Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Series

Hill sphere — the series

4 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. The Hill radius against the mass ratio, and where four planets keep their outermost moon. The Hill radius R_H = a(μ/3)^⅓ and the exact L₁ distance from the same quintic, both in units of the planet's own semi-major axis, against the mass ratio μ = m/(M+m) from 10⁻⁸ to 0.12. The two are the same line to the width of the stroke across the whole planetary range — the cube-root formula runs 0.33% short of the exact L₁ distance at the Earth's mass ratio and 10.0% short at the right-hand edge — so the departure between them is drawn on its own percentage scale at the right, which is the only place it can be seen. Below the curves are the numerically determined stability limits, 0.5 R_H for a prograde satellite and 0.7 R_H for a retrograde one, and the outermost known satellite of each of four planets, each at a Hill fraction computed from that planet's own mass and orbit: Moon 0.257, Sinope 0.451, Phoebe 0.198, Neso 0.424. Of the four, three are retrograde — Sinope, Phoebe, Neso — and they reach 0.451 of their planet's Hill radius against 0.257 for the one prograde satellite: 1.8 times as far out, in a diagram whose two stability limits stand in the ratio 0.7 to 0.5. No equilibrium argument predicts that, and it is what the drawing makes plain.

    The region a planet may keep a moon in

    A satellite is not held by orbiting but by orbiting inside the radius at which the Sun's tidal field would take it away. That radius is the same distance the innermost Lagrange point sits at, asked a different question — and the boundary the sky actually respects is smaller, by a factor that depends on which way the moon is going round.

    part 1 · gravitation
  2. Three orders of magnitude in astronomical units, and a factor of 9.6 in mutual Hill radii. Every adjacent pair of planets in three systems, plotted by the separation between them measured in their own mutual Hill radius, ((m₁+m₂)/3M⋆)^⅓ · (a₁+a₂)/2. In astronomical units the same 17 separations span a factor of 2554 — from 0.0043 AU between two TRAPPIST-1 planets to 10.9 between Uranus and Neptune — and carry no visible structure at all. In this unit they span 9.6, with a median of 11.8. The solid line at 2√3 = 3.46 is a theorem: two planets on circular coplanar orbits wider apart than that can never have a close encounter, whatever else happens, and every pair here is clear of it. The dashed line at 10 is a fit, to integrations of systems of several planets over billions of years, and it is the one that bites — a system packed tighter than about ten does not survive, which is why the observed distribution has a floor there and not at the theorem. A planetary system's spacing is not measured in kilometres. It is measured in a unit the planets define.

    A feeding zone, and the spacing it forces

    The radius that decides what a planet may keep also decides what it could reach while it was growing — and measuring the gaps between planets in that unit turns a distribution spanning three orders of magnitude in astronomical units into a band a factor of ten wide, with a floor that is partly a theorem and partly a fit.

    part 2 · gravitation
  3. The quantity a capture has to change. The Jacobi constant along three trajectories through the same encounter with the secondary, integrated in the rotating frame at mass fraction 0.0009543. The undissipated one holds its value to 3e-11 over the whole passage — that is not an approximation but an identity of the equations of motion, and the residual is the integrator's. A body that enters through the neck at L₁ with the neck open leaves through it, because C has not changed and the neck is still open; a purely gravitational two-body encounter is time-reversible and cannot end in a bound orbit. The other two runs remove energy in the rotating frame. A drag proportional to velocity raises C continuously at a rate 2k v², and a single impulse against the motion raises it in a step. Both finish above C(L₁) = 3.039, which is the line at which the neck shuts and the body is trapped in the secondary's lobe. Which mechanism operated for a given satellite is not recoverable from its orbit today — but it is partly recoverable from the population, because the three leave different distributions behind.

    A moon that two bodies could not have caught

    A body that falls into a planet's Hill sphere under gravity alone leaves it again, because the quantity the rotating frame conserves is the same on the way out as on the way in. Every captured moon is therefore a record of something that removed energy — and which of the three candidates did it is written in the inclinations rather than in any one orbit.

    part 3 · gravitation
  4. A limit with a notch cut in the middle of it. The stability limit for a satellite, in units of its planet's Hill radius, against the inclination of its orbit to the planet's. The two flat stretches are the coplanar answers — 0.5 prograde and 0.7 retrograde, the difference between them being the Coriolis asymmetry that a rotating frame imposes and no potential can hold. Between them the limit is not an interpolation. Inside the shaded band, from 39.23° to 140.77°, the Sun's averaged perturbation exchanges the orbit's inclination for its eccentricity, and a satellite whose semi-major axis is comfortably inside the lobe has an apocentre that is not — so the boundary is set by a(1 + eₘₐₓ) rather than by a, and it falls to exactly half the coplanar value at ninety degrees. The band edges are cos²i = 3/5 exactly, with no fitted quantity anywhere in them, and the notch is the reason a quoted stability limit in Hill radii is a statement about a coplanar orbit and not about a satellite.

    A stability limit with a notch cut in it

    The two numbers usually quoted for how far out a moon may orbit are coplanar numbers. A tilted orbit is not somewhere between them: inside a band of inclination fifty-six degrees wide the Sun converts the tilt into an eccentricity, the apocentre rather than the semi-major axis has to stay inside the lobe, and the limit falls to half. The band is empty in the sky.

    part 4 · gravitation

All series