Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Angular momentum transport — where it appears

The handing of spin from one place to another, whether by a tidal couple paying rotation into an orbit or by a spiral pattern carrying it outwards. It is what a disc must do before anything can fall in, because matter arriving with too much angular momentum cannot reach the centre however much energy it loses.

Named by 14 essays across 4 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Integrating the measured recession back: the Moon reaches the Earth 1.54 Gyr ago. The Earth–Moon separation and the length of the Earth's day, integrated backwards from the measured present recession rate of 3.83 cm per year. Constant-Q tidal friction makes a^(13/2) linear in time, so the history is a single line in a variable nobody plots, and it is calibrated to the laser-ranging measurement rather than to a modelled k₂/Q — the k₂/Q it implies is 0.0257, or Q = 11.6 for the Earth's k₂ of 0.299, which is a startlingly dissipative Earth. Run back at that rate the separation reaches zero 1.54 Gyr ago and crosses the Roche limit at 2.88 Earth radii only 4 years before it, so the drawing is cut off there rather than extrapolated. The Moon is 4.5 Gyr old, so this is a refutation and not a date: the present rate cannot have been the rate, and a mean Q of 34 — drawn dashed, reaching 4.51 Gyr — is the sort of value the age requires. Tidal rhythmites at 620 Myr put the day at 21.9 h and the Moon at 96.5 per cent of its present distance, and this history reads 20.1 h and 92.4 per cent — too fast and too close, which is the same failure the zero crossing is. Day length follows from total angular momentum, 23.93 h today, 9.84 h at half the present lunar distance and 4.97 h at the Roche limit, and depends on the separation alone: it is the same curve whatever Q is. The rate of lengthening the recession requires is 2.10 ms per century, against a tidal total of about 2.3 including the Sun's tide, which slows the Earth without moving the Moon, and an observed 1.75 from ancient eclipses and occultations — the shortfall being the Earth's moment of inertia falling as the mantle rebounds from the last glaciation.

A day five hours long

The tidal bulge leads, so the Earth's spin is being paid into the Moon's orbit. Run the measured payment backwards and two curves come out of one integration — a timeline that is refuted by the Moon's own age, and a day length that is refuted by nothing.

gravitation · Tides The temperature of a disc around a stellar black hole. Effective temperature against radius, in units of the inner edge, for a stellar black hole of 10 solar masses accreting 10⁻⁸ solar masses a year. Two features are structural. The profile turns over rather than rising all the way in: the factor (1 − √(r_in/r)) is the statement that no torque acts across the inner edge, so nothing is dissipated there and the peak sits at 49/36 of it, measured here at 1.361. And outside a few inner radii the run is exactly r^−3/4, drawn as the dashed line, which is what makes a disc's spectrum broad: every decade of radius contributes at a temperature a factor of 5.6 lower. The peak is 3.46·10⁶ K here, so the disc radiates in X-rays, and integrating the whole profile gives 4.72·10³⁰ W — which is GMṀ/2r_in to a per cent, half the binding energy released and no more, because the other half is still going round.

The disc that has to throw angular momentum away

Matter cannot simply fall onto a compact object. At the energy it arrives with, it has far too much angular momentum, and the only way in is for some of it to be carried outwards — which is what a disc is for.

stars · Accretion Two stars at the same point of every other diagram, 4.1 times apart in one. Above: the gravity-mode period spacing against the large frequency separation, for 90 shell-burning giants and 55 core-burning ones. These are the same stars in every other measurement. They have the same luminosity, the same temperature, the same colour, the same surface gravity and — inside the band drawn — the same Δν, which means the same mean density; the global scaling relations return the same mass and the same radius for both. What separates them is a quantity that comes from nowhere near the surface: ΔΠ₁ is set by the buoyancy frequency integrated across the core, and a core that has ignited helium is expanded and convective, so its integral is smaller and its period spacing larger. The two sequences do not touch — 61 seconds against 248 — and the gap sorts a catalogue of tens of thousands of giants into stars burning hydrogen in a shell and stars burning helium in a core, by a Fourier transform of a light curve. Below: what that looks like in the spectrum itself, drawn over two radial orders. The number of mixed ℓ = 1 modes between consecutive radial modes is Δν/(ΔΠ₁ν²), so the shell burner has about 12 of them and the core burner about 3: the star with the larger period spacing has the sparser spectrum. The picture cannot show what the same modes are also used for and cannot settle — the splitting of each mixed mode gives the rotation rate of the core separately from the envelope, and the cores come out spinning some ten times faster than the surface and a hundred times slower than any model of angular-momentum transport predicts.

Two stars only a Fourier transform can tell apart

A giant burning hydrogen in a shell and one burning helium in its core sit at the same luminosity, the same temperature and the same mean density. Every scaling relation returns the same mass and radius for both. The gravity-mode period spacing is fifty seconds for one and three hundred for the other.

stars · Asteroseismology Where a 2-armed pattern is allowed to exist in the Milky Way. Angular speed against radius, with the two combinations that matter for a pattern of 2 arms. A wave turning at 25 km/s per kpc corotates with the stars at 8.7 kpc, has an inner Lindblad resonance at 1.9 kpc and an outer one at 13.8 kpc. Between the Lindblad radii the wave propagates; at them it is absorbed. Every one of these radii is found by bisection on the curves as drawn, not quoted — and none of them is a property of the pattern alone, because κ comes from the rotation curve, which comes from the mass.

Where a pattern is allowed to turn

A spiral wave has one pattern speed, and that single number decides where in the disc it can exist at all. The boundaries are set by the frequency at which a star rocks radially about its circular orbit — a frequency the rotation curve already contains.

galaxies · Spiral structure The Sun's internal rotation: differential above 0.693 R, rigid below, and the 15 nHz between two modes. Angular velocity against fractional radius, in nanohertz, from the inversion of hundreds of thousands of measured rotational splittings. Two features had to be discovered rather than deduced. The convection zone rotates differentially in latitude — 473 nanohertz at the equator, 330 at sixty degrees — and that latitude dependence persists all the way down through it, in surfaces that are very nearly radial rather than the cylinders a rotating convective fluid was expected to produce. And below about 0.693 of the radius the latitude dependence stops: the radiative interior turns as a single rigid body at 430 nanohertz, which is a remarkable thing for a fluid with no strength to do, and requires something — most likely a weak internal magnetic field — to be enforcing it. The two regimes are joined by a shear layer a few per cent of the radius thick, the tachocline, and it is where the solar magnetic cycle is generally thought to be generated, because it is the only place in the Sun with the shear a dynamo of that strength needs. The horizontal marks are what individual modes would report: the rotation averaged over the cavity each one occupies, weighted by the time the wave spends at each radius. A mode of degree 100 is trapped near the surface and reports 473 nanohertz; one of degree 1 passes through the deep interior and reports 458. The 15-nanohertz difference between them is the measurement, and splittings are measured to about a nanohertz — which is why the profile can be resolved at all. The kernels used here have the right support and the right sense; a real inversion uses computed eigenfunctions, and its resolution below 0.2 R is poor for the reason the previous figure gives.

A fluid that turns as one piece

The Sun's surface turns faster at its equator than at its poles, and everyone expected the inside to do something similar. Below seven-tenths of the way down it does not — the radiative interior rotates as rigidly as a bell, and nothing in hydrodynamics makes a fluid do that.

stars · Internal rotation A lever 12 radii long, and the spin it removes. A magnetised stellar wind, drawn with the Alfvén surface at 12 stellar radii — the schematic distance at which the wind's inertia finally beats the field. Inside it the gas is forced to turn with the star, so every gram that leaves carries the specific angular momentum of the radius at which it broke free rather than of the surface it came from, and the lever squares: J̇ = (2/3) Ṁ Ω r_A². Beyond the surface the streamlines curve backwards, because angular momentum conservation makes the azimuthal speed fall as 1/r while the radial speed does not. With a moment of inertia coefficient of 0.073 and a mass loss of 2.3·10⁻¹⁴ solar masses a year, the star loses a fraction 2.3·10⁻¹⁴ of its mass and a fraction 3·10⁻¹¹ of its angular momentum in the same year — a ratio of 1,315, which is (2/3)(r_A/R)²/k² and nothing else. The e-folding time for the spin is 3.3·10¹⁰ years against 4.3·10¹³ years for the mass. Nothing here is to scale in one respect that matters: the wind's density falls by more than ten orders of magnitude across the drawn region, so the streamlines are drawn as though the flow were visible when almost none of it is.

A wind that takes no mass and all the spin

The Sun loses about a ten-thousandth of itself to its own wind over its whole life. It loses most of its rotation to the same wind, and the whole of that asymmetry is one geometric factor — the gas is forced to keep turning with the star until it is a dozen or more radii out from the surface it left.

stars · Magnetic braking Who holds the mass, and who holds the spin. The solar system's two ledgers on one logarithmic axis, each row a body or a group of them, with the pale bar its share of the mass and the dark bar its share of the angular momentum. Both columns are computed rather than quoted: the Sun's spin from 0.07 M R² Ω at a 25.38-day rotation, each planet's orbit from M √(GM☉ a (1 − e²)) with its own semi-major axis and eccentricity, and both sums are required to close to one part in a billion. The Sun holds 99.866 per cent of the mass and 0.61 per cent of the angular momentum. Jupiter holds 0.095 per cent of the mass and 61.1 per cent of the angular momentum, so a body a thousandth of the system by weight carries most of its rotation. The four inner planets together account for 0.0016 of it. A cloud collapsing to make this system had to move nearly all of its spin outward onto a small fraction of its mass, and the ledger is what that operation looks like when it is finished. What the figure cannot show is where the transfer happened, because everything that carried it away has either fallen in or left.

Ninety-nine per cent of the mass and none of the spin

The Sun holds 99.87 per cent of the solar system's mass and 0.6 per cent of its angular momentum. Jupiter holds a thousandth of the mass and three-fifths of the spin. That is not a curiosity of accounting — it is the record of the single operation that had to succeed before a star could form at all.

orbits · Angular momentum A collapse that stops 29 astronomical units short. Equatorial rotation speed against radius for a collapsing cloud core of 1 solar mass, turning at 10⁻¹⁴ radians a second at a radius of 0.05 parsecs, compared with the Keplerian speed at the same radius. Both axes are logarithmic; both curves are computed from the same specific angular momentum, 2.4·10¹⁶ square metres a second, held fixed. The rotation speed rises as the reciprocal of the radius and the orbital speed only as its inverse square root, so they must cross, and the crossing is measured off the drawn curves at 4.27·10¹² metres — 29 astronomical units, or 6135 solar radii. Inside that radius the material is orbiting rather than falling, and no further collapse happens along the equator at all. To arrive at a star turning once in 25.38 days the core must dispose of a factor of 1.7·10⁴ in specific angular momentum, and nothing in the collapse itself removes any: it has to be handed to a magnetic field, to a disc, or to a companion. The figure assumes uniform rotation and a spherical core, both of which are simplifications a real core violates in the direction that makes the problem worse.

A cloud that cannot become a star

A molecular cloud core turning once every twenty million years sounds like a body at rest. Conserve its angular momentum through a collapse by a factor of ten thousand and it stops at the orbit of Neptune, spinning, having failed to make anything at all.

galaxies · Star formation The Sun's internal rotation: differential above 0.693 R, rigid below, and the 15 nHz between two modes. Angular velocity against fractional radius, in nanohertz, from the inversion of hundreds of thousands of measured rotational splittings. Two features had to be discovered rather than deduced. The convection zone rotates differentially in latitude — 473 nanohertz at the equator, 330 at sixty degrees — and that latitude dependence persists all the way down through it, in surfaces that are very nearly radial rather than the cylinders a rotating convective fluid was expected to produce. And below about 0.693 of the radius the latitude dependence stops: the radiative interior turns as a single rigid body at 430 nanohertz, which is a remarkable thing for a fluid with no strength to do, and requires something — most likely a weak internal magnetic field — to be enforcing it. The two regimes are joined by a shear layer a few per cent of the radius thick, the tachocline, and it is where the solar magnetic cycle is generally thought to be generated, because it is the only place in the Sun with the shear a dynamo of that strength needs. The horizontal marks are what individual modes would report: the rotation averaged over the cavity each one occupies, weighted by the time the wave spends at each radius. A mode of degree 100 is trapped near the surface and reports 473 nanohertz; one of degree 1 passes through the deep interior and reports 458. The 15-nanohertz difference between them is the measurement, and splittings are measured to about a nanohertz — which is why the profile can be resolved at all. The kernels used here have the right support and the right sense; a real inversion uses computed eigenfunctions, and its resolution below 0.2 R is poor for the reason the previous figure gives.

A shear layer that should have spread

The Sun's convection zone turns differentially — its equator laps its poles about once every three months — and the radiative interior below turns as one rigid piece. Between them is a transition four per cent of the radius thick. Nothing in hydrodynamics keeps a velocity discontinuity that thin for four and a half billion years.

stars · Internal rotation Two measured numbers, and everything else on the page derived from them. 25 pulsars in the plane of period against period derivative, at their catalogued values. Only the two axes are measurements; the three families of contour are models. Constant surface field runs at slope −1 because B ∝ √(PṖ), constant characteristic age at slope +1 because τ = P/2Ṗ, and the two families cross the population at right angles — which is why a single dot fixes both. The Crab sits at 3.8·10¹² G and 1257 years, and its true age is 972; the millisecond pulsars at the lower left have fields ten thousand times weaker and characteristic ages of billions of years, because they were spun back up by a companion long after they died. The line at the lower right is the death line, B/P² below which the model says no pair production and therefore no radio emission — and J2144−3933 is drawn below it, an 8.5-second pulsar that is radiating anyway.

A neutron star born turning too slowly

Collapse an iron core a few thousand kilometres across down to twelve, and conservation of angular momentum multiplies its rotation rate by about eighteen thousand. A model with no transport in it delivers a newborn pulsar at the break-up limit; the ones that are observed turn twenty times slower, which is a measurement of the core before it fell.

stars · Supernovae An arm that moves angular momentum outwards, and is spent doing it. Where a 2-armed spiral pattern of 25 km/s per kiloparsec takes angular momentum from the disc and where it gives it back, against galactocentric radius, for the Milky Way's rotation curve. The resonances are found on that curve rather than placed: the inner Lindblad resonance at 1.91 kiloparsecs, corotation at 8.67, the outer Lindblad resonance at 13.80. The lower curve is the angular momentum removed per unit radius and the upper one what the wave delivers; between them runs the flux the wave carries, which is flat across the whole region where nothing is resonant, because a wave that is not interacting with anything simply travels. The two deposits are required to cancel to a part in a million — the pattern is a conveyor and keeps nothing — so the disc's total angular momentum is unchanged while its distribution is not. That is the sense in which a spiral is a machine: it moves mass inwards by moving angular momentum outwards, which is the same operation an accretion disc performs and the same one a protostellar disc must perform to make a star. The cost is paid in random motion. Every exchange heats the stellar disc, a hotter disc supports a weaker wave, and the pattern that did the work is the thing the work destroys. What the figure cannot show is the pattern's own lifetime, which is the unsettled part of the subject.

An arm that is undone by the work it does

A spiral pattern takes angular momentum from the inner disc and delivers it to the outer, which lets mass move inwards without violating anything. It is paid for in random motion, and a disc with too much random motion cannot carry a wave — so the pattern destroys the conditions it needs to exist.

galaxies · Spiral structure A bead on a rotating wire: when gas is flung off a disc. The effective potential — gravity plus the centrifugal potential in the frame rotating with the footpoint — for gas sliding along a rigid magnetic field line that leaves a Keplerian disc at 20°, 30°, 40° from the vertical, in units of GM over the footpoint radius, against distance along the line in units of that radius. The field line corotates with the disc where it is anchored, like a wire whipped round, and gas on it behaves like a bead. Close to vertical the potential rises away from the disc and the gas is bound to its footpoint. Inclined by more than 30° it falls, and gas is flung outward along the line with nothing but the rotation to drive it. The 30° threshold is exact for a Keplerian disc — the second derivative of the potential at the footpoint changes sign there — and it was the result that made magnetised disc winds a mechanism rather than a speculation.

A disc that throws its spin upward

A disc does not need turbulence to accrete. A magnetic field threading it can fling gas off its surface along field lines tilted more than thirty degrees from the vertical, and each gram flung out leaves with several times the angular momentum it had — so a wind carrying a few per cent of the inflow can drive the rest onto the star. Because it pulls on the disc's faces rather than across its edge, a wind outpulls the turbulence as soon as the field's pressure is a few ten-thousandths of the gas's.

gravitation · Magnetorotational instability The orbit that turns across the bar. The radial displacement with which a nearly circular orbit answers a weak rotating bar, against radius in kiloparsecs, in linear theory, scaled to its largest value: positive means the orbit's long axis lies along the bar, negative across it. The disc's rotation curve rises within 0.35 kpc to 220 km/s, the bar ends at 3 kpc and turns with corotation at 3.6 kpc, and the disc then has two inner Lindblad resonances, at 0.37 and 0.78 kpc (vertical lines). Without dissipation (dashed) the response diverges at each resonance and changes sign across it: orbits between corotation and the outer resonance are elongated along the bar — the x1 family that builds the bar itself — and orbits between the two resonances are elongated across it — the x2 family. Gas, which dissipates (solid, damping 8 km/s/kpc), cannot follow the flip abruptly; its orbits turn through ninety degrees over a band round the resonance, where streams of gas on neighbouring orbits cross, collide and shock. That band is where a nuclear ring forms. Near corotation the linear theory itself fails, and the curves stop short of it.

The bar leaves its gas where the orbits turn

A rotating bar in a disc galaxy drives gas inwards from kiloparsecs out, and the gas does not fall to the centre. It stops in a ring a few hundred parsecs across and forms stars there at rates the rest of the galaxy cannot match. The ring sits at the bar's inner Lindblad resonance, where the orbits that support the bar give way to orbits turned across it — so its existence says there is mass concentrated at the centre, and its size says how fast the bar turns.

galaxies · Spiral structure How far a turbulent disc bends the field it drags. The tangent of the angle by which an accretion flow bends a vertical magnetic field at the disc's surface, against the magnetic Prandtl number Pm — the ratio of the turbulent viscosity that drives the inflow to the turbulent resistivity that lets the field slip — for discs of aspect ratio 0.03, 0.05, 0.1. In a steady state the inflow drags the field in at exactly the rate it diffuses back, and that balance sets tan i = (3/2) Pm H/R. The dashed line is 30° from the vertical, the inclination a field needs before gas is flung off along it. Turbulence whose own Prandtl number is of order one bends the field by about the disc's aspect ratio, a few degrees; reaching 30° needs Pm of 13, 8, 4. The same turbulence that carries the gas in lets the field out almost as fast, because both are the same eddies.

A field the turbulence will not let in

A disc that accretes through its own turbulence drags its magnetic field inward, and the same eddies let the field slip back out almost as fast. A disc of ordinary thickness bends its field by a few degrees instead of the thirty a wind needs, so a turbulent disc cannot gather the flux that would let it stop being turbulent.

gravitation · Magnetorotational instability

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Angular momentumSpecific angular momentumDisc windAsteroseismologyCorotationDensity waveEpicyclic frequencyLindblad resonanceMagnetic brakingMagnetorotational instabilityMoment of inertiaPattern speed

All concepts