Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Series

Velocity dispersion — the series

4 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. Mass from a velocity dispersion, across nine decades. The virial estimate M = 5 σ²R_e/G, drawn for half-light radii from 0.2 to 20 kpc, with four systems placed on it: M32 at σ = 75 km/s and R_e = 0.1 kpc, giving 6.5e+8 M☉; the Milky Way's bulge at σ = 105 km/s and R_e = 1 kpc, giving 1.3e+10 M☉; M87 at σ = 320 km/s and R_e = 7 kpc, giving 8.3e+11 M☉; the Coma cluster at σ = 1000 km/s and R_e = 1500 kpc, giving 1.7e+15 M☉. The same expression spans from a dwarf elliptical to a cluster of galaxies — nine decades of mass — because the virial theorem does not care what the moving objects are. In the last case they are whole galaxies, and the estimate exceeds everything visible in the cluster by a factor of about fifty, which is where the problem was first noticed.

    A galaxy held up by disorder

    An elliptical galaxy barely rotates. What holds it up against its own gravity is the randomness of its stars' motions, and the virial theorem turns that randomness into a mass by exactly the reasoning that turns a rotation speed into one.

    part 1 · galaxies
  2. A virial mass inflated 23.2-fold by orbits nobody resolved. The factor by which a virial mass is overestimated when the velocity dispersion is measured from single-epoch spectra, against the system's true dispersion, for four numbers of observing epochs. Every star in a binary carries its own orbital velocity, which adds in quadrature to the system's own, and the orbital velocities of ordinary binaries are of order a kilometre a second. A system whose real dispersion is 0.3 km/s therefore measures 1.45, and since a virial mass goes as the square of the dispersion the mass comes out 23.2 times too large. Repeat epochs fix it: the orbital velocities are uncorrelated between visits while the system's own are not, so the binary variance falls as one over the number of epochs and the correction is measured rather than modelled.

    A dispersion inflated by orbits nobody resolved

    A velocity dispersion measured from single spectra is not the dispersion of the system's centres of mass. Every star in a binary carries its own orbital velocity of a kilometre or so, and for a dwarf galaxy whose real dispersion is smaller than that, the measured value — and the dark-matter content computed from its square — is mostly binaries.

    part 2 · galaxies
  3. Mass profiles that pinch together near the half-light radius. The enclosed mass of each of the 13 haloes that fit the same flat dispersion of 10 km/s, against radius in units of the stars' three-dimensional half-light radius, 391 parsecs. At a tenth of that radius they span a factor of 17, and at four times it a factor of 2.5; they pinch together near the half-light radius, closest at 1.47 of it, where they agree to 14 per cent. The dot is the estimate 3σ²r/G at the radius where the stars' density falls as r⁻³, 0.94 of the half-light radius; there the fitted masses lie between 0.65 and 1.03 times it. Each model trades a wrong guess about the orbits against a wrong guess about the mass, in opposite senses inside and outside.

    The one radius where the orbits stop mattering

    A velocity dispersion weighs a galaxy only if the shape of its stars' orbits is known, and it never is. Yet every model that fits a dwarf galaxy's flat dispersion profile — cored or cusped, radial orbits or tangential — agrees on the mass inside one particular radius, close to the radius that contains half the light. The degeneracy has a node, and the node is where the measurement should be quoted.

    part 3 · galaxies
  4. Haloes that agree on the line of sight, and disagree across the sky. The dispersion of the tangential component of motion on the sky — across the radius vector, as a proper motion measures it — predicted by each of the 13 dark haloes that fit the same flat line-of-sight dispersion of 10 km/s, against projected radius in half-light radii, for stars in a Plummer profile. Coloured by the halo's inner slope; the dashed line is the line-of-sight value all of them reproduce. At the half-light radius the haloes' line-of-sight dispersions agree to 2.0 per cent, and their tangential dispersions range from 8.3 to 10.8 km/s, a factor of 1.29. The anisotropy each halo needed to match the line of sight is written into the motion across it, which no line-of-sight measurement sees.

    Motions across the sky measure the orbits first

    A dwarf galaxy's line-of-sight velocities leave the shape of its stars' orbits free, and that freedom hides whether its dark halo has a core or a cusp. Proper motions add the two components across the sky. They read the orbits' shape almost at once, with a few hundred stars — and they reach the slope of the halo only with ten thousand.

    part 4 · galaxies

All series