Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Series

Equation of time — the series

7 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. The equation of time, and its two causes. The difference between a sundial and a clock over the year, in minutes, computed from Kepler's equation and the tilt. The eccentricity term has one cycle a year and the obliquity term has two; their sum runs from −14.2 to 16.4 minutes.

    The Sun is a bad clock, by up to sixteen minutes

    Solar noon and twelve o'clock are not the same instant, and the discrepancy runs through a fixed annual cycle. It has two causes, one from the shape of the orbit and one from the tilt of the axis.

    part 1 · sky
  2. The equation of time, and its two causes. The difference between a sundial and a clock over the year, in minutes, computed from Kepler's equation and the tilt. The eccentricity term has one cycle a year and the obliquity term has two; their sum runs from −14.2 to 16.4 minutes.

    Two fictitious suns in sequence

    The equation of time is usually described as one quantity with two causes. It is better read as two separate reductions, each with its own imaginary body — one that moves uniformly along the ecliptic and one that moves uniformly along the equator — and the second is not the first.

    part 2 · sky
  3. The extreme sunset and sunrise, neither of them on the December solstice. Sunset and sunrise in local mean solar time through the ninety days around the December solstice, at latitude 52°, computed from Kepler's equation and the tilt. Each is the solar noon — which is 12:00 minus the equation of time — plus or minus half the day arc, and the two ingredients have different stationary points. The day length is stationary at the solstice, exactly, because the declination is. The equation of time is not: it is changing at about 0.50 minutes a day there, moving solar noon steadily. So the sum is still changing after the day length has stopped, and the earliest sunset comes on 14 Dec — 9 days before the solstice on 23 Dec — while the latest sunrise comes on 31 Dec, 9 days after it. The shortest day is the solstice, and neither of its ends is extreme there. Nothing in this is an approximation or a correction: it is a sum of two functions with different stationary points, and the stationary point of a sum is not the stationary point of either.

    The earliest sunset is not the shortest day

    A sunset time is solar noon plus half the day length, and the two have different stationary points. The day length stops shortening at the solstice; the equation of time does not stop moving, so the sum keeps falling — and the earliest sunset comes days before the shortest day.

    part 3 · sky
  4. Mars: a sundial 40 minutes ahead and 51 behind. The equation of time on Mars over one of its years, 668.6 sols long, against sols since the northern spring equinox, computed from Kepler's equation for an orbit of eccentricity 0.0934 and an axis tilted 25.19°, with perihelion at solar longitude 250.87°. The solid curve is the difference between true and mean solar time: it runs from −51.1 local minutes, 611 sols after the equinox, to +39.9, 385 sols after it — −52.5 to +41.0 in Earth minutes, since a local minute is a 1,440th of a sol. The dashed curves are its two parts. The eccentricity term, one cycle a year, swings by ±42.9 minutes; the obliquity term, two cycles, by ±11.4; the first is 3.74 times the second. Perihelion falls 485 sols after the equinox, marked, and the vertical lines are the equinoxes and solstices.

    On Mars the orbit outweighs the tilt

    The equation of time is the sum of two terms, one from the shape of the orbit and one from the tilt of the axis, and on the Earth they are nearly the same size. On Mars the orbit's term is almost four times the tilt's, a sundial runs from fifty-one minutes behind the clock to forty ahead, and the figure-of-eight the Sun traces in the Earth's sky becomes a teardrop. Nothing about the two terms is different; only their ratio is.

    part 4 · sky
  5. A Sun that runs backwards for 8.1 days. The rate at which the Sun moves across the sky of a planet with a 3:2 spin–orbit ratio and eccentricity 0.2056, in degrees of hour angle per Earth day, against days from perihelion, over one 87.97-day orbit. The rate is the spin rate minus the rate at which the Sun's direction turns because the planet moves along its orbit, and by Kepler's second law that orbital rate peaks at perihelion, at 1.551 times its mean. The spin is 1.5 times the mean orbital rate, so for 8.1 days around perihelion, from −4.0 to +4.0 days, the orbital rate wins, the rate is negative, and the Sun moves backwards across the sky by 1.11 degrees before resuming. At perihelion it is moving at 0.21 degrees a day in the wrong direction. Away from perihelion the Sun crosses the sky at up to 3.4 degrees a day, and a whole solar day, noon to noon, takes 175.9 days — two orbits.

    A Sun that stops and runs backwards

    On Mercury the equation of time is not a correction but a reversal. The planet turns three times for every two orbits, and near perihelion its orbital motion briefly outruns its spin, so the Sun halts, backs up by a degree over eight days and resumes. From one longitude that is three noons in a week; from another, a sunrise, a sunset and a second sunrise — and a slightly rounder orbit would have stopped it happening at all.

    part 5 · sky
  6. Solar noon by the clock, in four places on ordinary time. The clock time at which the Sun crosses the meridian, through a year, for London (0.13°W, clocks on UTC+0), Madrid (3.70°W, clocks on UTC+1), Vigo (8.72°W, clocks on UTC+1), Kashgar (75.99°E, clocks on UTC+8), with summer time where it is kept, from the end of March to the end of October. In London noon falls between 11:44 (4 November) and 13:07 (27 July); in Madrid noon falls between 12:58 (4 November) and 14:21 (27 July); in Vigo noon falls between 13:18 (4 November) and 14:41 (27 July); in Kashgar noon falls between 14:40 (4 November) and 15:10 (12 February). The smooth wave on each curve is the equation of time, the same ±16 minutes everywhere. The steps are summer time, a whole hour. And the vertical offset of each curve is where the place sits inside its time zone, which for a city in the far west of a wide zone is larger than both: noon near three in the afternoon, by the clock, is an ordinary consequence of one time zone spanning a large country.

    The smallest term between a clock and the Sun

    A clock and a sundial disagree for three reasons, and the one astronomy supplies — the equation of time, sixteen minutes at most — is usually the smallest of them. Where a place sits inside its time zone can put noon three hours after twelve, and summer time adds a whole hour on top. The equation of time is visible in ordinary life only where the other two happen to vanish.

    part 6 · sky
  7. An hour that was a twelfth of the daylight. The length of a daylight hour when the time from sunrise to sunset is divided into twelve, through a year, at Alexandria (31.2°N), Rome (41.9°N), London (51.5°N), Stockholm (59.3°N). At Alexandria the hour runs from 51 minutes at the winter solstice to 71 at the summer solstice; at Rome the hour runs from 46 minutes at the winter solstice to 76 at the summer solstice; at London the hour runs from 39 minutes at the winter solstice to 83 at the summer solstice; at Stockholm the hour runs from 30 minutes at the winter solstice to 93 at the summer solstice. The dashed line is sixty minutes, the length it has at both equinoxes everywhere. This is the hour of the ancient Mediterranean world and of medieval Europe until mechanical clocks: an hour defined by the Sun, which a sundial with suitably drawn lines reads exactly, and in which the equation of time does not exist, because nothing is being compared with a uniform clock. Sunrise, sunset and noon are each defined by the Sun, and the clock that would disagree with them had not been built.

    An hour that stretched with the season

    For most of recorded history an hour was a twelfth of the daylight — seventy-six minutes at a Roman midsummer and forty-six in midwinter — and a sundial read it exactly. In that system there was no equation of time, because nothing uniform was being compared with the Sun. The sixteen-minute correction became real only when the hour was made equal, and measurable only when clocks could keep time more steadily than the Sun by more than it.

    part 7 · sky

All series