Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Series

Libration — the series

4 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. The sub-Earth point over 400 days. Where on the Moon the Earth stands overhead, in selenographic longitude and latitude, sampled over 400 days. The excursion in longitude is the equation of centre — the Moon's rotation is uniform and its orbital motion is not, so the face runs alternately ahead and behind by up to 6.3° — and the excursion in latitude is the tilt of its equator, up to 6.7°. The two run on months of different length, so the track never repeats.

    The face that is not quite fixed

    The Moon keeps one face turned toward the Earth, and the sentence is exactly true only of a fictitious Moon on a circular orbit. The real one rocks by a few degrees each month, in two directions and for two unrelated reasons, and the rocking has shown 59 per cent of its surface to people who never left the ground.

    part 1 · sky
  2. Mercury's forced libration: 38.5″ against the 16.2″ a solid body would give. The measurement that finds a liquid core from a distance. A body on an eccentric orbit does not feel a steady torque: the pull on its equatorial bulge swings back and forth through the orbit, and the body rocks about its mean rotation by a small angle. How small depends on how much moment of inertia has to be rocked, and on nothing else — every other factor in the problem belongs to the orbit or to the body's own measured gravity field. The horizontal axis is therefore the fraction of the total polar moment that participates, one if the whole body turns rigidly together, and the vertical axis is the resulting amplitude. The curve is a rectangular hyperbola, because the same torque applied to less moment produces proportionally more angle. A Mercury turning in one piece would librate by 16.2 arcseconds. Radar measurements of the actual rocking give 38.5 ± 1.6, which is 2.38 times larger and many standard deviations away, so only 42 per cent of the moment is being rocked at all. The other 58 per cent is not following the mantle on an eighty-eight-day timescale, and the only way for an interior not to follow its own mantle is for the two to be separated by a liquid. That is how a planet nobody has landed on was shown to have a molten core — by watching, from Earth, the tiny irregularity of its turning. The figure treats the librating shell as rigid, which is right for a rocky mantle and wrong for an ice shell floating on an ocean, where the shell's own elasticity enters at the same level as the effect.

    Four numbers that weigh a planet's core

    Mercury rocks about its mean rotation by thirty-eight arcseconds, which is more than twice what a planet turning in one piece could manage. The excess says that most of the planet's moment of inertia is not following the mantle on an eighty-eight-day timescale, and the only thing that does not follow a mantle is a liquid.

    part 2 · sky
  3. A free libration does not last. How long a free libration survives before tidal dissipation removes it, against the tidal quality factor, for four locked bodies — with the age of the solar system marked. A lightly damped oscillator loses its amplitude in about Q of its own periods, and a free libration's period is years, so the decay time is thousands to hundreds of thousands of years for any plausible Q. Against 4.5 billion years that is instantaneous. A free libration that is observed today was excited within the last geological instant, and one that is not observed bounds how much has happened. The Moon's is detected, at a few arcseconds, and requires something recent — an impact, a core–mantle interaction, or a resonance passage. Mercury's has been searched for and not found, and the upper limit is the constraint.

    A rocking nobody started

    A locked body is a pendulum, and a pendulum has a period of its own. That free libration is damped by tides in thousands of years, so any body still oscillating at its own frequency was disturbed in the last geological instant — and the Moon is, while Mercury is not.

    part 3 · sky
  4. The Moon's Cassini states as it recedes. The angle between the Moon's spin axis and its orbit normal in each Cassini state, signed so that the present state is positive, against the Earth–Moon distance in Earth radii, for the Moon's present shape (β = (C − A)/B fixed) and orbital inclination. Today the Moon sits in Cassini state 2 at 6.68°. Closer in, two more states exist, a low-obliquity state 1 and an unstable state 4; they meet and vanish at 33.8 Earth radii, where the spin-axis precession, which weakens as the cube of the distance, falls to the critical fraction of the orbit's regression. A Moon that formed close to the Earth sat in state 1 at small obliquity, growing to 21° as it receded; at 33.8 Earth radii that state disappeared from under it, and it had to move to state 2 — which at that distance is at 46°. Since then, the obliquity has relaxed along state 2 to its present value.

    A state the Moon had to jump to

    The Moon's spin axis sits a degree and a half from the ecliptic pole, locked in a geometry Cassini described in 1693. The lock is an equilibrium between the Earth's torque on the Moon's bulge and the slow regression of its orbit, and both depend on the Moon's distance. When the Moon was closer than about 34 Earth radii there were two more equilibria — and the one it almost certainly occupied vanished as it receded, leaving it to jump to the present one at an obliquity near 45°.

    part 4 · sky

All series