Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Differential measurement — where it appears

A measurement made as the difference between two quantities recorded under shared conditions, so that errors common to both cancel. Precise photometry, polarimetry and astrometry all rely on it, trading an absolute calibration for a symmetry.

Named by 2 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A nanosecond across the Earth is 35.69 nanoradians on the sky. The angular accuracy of a differenced-delay measurement against the length of the baseline it is measured on, both axes logarithmic, for three levels of delay precision. The relation is σ_θ = cσ_τ/B and nothing else, so every curve is a straight line of slope −1.00: the only two ways to measure an angle better are a better clock or a wider Earth, and only one of those is available. The three marked baselines are the ones that exist — the deep-space complexes in California, Spain and Australia, 8,400, 10,600, 11,700 kilometres apart. On the longest of them a delay good to 0.05 nanoseconds is 1.28 nanoradians, which at 0.52 astronomical units is 100 metres across the line of sight; a more typical 0.15-nanosecond measurement on the shortest baseline is 5.35 nanoradians. What makes any of this survivable is that the same pair of antennas observes a quasar a few degrees away immediately afterwards. The quasar is at infinity, its position is known better than the measurement, and subtracting its delay from the spacecraft's removes the clock offsets, the water vapour over each dish and the station coordinates in one step — so the number that comes out is not a delay at all but an angular separation from a fixed point in the sky.

An angle measured against a quasar

A tracking station measures how fast a spacecraft is receding, which is one number where three are wanted. The two missing angles come from the Earth's rotation, slowly, and near a planetary encounter there is no time for slowly — so the position is instead measured directly, as a difference of arrival times between two antennas, referred to a quasar a few degrees away.

spaceflight · Radiometric navigation How fast to switch. The rms false polarisation left by a 1 per cent rms brightness fluctuation, against the modulation frequency, both on logarithmic scales, for fluctuations whose spectrum turns down at 5, 20, 100 Hz. Below the turnover the false signal is the whole fluctuation, about 0.7 per cent; above it, it falls steeply as the pairs are taken faster than the air changes. To reach a part in ten thousand (dashed) — the precision at which stellar and planetary polarisation becomes interesting — the switching must run at 3,311 Hz, 13,183 Hz, 66,069 Hz respectively: switching at hertz is useless, and a single beam needs kilohertz or more.

A polarisation measured faster than the air changes

Polarisation is a difference between two brightnesses, and the brightness of a star seen through the air changes by a per cent from one millisecond to the next. Measure the two one after the other and the air's flicker becomes a false polarisation a hundred times larger than the signals worth having. The cure is to switch between them faster than the air can change, or to measure both at once and then swap them — turning a calibration problem into a differential one.

starlight · Polarimetry

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Angular accuracyBaselineClock offsetDeep-space networkDelta-DORDual beam polarimetryEncounter navigationGroup delayHalf-wave plateInternational celestial reference framePhoton noisePlane of sky position

All concepts