Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Series

The HR diagram — the series

5 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. The Hertzsprung–Russell diagram. Luminosity against surface temperature, both in solar units and on logarithmic axes, with temperature increasing to the left. The main sequence is computed from the mass–luminosity and mass–radius relations; the dashed diagonals are lines of constant radius.

    The diagram that sorted the stars, by plotting two things against each other

    Plot brightness against colour for a few thousand stars and they do not scatter. They fall on a narrow band with two islands off it, and explaining that structure is most of stellar astronomy.

    part 1 · stars
  2. The Hertzsprung–Russell diagram. Luminosity against surface temperature, both in solar units and on logarithmic axes, with temperature increasing to the left. The main sequence is computed from the mass–luminosity and mass–radius relations; the dashed diagonals are lines of constant radius.

    The main sequence is a place stars sit, not a track they travel

    The commonest misreading of the Hertzsprung–Russell diagram is that stars slide down the band as they age. They do not. They sit at one point for ninety percent of their lives and then leave sideways.

    part 2 · stars
  3. Three clusters, three ages, one diagram. Isochrones for populations of 100 Myr, 1 Gyr, 12 Gyr, each drawn as the main sequence up to its own turnoff and then the post-main-sequence track of the turnoff mass. The turnoffs are at 5.52 M☉, 2.20 M☉, 0.94 M☉, from t = 10¹⁰ M/L with this file's own mass–luminosity relation. Nothing here is a track along which a star moves. Every point is a different star of a different mass, all the same age, and the bend is simply where the population runs out of stars that have had time to leave. That is why a cluster has an age and a field star does not: the bend needs a population, and one star is not one. The oldest globular clusters sit near the 12 Gyr line, and in the 1990s the same construction gave them ages of 16 to 18 Gyr against a universe measured at 10 — a two-standard-deviation contradiction that was resolved from the distance side, by Hipparcos, and not from this one.

    An age read off a bend

    A cluster is a population of one age and many masses, so the place where its stars leave the main sequence is a clock. The bend needs a population — which is why a cluster has an age and a single star does not.

    part 3 · stars
  4. Isochrones that crowd on the main sequence and fan out above it. Isochrones for stars of solar metallicity at 1, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12 billion years, luminosity against temperature with temperature falling to the right. On the main sequence they lie almost on top of one another — a star brightens and barely changes colour as it ages — and only where they turn off and cross towards the giants do they separate. Two boxes show the measurement errors of a star with a good parallax and spectrum (twice 70 K and 3 per cent): one around a Sun-like star of 4.6 billion years, whose age they allow anywhere in 4.53 (3.38–5.63) billion years; one around a subgiant of the same mass at 10.5, allowed only 10.5 (10.3–10.7).

    A lone star is dated only as it leaves

    A star in a cluster is dated by the bend its neighbours trace. A star alone has one position on the Hertzsprung–Russell diagram, and an age for it means finding which isochrone passes through that point. On the main sequence they almost all do: a Sun-like star measured as well as a parallax and a spectrum allow is anywhere from three and a half to five and a half billion years old. A star the same mass on its way off the main sequence is dated to two per cent.

    part 4 · stars
  5. Four clocks for a 1 M☉ dwarf, and the best of them. The fractional age uncertainty each method reaches for an isolated 1 solar-mass main-sequence star, against its age, logarithmic, for isochrones, rotation, oscillations and chemical clock, with representative published precisions. Rotation is best while the star is young, once its spin has forgotten its start and before its braking weakens; isochrones and oscillations improve with age as the star moves further on the diagram. The combination (heavy line) is 14 per cent at 1 Gyr, 9 at 3 and 4 at 8. It is better than ten per cent (dashed) from 2.6 to 9.4 Gyr.

    Four clocks and the stars none of them reads

    An isolated dwarf star can be dated four ways — by its position on the Hertzsprung–Russell diagram, by how fast it spins, by its oscillations, and by the ratio of two elements its galaxy made at different rates. Each clock has an age range where it works and masses it cannot read. Laid side by side for a Sun-like star they cover most of its life to ten per cent or so. For a star of eight-tenths of the Sun's mass only one clock is left, it works only while the star is young, and the commonest stars in the Galaxy's disc are dated one at a time no better than fifteen per cent at any age.

    part 5 · stars

All series