Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Magnetic braking — where it appears

The loss of a star's rotation to a magnetised wind, which forces escaping gas to keep turning with the star out to many stellar radii before releasing it. Because the lever arm is squared, a wind removing a hundredth of a per cent of the mass can remove most of the spin.

Named by 8 essays across 3 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A lever 12 radii long, and the spin it removes. A magnetised stellar wind, drawn with the Alfvén surface at 12 stellar radii — the schematic distance at which the wind's inertia finally beats the field. Inside it the gas is forced to turn with the star, so every gram that leaves carries the specific angular momentum of the radius at which it broke free rather than of the surface it came from, and the lever squares: J̇ = (2/3) Ṁ Ω r_A². Beyond the surface the streamlines curve backwards, because angular momentum conservation makes the azimuthal speed fall as 1/r while the radial speed does not. With a moment of inertia coefficient of 0.073 and a mass loss of 2.3·10⁻¹⁴ solar masses a year, the star loses a fraction 2.3·10⁻¹⁴ of its mass and a fraction 3·10⁻¹¹ of its angular momentum in the same year — a ratio of 1,315, which is (2/3)(r_A/R)²/k² and nothing else. The e-folding time for the spin is 3.3·10¹⁰ years against 4.3·10¹³ years for the mass. Nothing here is to scale in one respect that matters: the wind's density falls by more than ten orders of magnitude across the drawn region, so the streamlines are drawn as though the flow were visible when almost none of it is.

A wind that takes no mass and all the spin

The Sun loses about a ten-thousandth of itself to its own wind over its whole life. It loses most of its rotation to the same wind, and the whole of that asymmetry is one geometric factor — the gas is forced to keep turning with the star until it is a dozen or more radii out from the surface it left.

stars · Magnetic braking A period, a colour, and an age. Rotation period against colour for stars of 125, 625, 1000, 2500, 4570 million years, under the empirical relation P = t^0.5189 × 0.7725(B−V − 0.4)^0.601. The isochrones do not cross and are separated at every colour by exactly the age ratio raised to 0.5189, which is what allows a single measured period to be inverted for an age once the colour is known. The Sun, at B−V = 0.653 and 4570 million years, is placed by the relation at 26.8 days against the 25.4 days it is observed to have. Three clusters are marked at a common colour to show the spacing directly. The dashed boundary at the left is where the Rossby number — the period divided by the convective turnover time — passes 2 on the oldest isochrone, at B−V = 1.35: past that point the braking weakens and the relation is known to over-predict the age, which is the one place a rotation period stops being a clock. What the figure cannot show is the scatter, which is a few days at fixed colour and age and is the real error bar on any single star.

The clock that starts by forgetting

An ordinary star tells nothing about its age. It sits on the main sequence for billions of years at almost fixed brightness and colour, and the one property that changes monotonically is how fast it turns — but only because the braking law destroys the initial condition first, and only until it stops.

stars · Magnetic braking Who holds the mass, and who holds the spin. The solar system's two ledgers on one logarithmic axis, each row a body or a group of them, with the pale bar its share of the mass and the dark bar its share of the angular momentum. Both columns are computed rather than quoted: the Sun's spin from 0.07 M R² Ω at a 25.38-day rotation, each planet's orbit from M √(GM☉ a (1 − e²)) with its own semi-major axis and eccentricity, and both sums are required to close to one part in a billion. The Sun holds 99.866 per cent of the mass and 0.61 per cent of the angular momentum. Jupiter holds 0.095 per cent of the mass and 61.1 per cent of the angular momentum, so a body a thousandth of the system by weight carries most of its rotation. The four inner planets together account for 0.0016 of it. A cloud collapsing to make this system had to move nearly all of its spin outward onto a small fraction of its mass, and the ledger is what that operation looks like when it is finished. What the figure cannot show is where the transfer happened, because everything that carried it away has either fallen in or left.

Ninety-nine per cent of the mass and none of the spin

The Sun holds 99.87 per cent of the solar system's mass and 0.6 per cent of its angular momentum. Jupiter holds a thousandth of the mass and three-fifths of the spin. That is not a curiosity of accounting — it is the record of the single operation that had to succeed before a star could form at all.

orbits · Angular momentum A collapse that stops 29 astronomical units short. Equatorial rotation speed against radius for a collapsing cloud core of 1 solar mass, turning at 10⁻¹⁴ radians a second at a radius of 0.05 parsecs, compared with the Keplerian speed at the same radius. Both axes are logarithmic; both curves are computed from the same specific angular momentum, 2.4·10¹⁶ square metres a second, held fixed. The rotation speed rises as the reciprocal of the radius and the orbital speed only as its inverse square root, so they must cross, and the crossing is measured off the drawn curves at 4.27·10¹² metres — 29 astronomical units, or 6135 solar radii. Inside that radius the material is orbiting rather than falling, and no further collapse happens along the equator at all. To arrive at a star turning once in 25.38 days the core must dispose of a factor of 1.7·10⁴ in specific angular momentum, and nothing in the collapse itself removes any: it has to be handed to a magnetic field, to a disc, or to a companion. The figure assumes uniform rotation and a spherical core, both of which are simplifications a real core violates in the direction that makes the problem worse.

A cloud that cannot become a star

A molecular cloud core turning once every twenty million years sounds like a body at rest. Conserve its angular momentum through a collapse by a factor of ten thousand and it stops at the orbit of Neptune, spinning, having failed to make anything at all.

galaxies · Star formation A hundredfold expansion is a four-order slowdown. Equatorial rotation speed against radius for three stars leaving the main sequence at 2, 10, 100 km/s, on the single assumption that nothing exerts a torque. Both axes are logarithmic. The specific angular momentum is held fixed along each track and checked at four radii rather than assumed, so the speed falls as the reciprocal of the radius and then faster, as the moment of inertia coefficient slides from 0.073 on the main sequence to 0.02 in a centrally condensed giant envelope. A star at 100 km/s crosses the 8 km/s line — the usual boundary for calling a giant a rapid rotator — at 45.6 solar radii, and everything larger is slower. That is why the observed giants are almost all under two kilometres a second, and why the one or two per cent that are not cannot be explained by anything the star did on its own: the angular momentum has to have been delivered, by a swallowed companion or a merger. The figure assumes no mass loss, which for the largest radii drawn is the weakest of its assumptions.

A surface that slowed because the star grew

A star leaving the main sequence expands by a factor of a hundred. Conserve its angular momentum and its equator slows by four orders of magnitude, which is why every red giant is a slow rotator. One or two per cent are not, and a giant turning at fifty kilometres a second has to have been given the angular momentum by something else.

stars · Stellar evolution Three causes, three shapes, one residual. An eclipse-timing residual: the observed minus the computed time of each eclipse, against cycle number, in days. Three effects are superposed and each has its own functional form. A slow change in the orbital period — from mass transfer or from magnetic braking — integrates to a parabola. A third body in a wide orbit moves the whole binary towards and away from the observer, so its light-travel time adds a sinusoid at the third body's period. And an eccentric orbit whose apsides are precessing moves the two eclipses in opposite directions, which is a sinusoid that changes sign between primary and secondary minima. The last is why both eclipses have to be timed: a third body moves them together and apsidal motion moves them apart, and a series of primary minima alone cannot tell the two apart at all.

Three causes with three shapes in one curve

The times of eclipse in a binary star are a clock, and the clock runs late and early. Three completely different things make it do so — a third body, a changing period, and a slowly turning orbit — and they are separable only because each imposes a different shape on the residual.

stars · Binary stars In a mixed field the torque follows the dipole and ignores the rest. The torque of a field that is part dipole and part quadrupole, with the total surface strength fixed, as a fraction of a pure dipole's, against the fraction of the field strength in the dipole, for wind magnetisations of 300, 3,000, 30,000, using the broken power law fitted to simulated mixed-field winds. Above a dipole fraction of 0.39, 0.24, 0.15 respectively, the torque is exactly what the dipole component alone would give: the quadrupole has fallen below the dipole long before the wind reaches its Alfvén radius, and contributes nothing to the lever. Below it, the quadrupole sets a floor. A star whose surface is mostly quadrupole by strength can therefore be braked almost entirely by its small dipole — and a measurement of the total field says little about the torque unless it says how much of the field is dipolar.

A lever set by the dipole and not the field

A star's wind carries away its spin because the magnetic field holds the gas in step with the surface out to the Alfvén radius, and the torque goes as the square of that radius. How far out the field can hold depends less on how strong it is than on how it is arranged: a quadrupole of the same surface strength holds the Sun's wind to half the distance and brakes it at a fifth of the rate. In a mixed field only the dipole reaches far enough to matter — so the field that brakes a star is the part of it that is hardest to measure.

stars · Magnetic braking A binary that goes silent for part of its shrinking. The orbital period of a white dwarf of 0.8 M☉ and a donor from 0.5 M☉, in a one-zone evolution, against time. Mass transfer drives the period down fast while magnetic braking acts. At 3.17 hours the donor reaches 0.2 M☉ and loses its radiative core and with it the brake. Its radius, swollen by the fast transfer, relaxes and it falls inside its Roche lobe; transfer stops (dashed, no accretion, nothing to see). Gravitational waves alone close the orbit, until contact returns at 2.30 hours, 0.60 billion years later. The observed gap runs from 2.15 to 3.18 hours. The donor's thermal time at 0.2 M☉, set here to 3×10⁸ years, is chosen to place the upper edge, so that edge is fitted and the lower one is not. The period reaches a minimum of 68 minutes against an observed 80, a shortfall every model of this simplicity shares.

A binary that goes silent for an hour of period

Binaries of a white dwarf feeding off a small star can be found at almost any orbital period down to about eighty minutes, except between about two and three hours, where they are strikingly rare. They have not stopped existing there. They have stopped shining. The moment the donor loses its radiative core, the wind's magnetic brake appears to switch off. The star, swollen by the transfer it was being driven through, shrinks back inside its own Roche lobe, and the feeding stops. Only gravitational waves remain to close the orbit, and it takes them about half a billion years.

stars · Magnetic braking

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Angular momentumAngular momentum transportConvective envelopeMoment of inertiaSpecific angular momentumAlfven radiusAsteroseismologyDisc windGyrochronologyMass loss rateRossby numberSkumanich law

All concepts