Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Neutrino oscillation — where it appears

The periodic change of a neutrino from one flavour to another as it travels, because flavour states are mixtures of slightly different mass states. Its observation showed that neutrinos have mass, which the original standard model did not allow.

Named by 3 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A survival probability with a step in the middle of the spectrum. The probability that an electron neutrino made in the core of the Sun is still an electron neutrino at the Earth, against its energy, from the resonant conversion it undergoes in the Sun's own electrons: mixing angle sin²θ₁₂ = 0.307, splitting Δm² = 7.4·10⁻⁵ eV², and an electron density at the point of production of 90 moles per cubic centimetre. At low energy the matter potential is small beside the vacuum term and the probability is the vacuum average, 0.54 at 0.3 MeV (the flat limit is 0.55). At high energy the matter term dominates, the neutrino is born almost entirely in the heavier mass state, and the probability falls to 0.32 at 10 MeV, close to sin²θ₁₂. The two terms are equal at 2.1 MeV, which falls in the gap between the ⁷Be line and the bulk of the ⁸B spectrum. The points are the measured survival probabilities for each source separately — pp, ⁷Be, pep and ⁸B from Borexino, and ⁸B from SNO — and every one of them lies within about two standard deviations of the curve: low-energy neutrinos survive about half the time, high-energy ones about a third.

A survival that depends on the energy

A low-energy neutrino from the Sun reaches the Earth still an electron neutrino about half the time, and a high-energy one about a third of the time. The difference is made by the Sun's own electrons, and the energy at which it switches over — near two million electronvolts — sits in the gap between the neutrinos that never meet a resonance and the ones that all do.

stars · Solar neutrinos The rise in survival, and what two detectors see of it. The survival probability of ⁸B electron neutrinos against neutrino energy (grey), and what two detectors measure of it against the energy of the electron they record: the ratio of the counted spectrum to the one expected without conversion, for electron scattering in water (blue) and for charged-current capture on deuterium (orange), both smeared by a water detector's energy resolution. Between 3 and 10 MeV the survival probability rises by 0.122. Scattering shows a rise of 0.044 over the same recoil energies, 36 per cent of it; capture on deuterium shows 0.063, 52 per cent.

A rise a detector shrinks to a tilt

Between 10 and 3 MeV the chance that a solar neutrino arrives as it left should rise by a third of its value, and no detector has clearly seen it. Counting is not the obstacle: a large water detector has many times the exposure the rise needs. What hides it is that scattering shows only a third of the rise, spread over the spectrum as a tilt of a few per cent, and that half of the evidence for the tilt sits where the radioactive background is and the other half where an error in the energy scale looks the same.

stars · Solar neutrinos One likelihood, read with three priors. A Gaussian likelihood in the effective neutrino mass sum, peaking at −0.08 eV with a width of 0.05 eV — of the shape that combinations of microwave-background and baryon-acoustic data have been reported to give. Read with no prior it says the data prefer a negative sum. Read with the physical prior, sum ≥ 0 (shaded right of zero), its 95 per cent upper limit is 0.059 eV, at the normal-ordering floor. Read with the oscillation prior, sum ≥ 0.059 eV, its limit is 0.102 eV — but only 0.3 per cent of the likelihood lies above the floor at all, which is the more informative number: the data and the oscillation experiments disagree at about 2.8 standard deviations.

A bound below the floor is not a mass

Oscillation experiments prove that neutrinos weigh at least 0.059 eV between them. Cosmology's latest upper bound on their total is 0.064 eV, and a bound computed differently would sit below the floor. The usual reading is that cosmology has nearly weighed the neutrino. The better one is that the fit's likelihood peaks at a negative mass: the data see more clustering than any real neutrino allows, and the bound is a symptom of that tension rather than a measurement of anything.

cosmology · Density parameters

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Msw effectAdiabatic invariantBaryon acoustic oscillationsCharged currentDay night asymmetryDensity parameterDetector thresholdElectron densityEnergy scaleFlavourFree-streamingMass ordering

All concepts