Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Greatest elongation — where it appears

The largest angle from the Sun that an inner planet reaches as seen from the Earth. At that moment the angle at the planet between the Sun and the Earth is a right angle, so the sine of the elongation gives the planet's orbital radius in astronomical units.

Named by 3 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The solar system to three figures, and not one distance in it. Left, why an inferior planet's wandering is a measurement. At greatest elongation the sight line from the Earth is tangent to the planet's orbit, so the angle at the planet is a right angle and a/a⊕ = sin ε — no distance anywhere in the argument, only the angle between two directions. Venus reaches 45.4°–47.1°, giving 0.7224 AU against the modern 0.72333. Right, every planet Copernicus could see, derived this way and by the synodic route for the outer ones — 1/P = 1/E − 1/S for the year, then the harmonic law for the distance — plotted against the catalogue. Mercury is the interesting failure: its elongation runs from 17.9° to 27.8° rather than sitting still, so the method returns a range, 0.307 to 0.466 AU, and the true 0.3871 lies inside it. That spread is not an error in the method; it is Mercury's eccentricity being measured by a technique that assumed a circle.

The solar system measured from inside one orbit

Venus never appears more than 47 degrees from the Sun. That single angle gives its orbital radius as a fraction of the Earth's, with no distance measured anywhere — and every other planet gives one up as easily.

sky · Apparent motion A right angle short by 0.147°, and a ratio of 389 hanging on it. The ratio of the Sun's distance to the Moon's implied by the angle between them at the moment the Moon is exactly half lit, on a logarithmic scale, for angles from 80° to 89.95°. At that moment the angle at the Moon between the directions to the Sun and the Earth is a right angle, so the ratio is the secant of the observed angle — a construction with no distance in it, the same right triangle that gives an inferior planet's orbit from its greatest elongation. Aristarchus measured 87°, which gives 19.1. The mean distances give 389, which corresponds to 89.853°. The curve's steepness is the whole story: across a tenth of a degree centred on each marked angle the ratio changes by 3.4 per cent at 87°, 10.5 per cent at 89° and 103 per cent at the true angle. The method was exact and it asked for a right angle measured to a hundredth of a degree, at an instant the eye can judge only to within hours, on a terminator that is never quite straight.

A right angle short by a seventh of a degree

When the Moon is exactly half lit, the angle at the Moon between the Sun and the Earth is a right angle, so the angle seen from the Earth gives the Sun's distance in units of the Moon's. Aristarchus measured 87° and concluded the Sun was nineteen times further away. The construction was exact; the angle he needed was 89.85°, and at that angle a tenth of a degree is the whole answer.

sky · Apparent motion Venus is brightest 51 days from inferior conjunction, 38 per cent lit. The brightness of Venus through one synodic period of 584 days, in magnitudes below its brightest, against days from superior conjunction — inferior conjunction at the two ends of the axis. The planet is treated as a matte, Lambert-scattering sphere on a circular orbit of 0.723 AU, so its flux is its phase function divided by the square of its distance from the Earth. The two factors fight: near inferior conjunction the planet is closest but shows only a thin crescent, and near superior conjunction it is fully lit but 1.72 AU away. For this orbit the contest has an interior winner. The brightest moment is 51 days either side of inferior conjunction, at an elongation of 44.6° from the Sun, with 38 per cent of the disc lit and the planet 0.539 AU away; greatest elongation, at 46.3°, comes 71 days from inferior conjunction, after the brightness peak on the way out from inferior conjunction. At superior conjunction the planet is 0.82 magnitudes fainter than its best. The marked point is the observed greatest brilliancy, about 36 days from inferior conjunction at an elongation near 39° — closer to conjunction and to a thinner crescent than any matte sphere on this orbit can be brightest at. A surface that sends more light forward, towards large phase angles, would move the peak exactly that way. Very near either conjunction the planet is lost in the Sun's glare, and the curve there describes light nobody sees.

Brightest as a crescent, and not as a disc

Venus is fully lit when it is furthest away and nearest when it is barely lit, and it is brightest in between, as a crescent weeks from inferior conjunction. A matte planet only has such a peak if its orbit is wider than about 0.46 of the Earth's — Mercury's is not, and Mercury is brightest full — and Venus's real peak sits closer to conjunction than any matte sphere allows, which is its clouds throwing light forward.

sky · Apparent motion

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Astronomical unit (AU)Inferior conjunctionLunar phaseRelative scaleAngular measurementAnomalistic monthCopernican systemDichotomyElongationError propagationForward-scatteringGeometric albedo

All concepts