of 10 Crab-days, from a blazar 500 Mpc away, both on logarithmic scales, for void fields of 10⁻²¹ G, 10⁻²⁰ G, 10⁻¹⁹ G, 3 × 10⁻¹⁹ G. The echo carries 1.0 × 10⁻⁴ erg cm⁻² in the band whatever the field — the field decides only when it arrives, and so how thinly it is spread. Half of it has arrived 14 hours after the flare began in the weakest field and 4.1 years in the strongest, and the flux at that moment falls from 1.1 × 10⁻⁹ to 1.3 × 10⁻¹³ erg cm⁻² s⁻¹. The dashed curve is the flux a space telescope needs to detect a source averaged over that long, falling as the square root of the time to a floor of 10⁻¹² erg cm⁻² s⁻¹. Counting only what arrives after the flare has ended, three of the four echoes clear it.

An echo heard only from the weakest fields

A missing gamma-ray halo gives the field in the voids a lower limit and nothing more. A flare's echo could give it a value — the gigaelectronvolt light that arrives late because the void field bent its path. But the echo carries a fixed amount of energy and the field decides only how long it is spread over, so it can be heard only from fields weak enough to deliver it quickly, and only after flares brighter than almost any yet seen from a blazar far enough away to make one.

An electroweak field decays toward one line, and helicity decides where it meets it. The comoving strength of a magnetic field against its coherence length, both on logarithmic scales. A field made at the electroweak transition, at 100 GeV, starts on a hundredth of the Hubble length then (1 AU today) with a tenth of the radiation's energy density (1 × 10⁻⁶ G), and decays as its turbulence is processed until the largest eddy is the one an Alfvén wave can cross by recombination — the straight line, 10⁻⁸ G at 1 Mpc. With no net helicity it falls as λ^−5/2 and stops at 0.038 pc and 4 × 10⁻¹⁶ G. Maximally helical, it falls only as λ^−½ and stops at 4.7 kpc and 5 × 10⁻¹¹ G. The shaded floor is what the missing gamma-ray halos exclude: a field coherent over more than a megaparsec must exceed 9 × 10⁻¹⁷ G, and the bound rises as the inverse square root of the coherence length below the leptons' cooling length of 0.6 Mpc. The non-helical field ends 3.0 decades below it; the helical one 4.6 decades above it. Above 10⁻⁹ G at a megaparsec the microwave background excludes the field.

A twist that decides where the field ends

A magnetic field made in the first trillionth of a second starts strong and absurdly small, and its turbulence spends the next three hundred thousand years trading strength for size. How far it gets depends on one conserved quantity — how twisted its field lines are — and for a field made at the electroweak transition, that twist is the difference between failing the void bound by three decades and clearing it by five.

A sightline through the web, and where its field would be. The density of matter along a 300-megaparsec sightline through a model cosmic web, relative to the mean, on a logarithmic scale: a lognormal field whose logarithm has a width of 1.2. Galaxies sit at the 8 density peaks above the mean, and each has blown a magnetised bubble 1.4 Mpc in radius (shaded columns). Together they cover 7% of the sightline. The dots along the bottom are where 60 teraelectronvolt photons, stopped at random along the path, made their pairs: a photon stops where it stops, regardless of what is there, so the pairs fall on the empty stretches as often as on the crowded ones. Four of the 60 are made inside a bubble and are turned by its field. The other 56 are made in unmagnetised space, and their light forms a halo at full strength whatever the bubbles hold.

A field the galaxies cannot spread far enough

The missing gamma-ray halos are read as a field older than the galaxies because the galaxies seem unable to have put one there. The reason is not strength. A galaxy's wind carries a field that, spread over a megaparsec, is still ten million times stronger than the halos require. What it cannot do is reach the empty volume where most of the pairs are made — and a halo is dimmed only by the share of space the field fills.

The whole library · All essays