Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Atmospheric turbulence — where it appears

Refractive-index fluctuations in the air above a telescope, stirred by wind shear and convection. Its phase differences follow a Kolmogorov structure function rising as the five-thirds power of separation, which sets both the seeing and the limit on phase referencing.

Named by 4 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Resolution stops improving at 10 cm of aperture. Angular resolution against aperture at 500 nm, both logarithmic. The falling line is diffraction alone, 1.03 λ/D, which is what a telescope in vacuum delivers and has no floor. The curve is the same telescope under an atmosphere of Fried parameter r₀ = 10 cm, combining diffraction and seeing in quadrature: it follows the diffraction line while D < r₀ and then bends onto a plateau at 0.98 λ/r₀ = 1.01″. An amateur's 100 mm at 0.1 m would resolve 1.062″ above the air and delivers 1.47″ through it; a metre at 1 m would resolve 0.106″ above the air and delivers 1.02″ through it; the VLT at 8.2 m would resolve 0.013″ above the air and delivers 1.01″ through it; the ELT at 39 m would resolve 0.003″ above the air and delivers 1.01″ through it. At 39 m the atmosphere is costing a factor of 371: the aperture is 390 coherence lengths across and every one of the 152,100 patches it collects arrives with a phase of its own. What the extra aperture still buys is photons and speckles, and those two are what adaptive optics and speckle interferometry respectively spend to get the falling line back.

A ten-metre mirror that resolves like a ten-centimetre one

The atmosphere delivers a wavefront in patches about ten centimetres across, and an aperture larger than a patch collects patches rather than detail. Resolution stops improving at that size — and what the extra aperture keeps buying is photons and speckles, which is why there are two entirely different ways out.

sky · Seeing The position closure discards, and what it costs to buy back. The astrometric error left after phase referencing, against how far away the calibrator is, for three switching cadences, on a 8000-kilometre baseline at 1.3 mm. Referencing gives up the immunity closure quantities have: instead of forming a combination the atmosphere cannot enter, it measures the atmosphere on a nearby source and subtracts it, which recovers the absolute position and leaves behind whatever differs between the two lines of sight. That difference is governed by the Kolmogorov structure function, which rises as the five-thirds power of a separation, so the phase residual and therefore the position error rise as the five-sixths power of the separation, which the drawn spatial term reproduces exactly. Below about 1.7 degrees at the fastest cadence the curves flatten, because there the atmosphere's change between one visit to the calibrator and the next is the larger of the two differences and the separation has stopped mattering. The consequence is a premium on finding a close calibrator: at one degree the error is 2 microarcseconds and at eight it is 5, and the sky is not dense in compact bright sources. The three curves are the other half of the trade — a faster cycle freezes the atmosphere better and spends more of the observation looking at the calibrator, so the optimum is where the two losses meet rather than as fast as the hardware allows.

The position closure throws away

A closure phase is immune to the atmosphere because it cannot see anything that looks like a per-antenna error — and a displacement of the source on the sky looks exactly like one. Recovering where a source is means giving that immunity up on purpose, measuring the atmosphere on a neighbour instead of cancelling it, and paying for the difference between two directions.

starlight · Interferometry How sharp a single short exposure is, for three sizes of telescope. The distribution of the Strehl ratio — the peak brightness of a star's image as a fraction of a perfect telescope's — for 600 independent short exposures through simulated Kolmogorov turbulence, with image motion removed, for telescopes 4, 7, 10 times the Fried parameter r₀ across. The screens' mean phase variance matches the analytic value for tilt-removed turbulence to within 2 per cent. At D/r₀ = 4 the exposures spread over the whole range and 31 per cent are better than 0.37 — a phase error under one radian, a nearly diffraction-limited image. At 7 the distribution has slid to low Strehl ratios and none of the 600 are that good; at 10, none. The best frames at the larger ratios are still several times sharper than the average, which is what practical selection keeps. The atmosphere is not uniformly bad: every so often, for a few milliseconds, the turbulence over a small enough aperture happens to be nearly flat, and those instants are a diffraction-limited telescope for free.

A sharp image kept by throwing the rest away

The atmosphere does not blur every instant equally. Now and then, for a few milliseconds, the air over a small telescope is almost flat, and a short exposure taken then is as sharp as the mirror allows. How often that happens falls as the exponential of the square of the telescope's size — which is why the method works on a two-metre mirror in the red and nowhere else.

sky · Seeing A lucky frame stays lucky further from the star when the high air was quiet. The mean Strehl ratio of short exposures of a target at a separation from an on-axis reference star, against the shift of the high turbulent layer between the two lines of sight in units of the aperture, s = θh/D — 0.50 of an aperture is 32 arcseconds for a 2.5-metre telescope and a layer at 8 km. The atmosphere has 50 per cent of its turbulence at the ground and the rest high, with D/r₀ = 7, and 1600 simulated frames. Frames are selected by the reference star's sharpness. When the two layers' strengths vary from frame to frame (log-normal, width 0.6), the best 2 per cent start at a mean Strehl of 0.523 and keep 0.339 at the largest separation; when the strengths are steady, the best frames start at 0.321 and fall to 0.105. In the first case the Strehl never falls to six-tenths of its on-axis value within the range drawn; in the second it does so at s = 0.208, 13 arcseconds. Selecting frames by one star selects, preferentially, the moments when the high layer was weak — and a weak high layer is weak for every star in the field.

Luck that reaches as far as the quiet air

Lucky imaging keeps the rare short exposures in which a reference star happens to be sharp, and a sharp star says the air was flat along one line of sight. A target a few arcseconds away looks through different air. It turns out to be sharper in those frames than the geometry of a single turbulent layer allows, because choosing a lucky instant chooses, preferentially, an instant when the high turbulence was weak — and weakness, unlike the pattern of the turbulence, is shared across the field.

sky · Seeing

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Adaptive opticsFried parameterSeeingDiffraction limitIsoplanatic angleLucky imagingSpeckleStrehl ratioAngular resolutionAnisoplanatismAstrometric referenceCalibrator

All concepts