Celestial sphere — the series
-
The sphere that is not there, and why it is still the right model
The stars are at wildly different distances and the celestial sphere is a fiction. It is also the most useful fiction in observational astronomy, because for pointing at things, distance is exactly the information to throw away.
-
Where a star is depends on who is asking
The sky needs two coordinate systems because two different things stay still in it — the observer's horizon and the stars themselves. One rotation converts between them, and the angle of that rotation is the time.
-
A frame made of things that are not points
Every position in astronomy is measured against a set of objects declared to be fixed. The objects chosen are quasars, because they are the most distant things there are — and each of them is a jet whose radio brightness centre wanders by tens of microarcseconds as new material is ejected from the core.
-
A frame fixed before its centre was found
Galactic longitude and latitude look like the Galaxy's own coordinates, and they are a convention agreed in 1958: a pole taken from the radio map of neutral hydrogen, a zero of longitude put on a radio source then catalogued in Sagittarius, an equator drawn through the Sun. The black hole at the centre was found afterwards, three arcminutes away, and nobody moved the origin. The Sun sits twenty parsecs above the disc, so latitude zero is not the Galaxy's plane except far away — and over eighty million years the Sun will swing a hundred parsecs either side of it.
-
A midplane that depends on how far it is averaged
The Sun sits a little above the middle of the Galaxy's disc — twenty parsecs, by the most careful recent counts, and anywhere from five to thirty by others. If the disc were flat that scatter would be error. It is not flat: the disc near the Sun ripples vertically by tens of parsecs on kiloparsec wavelengths, and on a rippled disc the Sun's height above 'the' midplane depends on how far around it the midplane is averaged. Every value in the scatter can be a correct answer to a different question.