Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
The collection

Every essay — page 46

One idea per essay, ordered so that the earlier ones set up the later ones — but nothing here depends on being read in sequence. Essays 901–909 of 909.

Orbits

Kepler's three laws, and the family of curves a single force allows.

The first-order perigee rate is right for a slower Sun, and half wrong for ours. The rate at which an orbit's perigee turns, in turns per orbit, against the ratio m of the Sun's motion to the orbit's, from separate integrations of a satellite with the Moon's eccentricity under a solar tide on a circular path. The first-order rate (3/4)m² gives 0.0042 at the Moon's m of 0.0748, a perigee period of 18 years. The integrations give 0.0085, 8.9 years; the Moon's perigee takes 8.85. At m = 0.01 the integration gives 8.3e-5 against a first-order 7.5e-5. So the disagreement is not a matter of neglected forces: it depends on how large m is.

A perigee that moved twice as fast as Newton

The Sun's tide on the Moon should turn the line of its perigee once in eighteen years. It takes less than nine. For sixty years that was the outstanding failure of the law of gravitation, and in 1747 Clairaut told the Paris Academy that the inverse-square law would have to be amended. Two years later he withdrew the remark. The law was right and the calculation was unfinished: the series for the perigee has a small parameter that is not small, and its second term is seventy per cent of its first.

5 figures · Perturbations

The observed sky

Coordinates, seasons, phases and shadows — geometry seen from inside it.

The Moon is late by anything from a quarter of an hour to well over an hour. Minutes between one moonrise and the next at latitude 52° N, against the Moon's longitude along its orbit, with the node at 0°. The daily delay is 10 minutes at longitude 354° and 84 at 222°. The mean of 50 minutes everyone quotes is true only as an average. A full Moon stands opposite the Sun, so it passes the shallow point near the September equinox, and the crescent passes it in spring.

A full Moon that stops rising later

The Moon rises about fifty minutes later each day. That number is an average that hardly any night obeys. At fifty-two degrees north, in late September, the full Moon rises only ten or twenty minutes later for several nights running, so that a bright Moon stands in the evening sky for most of a week, just when harvest once needed it. Nothing about the Moon changes. It is the angle at which its path meets the horizon, and that angle goes through its lowest value at one point of the ecliptic, which the autumn's full Moon happens to occupy.

5 figures · Seasons Rays from a ring of sunsets, bent into the shadow. Sunlight grazing the Earth at heights of 1, 5, 15 km, bent toward the axis by the atmosphere by twice the refraction at that height, reaching the Moon's distance, with the shadow's geometry in the plane through the Sun: the distance axis is compressed by about sixty to one against the vertical. The low rays cross the axis well before the Moon and reach the far side of the shadow; the higher rays only bend enough to enter its edge. The geometric umbra at the Moon has a radius of 4584 km, the two dashed lines, so without air the Moon would disappear inside it. Light arrives from the whole ring round the Earth, which is every sunrise and sunset at that moment.

A Moon lit by every sunset at once

With no air, the Moon would vanish inside the Earth's shadow. Instead it turns a dull copper, because the atmosphere bends sunlight round the planet, and what reaches the Moon has gone through a ring containing every sunrise and sunset on Earth at that moment. Each height in the air lights one place in the shadow, so the colour across the disc is a map of the atmosphere by altitude. It has sometimes been black, after the largest volcanoes, and that makes a century of eclipse records a measurement of the stratosphere older than any instrument sent up to sample it.

5 figures · Phases and eclipses

Spaceflight

Celestial mechanics used forwards — where to burn, and what it costs.

An outward path and a return path that cross, seen from a frame turning with the Moon. A trajectory in the Earth–Moon restricted three-body problem, in the frame rotating with the Moon. It leaves a 185 km parking orbit at 10.95 km/s, passes 716 km behind the Moon 3.0 days later, and returns to a perigee of -9 km without an engine firing, 6.0 days after departure. The crossing of the two legs is why it is called a figure of eight. The Moon's pull turns the direction of travel, and in a stationary frame the Earth is a much weaker influence on the far side; neither fact alone makes the geometry close. The Earth and Moon are at true scale.

A way home that needs no engine

A spacecraft can leave the Earth so that the Moon's gravity turns it round and sends it home with no further burn. Drawn in the frame that turns with the Moon the path is a figure of eight. It was flown to the Moon by every early Apollo mission for one reason: if the engine fails, the crew comes back. That safety is exquisitely narrow. A tenth of a metre a second at departure moves the perilune by tens of kilometres and the return by thousands, and the perilune it allows is not one that most landing sites can use.

5 figures · Patched conics Seven orbits in fifteen years, each turned from the last. The ellipse of an Aldrin cycler, semi-major axis 1.60 AU and eccentricity 0.390, in the Sun-centred frame, for 7 successive synodic periods, the line of apsides advanced by 48.7° each time. The inner circle is the Earth's orbit and the next is Mars's. Over about fifteen years the pattern has gone once round. The same spacecraft would need to be carried from each ellipse to the next by a flyby of the Earth, or a small burn. The drawing is the circular, coplanar case; the real one has to be recalculated for the actual orbit of Mars.

A timetable that orbits the Sun

Every trip to Mars leaves when the planets line up and accelerates everything it carries. Buzz Aldrin proposed in 1985 that there need be only one departure: a large ship on an orbit that returns to the Earth each synodic period, with crews riding small taxis out to catch it. The orbit almost exists without any propellant. It has a semi-major axis fixed by a single condition, an aphelion that passes Mars with nothing asked for, and one unavoidable bill: it must turn by about fifty degrees every twenty-six months, and the Earth can pay for all but seven of the eighty the turn requires.

5 figures · Launch windows

Starlight

Distance, brightness and colour: what can be measured when nothing can be visited.

Almost everything is ionised, and then almost nothing is. The ionised fraction of hydrogen against distance from an O7 star in gas of 10 per cubic centimetre, from integrating photoionisation balance outward, in units of the counted radius of 14.62 parsecs. The fraction is near one until about the edge and then falls from 90% to 10% within 0.192 parsecs, 1.3% of the radius. That width is about 18 mean free paths of an ionising photon in neutral gas (0.011 pc). Nothing about the star sets it. A region with no gradual boundary is a surprising result of a smooth input, and it comes from the fact that a photon that gets as far as the neutral gas is absorbed at once.

An ionised sphere that is a count of photons

A hot star sits in a cloud of hydrogen and ionises it, out to a radius, and there the ionisation stops within a tiny fraction of the distance. That edge was predicted in 1939 from a single count: every recombination uses up one photon, so the star can hold ionised only as many atoms as its light can pay for. By the equation that describes a stellar atmosphere at the same temperature, the same gas would hold ten orders of magnitude fewer neutral atoms than it does. In a nebula the temperature is not what decides the ionisation. A budget is.

5 figures · Ionisation Whether an excited ion radiates depends only on what reaches it first. The rate per second at which an oxygen ion in the state that gives the 5007 Å line loses its energy, by radiating and by collision, against electron density, both logarithmic. Radiating takes about 51 seconds whatever the surroundings. Collisions speed up with density and cross at 6.8e+5 per cubic centimetre. The air at the Earth's surface, 2.7×10¹⁹ molecules per cubic centimetre, has a collision rate about 4×10¹³ times the radiative one, so the ion loses its energy without radiating. A nebula at 10⁴ per cubic centimetre is sixty times below the crossing. The line has a tiny transition probability; the atom was never forbidden to make it, and it requires only the emptiness in which there is time.

An element that was only empty space

In 1864 William Huggins turned a spectroscope on a planetary nebula and saw a bright green line that matched nothing on Earth. It was given a name, nebulium, and it was treated as a new element for sixty years, until the periodic table had no room left for it. In 1927 Ira Bowen showed it was ordinary oxygen, emitting by a route that collisions close long before any laboratory vacuum could reach it. The line was never forbidden. It simply needs about a minute of being left alone, and nothing on Earth gets that.

5 figures · Spectra

Stars

The diagram that sorted them, and the one quantity that decides a star's whole life.

A binary that goes silent for part of its shrinking. The orbital period of a white dwarf of 0.8 M☉ and a donor from 0.5 M☉, in a one-zone evolution, against time. Mass transfer drives the period down fast while magnetic braking acts. At 3.17 hours the donor reaches 0.2 M☉ and loses its radiative core and with it the brake. Its radius, swollen by the fast transfer, relaxes and it falls inside its Roche lobe; transfer stops (dashed, no accretion, nothing to see). Gravitational waves alone close the orbit, until contact returns at 2.30 hours, 0.60 billion years later. The observed gap runs from 2.15 to 3.18 hours. The donor's thermal time at 0.2 M☉, set here to 3×10⁸ years, is chosen to place the upper edge, so that edge is fitted and the lower one is not. The period reaches a minimum of 68 minutes against an observed 80, a shortfall every model of this simplicity shares.

A binary that goes silent for an hour of period

Binaries of a white dwarf feeding off a small star can be found at almost any orbital period down to about eighty minutes, except between about two and three hours, where they are strikingly rare. They have not stopped existing there. They have stopped shining. The moment the donor loses its radiative core, the wind's magnetic brake appears to switch off. The star, swollen by the transfer it was being driven through, shrinks back inside its own Roche lobe, and the feeding stops. Only gravitational waves remain to close the orbit, and it takes them about half a billion years.

5 figures · Magnetic braking A reservoir so large that it does not notice. The fractional increase in the heat of the Sun's convective envelope if a fraction 0.001, 0.003, 0.01 of the surface is held under spots, against time. The envelope holds about 7×10⁴⁵ erg, 58 thousand years of the Sun's light. Spots covering 0.3% of the surface for an eleven-year cycle add 4.2e-7 of that, a temperature change of 0.4 parts per million at most, spread over the whole envelope. So the blocked heat simply remains in the star, and the surface flux shows the deficit. It levels off only after the envelope's thermal time, when the star has adjusted.

A spot whose missing heat goes nowhere

A sunspot blocks most of the energy trying to come up beneath it, and a large group visibly dims the whole Sun by a thousandth. Energy is conserved, so the blocked flux ought to come out somewhere else, and for a century observers looked for the bright ring around every spot. There is none to speak of. The heat has gone into the rest of the convection zone, spread so fast and so widely that the surface cannot notice, and it will stay there for longer than human history. For the time being the Sun simply is fainter, without any contradiction.

6 figures · Energy transport

Every sequence · Every named object · Search