Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Kepler's third law — where it appears

The relation making the square of an orbital period proportional to the cube of the semi-major axis, from which every mass in the sky is obtained. In its exact form the constant contains the sum of the two masses, and that correction is what makes it a way of weighing anything.

Named by 9 essays across 4 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Period against size for the planets, around the Sun. Orbital period against semi-major axis on logarithmic axes. The line has slope exactly three-halves — the harmonic law — and the measured bodies sit on it.

The law that links period to size, and weighs everything

Kepler found that the square of the period goes as the cube of the orbit. Newton found the constant of proportionality, and that constant is a mass — which is how every mass in astronomy has been obtained since.

orbits · Harmonic law The mass correction against the mass. Each planet's departure from the massless harmonic law, against its own mass in solar units, on logarithmic axes. The exact law puts every point on the diagonal. Jupiter and Saturn are the only planets whose mass correction is larger than the perturbations from everything else, and Saturn's measured departure has the opposite sign.

The third law is wrong by the mass of the planet

Kepler's harmonic law says the square of the period goes as the cube of the size. Newton's version has one more term in it, and the term is the orbiting body's own mass — negligible for a planet, decisive for a binary star, and the reason a period can be converted into a mass at all.

orbits · Harmonic law G: 14 determinations in two families. Published determinations of G, each with its quoted one-sigma interval, sorted into two families — torsion balance, in one form or another, against beam balance, pendulum, atom interferometry. The shaded band behind each family is that family's inverse-variance weighted mean: 6.67435 ± 0.00004 across 11 of them, against 6.67343 ± 0.00009 across 3. The difference is 0.00092 ± 0.00010 10⁻¹¹ m³ kg⁻¹ s⁻², which is 9.3 standard deviations, computed here from the quoted errors alone. The arithmetic is the same one the Hubble figure uses and here it should be distrusted, because the scatter inside each family already exceeds what the intervals allow: eleven torsion-balance determinations spread over 500 parts per million with quoted intervals of 12 to 130 cannot all be right, whatever the difference between the families comes to. That is why the recommended value's uncertainty is expanded far beyond any single experiment's rather than being the weighted combination drawn here — the disagreement is between laboratories using the same method, not between methods.

Nothing in the sky is weighed in kilograms

The Sun's gravitational parameter is known to eleven significant figures. The Sun's mass is known to five. The two statements are about the same object and the difference between them is a constant measured in basements, which is the worst-determined fundamental constant in physics.

gravitation · Gravitational constant Integrating the measured recession back: the Moon reaches the Earth 1.54 Gyr ago. The Earth–Moon separation and the length of the Earth's day, integrated backwards from the measured present recession rate of 3.83 cm per year. Constant-Q tidal friction makes a^(13/2) linear in time, so the history is a single line in a variable nobody plots, and it is calibrated to the laser-ranging measurement rather than to a modelled k₂/Q — the k₂/Q it implies is 0.0257, or Q = 11.6 for the Earth's k₂ of 0.299, which is a startlingly dissipative Earth. Run back at that rate the separation reaches zero 1.54 Gyr ago and crosses the Roche limit at 2.88 Earth radii only 4 years before it, so the drawing is cut off there rather than extrapolated. The Moon is 4.5 Gyr old, so this is a refutation and not a date: the present rate cannot have been the rate, and a mean Q of 34 — drawn dashed, reaching 4.51 Gyr — is the sort of value the age requires. Tidal rhythmites at 620 Myr put the day at 21.9 h and the Moon at 96.5 per cent of its present distance, and this history reads 20.1 h and 92.4 per cent — too fast and too close, which is the same failure the zero crossing is. Day length follows from total angular momentum, 23.93 h today, 9.84 h at half the present lunar distance and 4.97 h at the Roche limit, and depends on the separation alone: it is the same curve whatever Q is. The rate of lengthening the recession requires is 2.10 ms per century, against a tidal total of about 2.3 including the Sun's tide, which slows the Earth without moving the Moon, and an observed 1.75 from ancient eclipses and occultations — the shortfall being the Earth's moment of inertia falling as the mantle rebounds from the last glaciation.

A day five hours long

The tidal bulge leads, so the Earth's spin is being paid into the Moon's orbit. Run the measured payment backwards and two curves come out of one integration — a timeline that is refuted by the Moon's own age, and a day length that is refuted by nothing.

gravitation · Tides Mars through 8.3 months of sky. The geocentric ecliptic longitude and latitude of Mars over 252 days — 8.3 months — centred on opposition, computed as the direction of P − E with both orbits taken as circles: the Earth's of radius 1 AU, the planet's of 1.5237 AU inclined 1.850°. The motion reverses for 72.7 days and backs up 15.94° of longitude, and that interval is centred on opposition to within 0.0000° of longitude. The track closes on itself: over 149 days the planet visits the same point of the sky twice, and the loop it encloses is 15.9° long and 2.94° tall. Longitude and latitude are at different scales: a degree of latitude is drawn 4.6 times a degree of longitude, because the sweep of 51° in longitude and 4.5° in latitude will not share a scale on one page. Circular orbits mean one loop for every apparition, and that is the real cost of this figure: Mars is 0.525 AU away at the opposition drawn here, its true distance at opposition varies with its eccentricity, and the real loops differ in size from one apparition to the next because of it. The marks are 20 days apart, and they crowd where the motion stops.

The loop a planet does not make

Mars stops in the sky, backs up for ten weeks, and goes on. Neither orbit reverses anywhere — the loop belongs to the difference of two position vectors seen from one of them, and its width and duration are fixed by the ratio of the two radii and by nothing else.

sky · Apparent motion S2's orbit, and the mass it implies. The orbit of S2 about the centre of the Milky Way, drawn from its measured elements: a semi-major axis of 0.1251 arcseconds, which at 8.28 kpc is 1036 AU, an eccentricity of 0.8843, and a period of 16.05 years watched round twice. Kepler's third law in solar units — a³/P² — gives 4.31 million solar masses, by exactly the calculation that weighs a planetary system. At periapsis the star is 120 AU from the focus, 1407 Schwarzschild radii, and the mean density inside that radius is 5.3e+15 M☉ per cubic parsec — a million times the densest star cluster known. That density, not the mass, is the argument: there is no configuration of stars that would fit.

The mass at the centre that is not stars

One star at the centre of the Milky Way has been watched round a complete orbit. Its semi-major axis and its period give four million solar masses by Kepler's third law — and the volume that mass occupies is small enough to rule out every alternative to a black hole.

galaxies · Galactic nuclei Who holds the mass, and who holds the spin. The solar system's two ledgers on one logarithmic axis, each row a body or a group of them, with the pale bar its share of the mass and the dark bar its share of the angular momentum. Both columns are computed rather than quoted: the Sun's spin from 0.07 M R² Ω at a 25.38-day rotation, each planet's orbit from M √(GM☉ a (1 − e²)) with its own semi-major axis and eccentricity, and both sums are required to close to one part in a billion. The Sun holds 99.866 per cent of the mass and 0.61 per cent of the angular momentum. Jupiter holds 0.095 per cent of the mass and 61.1 per cent of the angular momentum, so a body a thousandth of the system by weight carries most of its rotation. The four inner planets together account for 0.0016 of it. A cloud collapsing to make this system had to move nearly all of its spin outward onto a small fraction of its mass, and the ledger is what that operation looks like when it is finished. What the figure cannot show is where the transfer happened, because everything that carried it away has either fallen in or left.

Ninety-nine per cent of the mass and none of the spin

The Sun holds 99.87 per cent of the solar system's mass and 0.6 per cent of its angular momentum. Jupiter holds a thousandth of the mass and three-fifths of the spin. That is not a curiosity of accounting — it is the record of the single operation that had to succeed before a star could form at all.

orbits · Angular momentum A fall into the Sun from a standing start. The distance of a body released at rest 1 AU from the Sun, as a fraction of its starting distance, against time as a fraction of the fall's total duration, 64.6 days: the exact radial orbit (solid) and a fall at the constant acceleration felt at the start (dashed). The exact fall begins exactly like the constant one and finishes far faster, because the pull grows as the inverse square of the shrinking distance: it reaches the Sun at 79 per cent of the time the constant pull would take. The curve is a cycloid, and the total time is a fifth of the circular orbital period at the starting distance — exactly 1/(4√2) of it — because a straight fall is half of an ellipse whose semi-major axis is half the starting distance.

A fall is half an orbit with no width

Stop a planet dead and it falls into the Sun, in a time that is not a quarter of its year or a half but exactly one over four times the square root of two. The fall is an ellipse squeezed to a line, it spends four-fifths of its duration in the outer half of its path, and in a uniform cloud every shell of it arrives at the centre at the same moment — which is where the free-fall time of star formation comes from.

orbits · Conic sections A moonlet's period measures its primary's density. The orbital period of a small satellite against the radius of its orbit in units of the primary's radius, both logarithmic, for primaries of bulk density 1, 2, 3.5 g/cm³. The size of the asteroid cancels: a moonlet at five radii from a body of 2 g/cm³ takes 26 hours whether the body is a kilometre or a hundred across. At one radius the curves give the spin period at which a strengthless rubble pile flies apart — 3.3, 2.3 and 1.8 hours. Didymos–Dimorphos, at 3.1 radii and 11.92 hours, gives 2.4 g/cm³; 1999 KW4, at 3.9 radii and 17.42 hours, gives 2.1 g/cm³.

A moonlet that weighs a pile of rubble

Put Kepler's third law round an asteroid and its size cancels: a moonlet's period depends only on how many of the asteroid's radii away it orbits and on the asteroid's density. So the first asteroid moon ever seen, a mile-wide speck beside Ida, turned a picture into a density — and the density came out too low for solid rock. A fifth to a half of the asteroids weighed this way is empty space.

orbits · Harmonic law

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Angular momentumEccentricityAngular momentum transportAstronomical unit (AU)BarycentreMass ratioOrbital periodStandard gravitational parameterAccretionAccretion discActive galactic nucleusAsteroid

All concepts