Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Astrometric reference — where it appears

A compact source of known position, observed alternately with a target so the atmosphere above both can be differenced. The residual error grows as the five-sixths power of the angle between them, so a close reference is worth a great deal.

Named by 2 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

20 closure phases, unmoved by an atmosphere that ruins every baseline. Closure phase measured against closure phase true, for all 20 triangles of a 6-antenna array observing a binary 3.2 mas apart with a flux ratio of 0.35. Each antenna has been given an independent atmospheric phase of 65° rms, which corrupts the individual baseline phases by 102° rms — several times the 31.2° the source itself produces, so no single visibility phase in this simulation carries usable information. Every point here nonetheless sits exactly on the diagonal: the per-antenna terms cancel identically round any triangle, and the largest departure over all 20 is 2.5e-14 degrees, which is round-off. The price is in the counting. 6 antennas give 15 baseline phases of which 5 are consumed by the unknowns, so of the 20 triangles only 10 closures are independent — a fraction (N−2)/N = 0.667 of the phase information. For two antennas that fraction is zero and there is no closure at all; the Event Horizon Telescope's image rests on quantities of this kind and on no absolute phase whatever.

A phase that survives what corrupts it

An atmosphere over each antenna adds an unknown to the phase of every baseline that antenna takes part in. Sum the phases round a triangle and every one of those unknowns cancels identically — which is the reason an image can be made across ten thousand kilometres, and the reason it has no position on the sky.

starlight · Interferometry The position closure discards, and what it costs to buy back. The astrometric error left after phase referencing, against how far away the calibrator is, for three switching cadences, on a 8000-kilometre baseline at 1.3 mm. Referencing gives up the immunity closure quantities have: instead of forming a combination the atmosphere cannot enter, it measures the atmosphere on a nearby source and subtracts it, which recovers the absolute position and leaves behind whatever differs between the two lines of sight. That difference is governed by the Kolmogorov structure function, which rises as the five-thirds power of a separation, so the phase residual and therefore the position error rise as the five-sixths power of the separation, which the drawn spatial term reproduces exactly. Below about 1.7 degrees at the fastest cadence the curves flatten, because there the atmosphere's change between one visit to the calibrator and the next is the larger of the two differences and the separation has stopped mattering. The consequence is a premium on finding a close calibrator: at one degree the error is 2 microarcseconds and at eight it is 5, and the sky is not dense in compact bright sources. The three curves are the other half of the trade — a faster cycle freezes the atmosphere better and spends more of the observation looking at the calibrator, so the optimum is where the two losses meet rather than as fast as the hardware allows.

The position closure throws away

A closure phase is immune to the atmosphere because it cannot see anything that looks like a per-antenna error — and a displacement of the source on the sky looks exactly like one. Recovering where a source is means giving that immunity up on purpose, measuring the atmosphere on a neighbour instead of cancelling it, and paying for the difference between two directions.

starlight · Interferometry

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Closure phaseAntenna gainAperture synthesisAtmospheric coherence timeAtmospheric turbulenceCalibratorClosure amplitudeCoherence timeDegrees of freedomThe Event Horizon TelescopeFringe trackingImage reconstruction

All concepts