Shell theorem — the series · Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics

Why a shell pulls a point inside it not at all. A double cone from a point inside a uniform shell. In the narrow-cone limit the far patch is 2.80 times further away and 2.80 times wider — the same number, checked to a part in a thousand before this figure is drawn. Its mass is greater by the square of that ratio and its pull weaker by the same square, so the two cancel in every direction.

A sphere pulls exactly like a point, and the proof is a pair of cones

Every orbit ever computed treats the Sun as a dot. That is not an approximation — for a spherical body it is exact, and the reason is a cancellation between two patches of a shell.

part 1 · gravitation

Forty-two minutes, from anywhere to anywhere. Left, the gravitational field inside the Earth: a straight line for a uniform sphere, because the enclosed mass grows as r³ and the field as r, and the PREM curve for the real one, which is nearly flat through the whole mantle at about 9.94 m/s² because the dense core is already all below. Right, what falls through it. A body dropped down a diametric tunnel through a uniform Earth executes simple harmonic motion with ω = √(g/R), reaching the far side in 42.2 minutes; a body dropped down a chord at 0.6 of the radius feels only the component along the tunnel, which is the same ω times a smaller distance, so it arrives in the same time from a shorter trip. The period does not contain the length of the tunnel, its direction, or where the body starts. And 2π/ω is also the period of a circular orbit grazing the surface, 84.3 minutes — the tunnel and the orbit are one ellipse, seen twice. The real Earth is not uniform and gets there in 38.2 minutes instead, which is the honest number and is 9% quicker.

The tunnel that takes the same time from anywhere

Inside a uniform sphere the field grows in proportion to the distance from the centre, which is Hooke's law. A body dropped down any straight tunnel arrives in the same time — and that time is the period of an orbit skimming the surface.

part 2 · gravitation

The pull of a ring, a shell and a point, in the plane. Radial force in the plane of a thin ring of radius 1, against distance from its centre, in units where the same mass at a point would pull with one over the distance squared; positive is outward. Inside a spherical shell of the same radius and mass the force is exactly zero. Inside the ring it is not: it points outward, toward the nearer part of the ring, at 0.34 at half the radius and 2.75 at nine tenths, growing without limit toward the rim. Outside, the ring pulls inward harder than a point would, by 25 per cent at twice its radius and 9 per cent at three times, because the near side of the ring is closer than the centre. The shell is indistinguishable from the point everywhere outside it.

Inside a ring the pull points outward

A hollow sphere exerts no force on anything inside it, and the proof is a pair of cones whose areas grow exactly as fast as gravity weakens. Cut the sphere down to a ring and the arcs grow only as the distance, the nearer side wins, and a planet set in the middle of a rigid ring falls into it within a handful of orbits — which is why Saturn's rings cannot be solid, and why a flat galaxy spins faster than its own enclosed mass allows.

part 3 · gravitation

A flattened shell that pulls nothing inside it. The strength of the gravitational field of a thin homoeoid — the shell between two similar concentric ellipsoids, here with axis ratio 0.5 — along its long axis (solid) and its short axis (dashed), in units of GM/a² against distance from the centre in units of the long semi-axis a, from 20,000 equal masses placed on it. The dotted curve is a point mass. Inside the shell the field is zero along both axes to within 0.0001 — the numerical residue of a finite sampling — however flattened the shell is: this is Newton's theorem for a homoeoid, the flattened generalisation of the spherical shell's empty interior. Outside, the shell does not pull like a point: at 1.2 a along the long axis the field is 1.003 against the point's 0.694, and at 0.60 a along the short axis, just outside the shell there, 0.901. The exterior field remembers the shape; the interior does not know there is one.

The shell can be flattened if it thins at the poles

A spherical shell exerts no force anywhere inside it, and a ring exerts a force that points outward. Between them lies a shape Newton found that keeps the sphere's empty interior however far it is flattened: the homoeoid, a shell bounded by two similar ellipsoids, thick at the equator and thin at the poles in exactly the right proportion. It is why the gravity inside any flattened body can be computed at all — and why the planes of stellar streams measure the shapes of dark haloes.

part 4 · gravitation

The flattening a halo has, and the flattening an orbit feels. Three model haloes with flat rotation curves, each built from thin similar-shell layers whose axis ratio changes with radius (dashed), and the axis ratio a nearly circular orbit at each radius responds to (solid) — the a²-weighted mean over the shells inside the orbit, because a shell exerts no force on anything within it. A halo flattened to 0.85 everywhere is felt as 0.85 everywhere. A halo round inside and flattened to 0.8 beyond about 30 kpc is felt as round by every orbit within 20 kpc — 0.988 at 20 — and at 60 kpc as 0.83, where its own shells are 0.80. A halo flattened inside and round outside is felt as flattened well beyond where its shells have become round. An orbit reports a running average of everything inside it, weighted towards its own radius, and nothing at all about what lies outside.

A shell outside the stream turns nothing

A flattened halo turns the plane of every orbit inside it, and a stream of stars several orbits long records how far. But the turning is set only by the halo inside the orbit — a flattened shell enclosing it exerts no force on it at all — and within that, mostly by the shells just inside. So a stream measures a running average of the halo's shape out to its own radius, a halo round inside and flattened outside looks round to every stream in its core, and reading the shape of each layer back out of the streams costs more precision the further out the layer lies.

part 5 · gravitation