Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Series

Galaxy interactions — the series

4 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. A bridge and a tail, integrated. A disc of 180 massless particles on circular orbits, and a companion of 1 times the primary's mass on a parabolic orbit with a pericentre of 1.6 disc radii, integrated from before the encounter to well after it. Times are in units of the disc's own outer orbital period, measured from pericentre. The outermost ring, drawn separately, is the one that produces both the bridge and the tail: at 3 its furthest particle is 31.4 disc radii from the centre, having started at 0.9; the panels are scaled to hold ninety per cent of the particles, so the very end of the tail is outside them. Nothing has been ejected and no material is new — every particle is on the orbit its own initial conditions and the two masses give it.

    A bridge and a tail drawn by one force

    The long thin streamers coming out of interacting galaxies look like debris thrown off by a collision. They are nothing of the kind — a simulation with no collisions in it, no gas and no self-gravity produces them from the tidal field alone, and only when the encounter runs the same way the disc turns.

    part 1 · galaxies
  2. Prograde and retrograde, the same encounter. The same encounter twice: a companion of 1 times the primary's mass passing at 1.5 disc radii, with the disc spinning the same way the companion orbits and then the other way. Nothing else differs. The prograde disc grows a bridge towards the companion and a tail away from it; the retrograde one is barely disturbed. The reason is a resonance rather than a force: in the prograde case the outer particles keep pace with the companion for a substantial part of the encounter and are pulled the whole time, and in the retrograde case they sweep past it and the impulses cancel.

    Whether it merges is a ratio of two times

    Two galaxies passing each other either merge or do not, and what decides it is not how close they come. It is whether the encounter lasts long enough for the internal motions to respond — a slow, prograde passage transfers orbital energy into stellar orbits and the pair is bound; a fast one leaves both galaxies heated and still moving.

    part 2 · galaxies
  3. The separation of the Milky Way and Andromeda, run forward. The distance between the Milky Way and Andromeda against time from now, in billions of years, integrated from today's separation of 770 kpc and radial approach of 110 km/s, for four values of Andromeda's sideways (tangential) velocity: 0, 17, 57, 100 km/s. The haloes are extended Hernquist spheres of 1.15 and 1.5 trillion solar masses, and dynamical friction drains the orbit at each passage. At 0 km/s the first approach is so nearly head on that the centres pass within 10 kpc and the pair merges at 4.0 Gyr. At 17 km/s the first approach is so nearly head on that the centres pass within 10 kpc and the pair merges at 4.8 Gyr. At 57 km/s the first pericentre is 117 kpc at 4.5 Gyr, and the pair merges at 9.2 Gyr. At 100 km/s the first pericentre is 321 kpc at 4.8 Gyr, and the pair has not merged by 14 Gyr. The measured sideways speed runs from about 17 km/s (Hubble) to about 57 km/s (Gaia), and the outcomes across that range differ by billions of years.

    A collision decided by a speed across the sky

    Andromeda is coming toward the Milky Way at a hundred and ten kilometres a second, and that part is measured to a few per cent. Whether the two galaxies merge in the next ten billion years depends on how fast Andromeda is also moving sideways — a drift of fifteen millionths of an arcsecond a year, measured twice, with answers of seventeen and fifty-seven kilometres a second. One is a near head-on collision in under five billion years, the other a coin toss.

    part 3 · galaxies
  4. The same added mass, a different size. A galaxy's half-light radius against its mass, relative to its starting values and both on doubling axes, as it grows by repeated dry mergers with companions of mass ratio 1:1, 1:3, 1:10, 1:30, each companion's squared dispersion scaling as the square root of its mass. Equal mergers keep radius proportional to mass; small mergers approach the limit of radius as mass squared. To reach twice the mass, 1:1 gives ×2.0, 1:10 gives ×3.6. The straight dashed line is the mass-squared limit.

    A galaxy that grows faster by eating small

    Two equal elliptical galaxies merge and the result has twice the mass and twice the size. A galaxy that takes in the same mass as thirty small companions ends up nearly four times the size. The difference is one line of the virial theorem, in which companions bring mass without much energy, and it may answer a puzzle thrown up by the first deep infrared surveys: the most massive galaxies at redshift two are a fifth of the size of anything like them today.

    part 4 · galaxies

All series