Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Generator

The resonance-gaps generator

The Kirkwood gaps
The Kirkwood gaps. Asteroid numbers against semi-major axis, with the resonant radii marked. Each gap sits where the orbital period is a simple fraction of Jupiter's, and each of those radii is computed from the harmonic law rather than placed by eye.

Asteroid numbers against semi-major axis, with the resonant radii marked. Each gap sits where the orbital period is a simple fraction of Jupiter's, and each of those radii is computed from the harmonic law rather than placed by eye.

4 essays call resonance-gaps. The drawing above is what it returns with no arguments at all; every call below passes it something, because a placement that passes nothing draws whichever member of the family the generator happens to default to rather than the one its essay argues about.

Where it is called

Every figure listed here is the same construction drawn at different numbers, so a correction to one is a correction to all of them.

The osculating semi-major axis of a perturbed orbit. The semi-major axis a test particle would have if the perturber vanished, computed from its position and velocity at every step of an integration over 26 orbits of the perturber. It is not constant: a short-period ripple rides on a slow trend, and only the trend accumulates. Orbits

Elements that do not stay constant

Six numbers fix an orbit for all time, and the phrase is only true in a universe containing two bodies. Add a third and the six start moving — some of them wandering and returning, one or two of them drifting in one direction forever, and the difference between those two behaviours is the whole of celestial mechanics after Newton.

 The Kirkwood gaps. Asteroid numbers against semi-major axis, with the resonant radii marked. Each gap sits where the orbital period is a simple fraction of Jupiter's, and each of those radii is computed from the harmonic law rather than placed by eye. Gravitation

Resonance clears a gap in one place and locks a moon in another

When two orbital periods are in a simple ratio, small tugs stop averaging away and start accumulating. Sometimes that empties a region entirely. Sometimes it holds three moons together for the age of the solar system.

 Three orders of magnitude in astronomical units, and a factor of 9.6 in mutual Hill radii. Every adjacent pair of planets in three systems, plotted by the separation between them measured in their own mutual Hill radius, ((m₁+m₂)/3M⋆)^⅓ · (a₁+a₂)/2. In astronomical units the same 17 separations span a factor of 2554 — from 0.0043 AU between two TRAPPIST-1 planets to 10.9 between Uranus and Neptune — and carry no visible structure at all. In this unit they span 9.6, with a median of 11.8. The solid line at 2√3 = 3.46 is a theorem: two planets on circular coplanar orbits wider apart than that can never have a close encounter, whatever else happens, and every pair here is clear of it. The dashed line at 10 is a fit, to integrations of systems of several planets over billions of years, and it is the one that bites — a system packed tighter than about ten does not survive, which is why the observed distribution has a floor there and not at the theorem. A planetary system's spacing is not measured in kilometres. It is measured in a unit the planets define. Gravitation

A feeding zone, and the spacing it forces

The radius that decides what a planet may keep also decides what it could reach while it was growing — and measuring the gaps between planets in that unit turns a distribution spanning three orders of magnitude in astronomical units into a band a factor of ten wide, with a floor that is partly a theorem and partly a fit.

 A circular orbit has one lock, and an eccentric one has several. The strength of each spin–orbit resonance against orbital eccentricity, as the Hansen coefficient H(p, e) that multiplies the restoring torque on a permanently non-spherical body. At zero eccentricity every curve but the synchronous one is exactly zero — the figure checks that rather than showing it — so a body on a circular orbit can lock only by turning once per orbit. Away from zero the others switch on: at Mercury's eccentricity of 0.2056 the 3:2 resonance has 73 per cent of the synchronous one's strength and more than twice the 2:1's. A planet spinning down through this family therefore meets the 3:2 before the 1:1 and has a real chance of being caught there, which is what happened — Mercury turns three times for every two orbits, a fact discovered by radar in 1965 after a century of assuming it was locked. The free libration of that locked state follows from the same coefficient and the measured 2.03e-4 for (B − A)/C: 12.1 years, against a measured period near twelve. What the figure cannot show is the capture probability itself, which depends on how the tide dissipates and ranges from a few per cent for a simple constant-lag tide to more than half once friction between a liquid core and the mantle is included. Gravitation

A rotation locked to the orbit, but not one to one

Mercury turns exactly three times for every two circuits of the Sun. That was not what anybody expected, and it is not an accident — on a circular orbit a tidally despun body has exactly one place to lock, and on an eccentric one it has several — with the strength of each set by a coefficient that vanishes when the eccentricity does.

The whole library · All essays