Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Generator

The surface-brightness generator

What distance does, and does not, do to a galaxy
What distance does, and does not, do to a galaxy. Three quantities against distance, each relative to its value at 5 Mpc, on logarithmic axes so that a power law is a straight line and its exponent is the slope. Flux falls with slope −2 and angular size with slope −1, both of which are ordinary. Their ratio has slope zero: a galaxy of surface brightness 23.5 magnitudes per square arcsecond has that surface brightness at every distance, and a sky of 22 is brighter than it at every distance too. The contrast against the sky — the quantity that decides whether the thing is detectable at all — is -1.5 magnitudes wherever it is put.

Three quantities against distance, each relative to its value at 5 Mpc, on logarithmic axes so that a power law is a straight line and its exponent is the slope. Flux falls with slope −2 and angular size with slope −1, both of which are ordinary. Their ratio has slope zero: a galaxy of surface brightness 23.5 magnitudes per square arcsecond has that surface brightness at every distance, and a sky of 22 is brighter than it at every distance too. The contrast against the sky — the quantity that decides whether the thing is detectable at all — is -1.5 magnitudes wherever it is put.

4 essays call surface-brightness. The drawing above is what it returns with no arguments at all; every call below passes it something, because a placement that passes nothing draws whichever member of the family the generator happens to default to rather than the one its essay argues about.

Where it is called

Every figure listed here is the same construction drawn at different numbers, so a correction to one is a correction to all of them.

What distance does, and does not, do to a galaxy. Three quantities against distance, each relative to its value at 5 Mpc, on logarithmic axes so that a power law is a straight line and its exponent is the slope. Flux falls with slope −2 and angular size with slope −1, both of which are ordinary. Their ratio has slope zero: a galaxy of surface brightness 23.5 magnitudes per square arcsecond has that surface brightness at every distance, and a sky of 22 is brighter than it at every distance too. The contrast against the sky — the quantity that decides whether the thing is detectable at all — is -1.5 magnitudes wherever it is put. Galaxies

The brightness distance cannot touch

Flux falls as the inverse square of distance and so does solid angle, so their ratio does not fall at all. A galaxy's surface brightness is the same number wherever it is put, which means whole populations can be undetectable at any distance whatever.

 A sky wrong by a thousandth, and the disc that ends or does not. The surface-brightness profile of an exponential disc with a central surface brightness of 21.65 magnitudes per square arcsecond, against radius in units of its scale length, drawn straight — a pure exponential is a straight line in magnitudes — and then as it would be measured after subtracting a sky of 21.5 magnitudes per square arcsecond wrong by +0.1%, −0.1%, +0.3%, −0.3%. A sky left in bends the profile up into a shallower outer part, the shape called an anti-truncation; a sky taken out too hard bends it down into a break and then drops it out of existence where the residual goes negative. The +0.1% error departs by 0.2 magnitudes at 5.2 scale lengths, 27.3 magnitudes per square arcsecond; The −0.1% error departs by 0.2 magnitudes at 5.0 scale lengths, 27.1 magnitudes per square arcsecond; The +0.3% error departs by 0.2 magnitudes at 4.1 scale lengths, 26.1 magnitudes per square arcsecond; The −0.3% error departs by 0.2 magnitudes at 3.9 scale lengths, 25.9 magnitudes per square arcsecond. Real discs are observed to break both ways, at 24 to 27 magnitudes; every one of those breaks lies in the range where a sky error of a few tenths of a per cent would make one. Galaxies

Where the sky is the measurement

The outskirts of a galaxy at 29 or 30 magnitudes per square arcsecond are a thousand times fainter than the night sky they are seen through. Photon noise averages down with exposure; an error in the sky subtracted from under them does not. A sky wrong by a tenth of a per cent draws a break into a disc that has none, or a halo around a galaxy that has none, and the telescope's own scattered light draws another.

 The same disc measured smaller at every redshift. The isophotal radius, at a limit of 26.5 magnitudes per square arcsecond, of three exponential discs that do not change at all — central surface brightnesses 20.5, 21.65, 23, the same scale length throughout — against the redshift they are placed at. Surface brightness falls as (1+z)⁴, three magnitudes at z = 1 and six at z = 3, before anything about the galaxy evolves or any band shift is accounted for, so every isophote moves inward. The discs vanish from an isophotal catalogue entirely at z = 2.98, 2.05, 1.24. The dashed line is the half-light radius, 1.68 scale lengths, which is defined by the galaxy's own light and does not move. Galaxies at high redshift are genuinely smaller than their present-day counterparts; how much smaller depends on which of these two kinds of radius is quoted, and the isophotal kind would report a shrinkage for galaxies that have none. Galaxies

A radius that is a measurement of the threshold

A galaxy has no edge. Its light fades exponentially for as far as anyone can measure, so every size ever quoted for one is the radius at which the fading crossed some line that somebody drew. Drawn at a fixed surface brightness, the line measures how bright the galaxy's centre is as much as how big the galaxy is — and at high redshift it measures the expansion of the universe as well.

 A compact galaxy with a faint envelope, seen at redshift two. The surface-brightness profile of a model galaxy at redshift 2, in magnitudes per square arcsecond against radius in kiloparsecs on a logarithmic axis (solid): a compact de Vaucouleurs core of 1 kpc half-light radius and an exponential envelope of 10 kpc holding 30 per cent of the light, dimmed by 4.77 magnitudes by the expansion. The dotted curve is the core alone. Horizontal lines mark survey limits of 27 and 30 magnitudes per square arcsecond. A single Sérsic profile fitted to what is brighter than each limit (dashed) gives a half-light radius of 1.3 kpc and index 4.6 above 27, and a half-light radius of 1.5 kpc and index 5.1 above 30. The galaxy's true half-light radius, core and envelope together, is 2.1 kpc. The envelope is above the deeper limit out to 16 kpc, and the fit still does not follow it: a single profile weighted towards the bright centre cannot bend to two components, and more depth only nudges the compromise it settles on. Galaxies

One profile for a galaxy that has two

The worry about the compact galaxies of ten billion years ago was that their growth since might be partly a faint envelope the sky hides. Modelled, the envelope does hide — but not mainly under the sky. A single profile fitted to a core with an envelope reports a compromise at any depth, too large for a tight envelope and too small for a wide one, and the growth it measures is an understatement.

The whole library · All essays