Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Black hole spin — where it appears

The second and last number a black hole in equilibrium has, written as a = Jc/GM² and lying between zero and one. It fixes the radius of the last stable orbit and therefore how much light a kilogram of infalling matter can emit before it disappears.

Named by 3 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Also named here as kerr metric — the same set of essays touches all of them, so they are one junction rather than several.

From six gravitational radii to one. The radius of the innermost stable circular orbit against the dimensionless spin a = Jc/GM², in units of GM/c², for orbits prograde and retrograde with the hole's rotation. Both curves are the Bardeen–Press–Teukolsky expression and are checked at the three places it has exact values: 6 at zero spin, and 1 and 9 at the extremal limit. The separation is the observable consequence of frame dragging — space near the hole is itself circulating, so an orbit going the same way can stay closer before it becomes unstable, and one going the other way cannot come as close as a non-rotating hole allows. The prograde branch is required to fall and the retrograde branch to rise at every step drawn, which is a claim about the direction of the effect rather than about its size. The marked spin of 0.998 is not the extremal value but the equilibrium a hole fed by a thin disc actually reaches, because photons emitted by the disc are preferentially captured on retrograde orbits and spin the hole down again. Nothing here depends on what the hole is made of: two numbers fix the whole geometry, and this figure is the first of them holding still while the second moves.

The second number a black hole has

A black hole in equilibrium is described by its mass and its spin, and nothing else. The mass decides how strongly it pulls. The spin decides how much light a kilogram of infalling matter can emit before it disappears — and between the two extremes that figure changes by a factor of seven.

gravitation · Black hole spin The spin a mismeasured radius reads as. The spin inferred from the disc's inner radius, against the fractional error in that radius, for four true spins. Both spectral methods reduce to one measurement — where the disc stops — and one conversion, the ISCO relation, so this figure is the error propagation both of them share. The behaviour is not uniform and it is the reverse of what the difficulty of the measurement suggests. A ten per cent error reads a hole of true spin 0.3 as anywhere from 0.16 to 0.44, while the same ten per cent moves a hole of true spin 0.99 only between 0.98 and 1.00. The reason is that the ISCO falls from six gravitational radii to one over the whole range of spin and does most of that falling in the last few per cent, so near the extremal limit a small change in radius is a large change in spin and the inversion is stiff. The published spins clustering near 0.9 and above are therefore the ones least sensitive to the systematics, and a published spin of 0.3 carries an error bar the method cannot really support. An overestimated radius always reads slow, so anything that stops the disc outside the last stable orbit biases every measurement the same way.

A spin that is one length in disguise

Both ways of measuring a black hole's spin from its light measure the same thing — where the accretion disc stops — and convert it through the same relation. That conversion is stiff at high spin and slack at low, so the published spins near one are the trustworthy ones and the published spins near a third are barely measurements.

gravitation · Black hole spin The horizon and the orbit that cannot come back, against the hole's spin. Two radii round a rotating black hole, in gravitational radii GM/c², against its spin a from −1 (an orbit against the rotation) to +1 (with it), for orbits in the equatorial plane. The lower curve is the horizon, 1 + √(1 − a²), which is the same whichever way the orbit goes. The upper one is the marginally bound orbit, 2 − a + 2√(1 − a): the closest a body falling in from far away can pass and still escape back out. For a hole with no spin the horizon is at 2 and the marginally bound orbit at 4 — twice as far out. With maximal spin the marginally bound orbit comes in to 1.09 for a prograde orbit (a = 0.998) and moves out to 5.83 for a retrograde one. A star whose tidal radius lies inside this curve is swallowed whole, so the curve, not the horizon, is the line a disruption flare is measured against — and it moves by a factor of 5.3 with the spin.

The line a star is swallowed at is not the horizon

A star torn apart by a black hole makes a flare, and a star swallowed whole makes nothing, so the heaviest hole that can produce a flare is a measurement. That ceiling is set not at the horizon but at the closest orbit from which infalling matter can still come back out — twice as far out for a hole that does not spin, and moved by a factor of five by the hole's rotation.

galaxies · Tidal disruption

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Kerr metricAccretion discEvent horizonFrame draggingInnermost stable circular orbitIron lineRadiative efficiencyRelativistic beamingAngular momentumContinuum fittingEddington limitEffective potential

All concepts