Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Astronomical unit (AU) — where it appears

The unit of length equal to 149,597,870,700 metres, close to the Earth's mean distance from the Sun and now defined rather than measured. It was determined for two centuries by transits of Venus and by radar ranging, and it stopped being a measured quantity in 2012 when it was fixed by definition.

Named by 8 essays across 4 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Period against size for the planets, around the Sun. Orbital period against semi-major axis on logarithmic axes. The line has slope exactly three-halves — the harmonic law — and the measured bodies sit on it.

The law that links period to size, and weighs everything

Kepler found that the square of the period goes as the cube of the orbit. Newton found the constant of proportionality, and that constant is a mass — which is how every mass in astronomy has been obtained since.

orbits · Harmonic law Four averages of one distance, and the two of them that are the semi-major axis. The average distance of a body from its primary, against eccentricity and in units of the semi-major axis, computed four ways: averaged over time, over true anomaly, over eccentric anomaly, and as the harmonic mean in time. Every curve is a quadrature over the orbit — 2,048 panels uniform in eccentric anomaly, with Kepler's equation supplying the time weight — and not a closed form. Two of the four are exactly a at every eccentricity, which is why they are drawn as one line: the eccentric-anomaly average, because the mean of cos E over a turn is zero, and the harmonic mean in time, because the time weight cancels 1/r at every node before the sum begins. The other two are not: the time average is a(1 + e²/2), which rises to 1.4050 a at e = 0.9, and the true-anomaly average is a√(1−e²) — the semi-minor axis — which falls to 0.4359 a there. So a is the average distance in two senses out of four, and the ordering b ≤ a ≤ ⟨r⟩ₜ holds at every eccentricity with equality only on the circle. At Earth's e = 0.0167 the four agree to 0.014%, and at Mercury's e = 0.2056 the spread is 2.14%. The distinction is invisible for the planets and unavoidable for a comet, and it is the reason a quoted "mean distance" has to say which mean.

The average depends on what is being averaged

Four ways of averaging one orbit's distance from its primary give four different numbers, and only two of them are the semi-major axis. Which two is not a matter of convention, and the same arithmetic decides how much sunlight a planet receives in a year.

orbits · Orbital averages G: 14 determinations in two families. Published determinations of G, each with its quoted one-sigma interval, sorted into two families — torsion balance, in one form or another, against beam balance, pendulum, atom interferometry. The shaded band behind each family is that family's inverse-variance weighted mean: 6.67435 ± 0.00004 across 11 of them, against 6.67343 ± 0.00009 across 3. The difference is 0.00092 ± 0.00010 10⁻¹¹ m³ kg⁻¹ s⁻², which is 9.3 standard deviations, computed here from the quoted errors alone. The arithmetic is the same one the Hubble figure uses and here it should be distrusted, because the scatter inside each family already exceeds what the intervals allow: eleven torsion-balance determinations spread over 500 parts per million with quoted intervals of 12 to 130 cannot all be right, whatever the difference between the families comes to. That is why the recommended value's uncertainty is expanded far beyond any single experiment's rather than being the weighted combination drawn here — the disagreement is between laboratories using the same method, not between methods.

Nothing in the sky is weighed in kilograms

The Sun's gravitational parameter is known to eleven significant figures. The Sun's mass is known to five. The two statements are about the same object and the difference between them is a constant measured in basements, which is the worst-determined fundamental constant in physics.

gravitation · Gravitational constant The solar system to three figures, and not one distance in it. Left, why an inferior planet's wandering is a measurement. At greatest elongation the sight line from the Earth is tangent to the planet's orbit, so the angle at the planet is a right angle and a/a⊕ = sin ε — no distance anywhere in the argument, only the angle between two directions. Venus reaches 45.4°–47.1°, giving 0.7224 AU against the modern 0.72333. Right, every planet Copernicus could see, derived this way and by the synodic route for the outer ones — 1/P = 1/E − 1/S for the year, then the harmonic law for the distance — plotted against the catalogue. Mercury is the interesting failure: its elongation runs from 17.9° to 27.8° rather than sitting still, so the method returns a range, 0.307 to 0.466 AU, and the true 0.3871 lies inside it. That spread is not an error in the method; it is Mercury's eccentricity being measured by a technique that assumed a circle.

The solar system measured from inside one orbit

Venus never appears more than 47 degrees from the Sun. That single angle gives its orbital radius as a fraction of the Earth's, with no distance measured anywhere — and every other planet gives one up as easily.

sky · Apparent motion Parallax for a star at 1.3 parsecs. The same star observed from two ends of a baseline. The two sight lines are 1.54″ apart, so the parallax — half of that, the shift seen from a one-astronomical-unit baseline — is 0.769″ for a star 1.3 parsecs away. The definition of the parsec is the distance at which it would be exactly one.

The triangle that reaches the stars, and stops

Parallax is the only distance measurement in astronomy that assumes nothing. It is also the only one with a hard ceiling, and everything beyond that ceiling rests on it.

starlight · Parallax The fractional distance error, rung by rung. Cumulative fractional uncertainty in a measured distance against the distance itself, both on logarithmic axes. Each rung of the ladder is calibrated against the one below it, so its scatter adds in quadrature to everything already inherited, and the total can only rise: radar to the planets 10⁻⁵%, parallax 1.0%, main-sequence fitting 5.1%, Cepheids 6.5%, Type Ia supernovae 8.2%.

Every distance is measured with the last one

No single method reaches from a planet to a distant galaxy. The ladder is built rung by rung, each calibrated on the one below, and the errors multiply all the way up.

starlight · Distance ladder The distance modulus. The difference between apparent and absolute magnitude against distance, on a logarithmic distance axis. It is a straight line of slope five per decade, passing through zero at ten parsecs — the definition of the absolute magnitude. Reading a distance off it requires the absolute magnitude, which is never measured and always inferred.

A brightness is a distance only if something is known

The inverse square law turns a brightness into a distance in one line. The line contains a quantity that has never been measured for any object outside the solar system.

starlight · Magnitudes A right angle short by 0.147°, and a ratio of 389 hanging on it. The ratio of the Sun's distance to the Moon's implied by the angle between them at the moment the Moon is exactly half lit, on a logarithmic scale, for angles from 80° to 89.95°. At that moment the angle at the Moon between the directions to the Sun and the Earth is a right angle, so the ratio is the secant of the observed angle — a construction with no distance in it, the same right triangle that gives an inferior planet's orbit from its greatest elongation. Aristarchus measured 87°, which gives 19.1. The mean distances give 389, which corresponds to 89.853°. The curve's steepness is the whole story: across a tenth of a degree centred on each marked angle the ratio changes by 3.4 per cent at 87°, 10.5 per cent at 89° and 103 per cent at the true angle. The method was exact and it asked for a right angle measured to a hundredth of a degree, at an instant the eye can judge only to within hours, on a terminator that is never quite straight.

A right angle short by a seventh of a degree

When the Moon is exactly half lit, the angle at the Moon between the Sun and the Earth is a right angle, so the angle seen from the Earth gives the Sun's distance in units of the Moon's. Aristarchus measured 87° and concluded the Sun was nineteen times further away. The construction was exact; the angle he needed was 89.85°, and at that angle a tenth of a degree is the whole answer.

sky · Apparent motion

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Distance ladderParsecAbsolute magnitudeDistance modulusEccentricityGreatest elongationKepler's third lawMetallicityPeriapsisPhotometryRelative scaleTrigonometric parallax

All concepts