Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Chirp mass — where it appears

The combination of two masses that fixes how fast a gravitational-wave inspiral sweeps upwards in frequency. It is the only mass parameter the early signal contains, and it is measured to several figures while the individual masses are not.

Named by 6 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

GW150914: 33 Hz to 250 Hz in 0.22 seconds. The strain of GW150914 — two black holes — through the last 0.22 seconds before merger, computed from the quadrupole sweep at the chirp mass its fit returned, 28.716 solar masses, and drawn at the luminosity distance it returned, 440 megaparsecs. Two things rise together and neither is free to rise on its own: the frequency goes from 33 Hz to 250 Hz, and the envelope — the outer curve — grows by a factor of 3.9, because the amplitude goes as f^2/3 and nothing else in it changes over so short a span. The vertical axis is in units of 10⁻²¹, so the peak here is a fractional length change of about 2.9·10⁻²¹: over the four kilometres of an interferometer arm that is 1.2·10⁻¹⁷ metres, a thousandth of the width of a proton. The chirp mass is not fitted to the amplitude at all — it comes from the spacing of these zero crossings, which is why it is the best-determined number in the whole event and why the distance, which does come from the amplitude, is the worst.

A distance with no ladder under it

The frequency sweep of an inspiral fixes the chirp mass with no distance in it, and the amplitude then gives the luminosity distance directly, because one expression fixes both. That is a distance measured with nothing calibrated beneath it — and its error budget is one angle.

gravitation · Gravitational waves Nothing visible in any pulsar, and a quadrupole in the angle between them. Above: 4 millisecond pulsars' timing residuals over 15 years, at the few hundred nanoseconds a good one reaches. Each wanders, and none of them shows anything a reader could call a signal; a gravitational-wave background of amplitude 2.4·10⁻¹⁵ at one cycle per year contributes a common part to all of them that is smaller than each pulsar's own red noise. Below: the correlation between pairs, against the angle on the sky between them. 2211 pairs out of 67 pulsars, binned into 15 angles, against three curves with no free parameters between them. A quadrupolar background gives the Hellings–Downs shape — positive for nearby pulsars, negative near 83°, and back up to exactly half its zero-separation value at 180° because a background looks the same in opposite directions. An error in the observatory clock would give a flat line, because it shifts every pulsar identically. An error in the solar-system ephemeris would give a cosine, because it moves the barycentre in one direction. The drawn points prefer the quadrupole over the flat line by Δχ² = 358. That is the detection: not a waveform, not an event, not a moment — a shape in an angle, accumulated over fifteen years, on data taken for another purpose entirely.

A detector the size of the galaxy

At a nanohertz no instrument can be built, so the clocks already in the sky are used instead. The signal is in no single pulsar's data — it is in the correlation between pairs as a function of the angle between them, and that curve has no free parameters at all.

gravitation · Gravitational waves One measured number, and every pair of masses that produces it. The plane of the two component masses of an inspiralling binary, with three curves of constant chirp mass across it. The middle one is GW150914's value of 28.7 solar masses, and the chirp mass recovered from the coordinates of the drawn curve varies along its whole length by 7.4e-14 per cent — which is the point: every binary on that line radiates the same frequency sweep at leading order, so the early inspiral cannot tell them apart. Two of them are marked. An equal pair of 33.0 and 33.0 solar masses and a lopsided pair of 63.6 and 18.4 sit on the same contour, and their total masses differ by a factor of 1.24. What separates them is the mass ratio, which enters the phasing only at the first post-Newtonian order, suppressed by the square of the orbital speed in units of the speed of light — small through the hundreds of cycles that carry most of the signal, and appreciable only in the last few, where that speed approaches a third of c. So the chirp mass is a measurement and the individual masses are an inference from the end of the signal, which is exactly the part a detector's high-frequency noise eats first.

One number where two masses were

The hundreds of orbits an inspiralling binary completes inside a detector's band depend on its two masses only through one combination of them. Every pair on that contour radiates an identical sweep, so the early signal — which carries nearly all the signal-to-noise — cannot say which pair it was.

gravitation · Gravitational waves Every pair arrives circular. Eccentricity against gravitational-wave frequency for four binaries of 30 and 30 solar masses, each starting at 0.2 astronomical units with an eccentricity of 0.3, 0.7, 0.9, 0.99. Both axes are logarithmic and the tracks run left to right as the orbit shrinks. The curves are Peters' closed solution a(e), and they are checked against Peters' differential equation at three eccentricities on each track rather than against the integral they came from. The ordering is preserved — a pair that starts rounder stays rounder — but by the time the orbit is radiating at 10 hertz, where a ground-based detector begins to hear it, the four eccentricities are 8.8·10⁻⁸, 5.6·10⁻⁷, 3.6·10⁻⁶, 1.5·10⁻⁴. All four are far below anything a detector could measure. That is the figure's whole content and it is a strong statement: radiation reaction removes angular momentum faster, relative to energy, than a circular orbit would need, so eccentricity is destroyed on the way in. A binary observed to be eccentric in band therefore cannot have spent long shrinking quietly, and must have been put on that orbit recently — by a third body, or in the crowded centre of a cluster. The figure assumes the two bodies are points and nothing else acts on them, which is exactly the assumption an eccentric detection would refute.

Every pair arrives circular

Gravitational radiation drains a binary's energy and its angular momentum at rates that do not keep step, and the mismatch destroys eccentricity far faster than it shrinks the orbit. A pair that starts at 0.99 and spirals in from a fifth of an astronomical unit is round to better than a part in a hundred million by the time a detector can hear it.

gravitation · Gravitational waves What a deformability is made of. The two factors of the tidal deformability Λ = ⅔ k₂ C⁻⁵ for a 1.4 solar-mass neutron star, each relative to its value at 12 km, on a logarithmic scale, against the star's radius. The Love number k₂ — the same number that measures a moon's response to a planet's tide — rises by a factor of 1.6 between 10 and 14 km; the inverse fifth power of the compactness rises by 5.4. Of the change in Λ across that range, 78 per cent, on a logarithmic scale, comes from the compactness: most of what a deformability measures is how large the star is for its mass. The Love number carries the rest: how centrally concentrated the matter is, which is where the equation of state enters beyond the radius.

A Love number measured at nuclear density

The number that told Cassini there was water under Titan's ice is defined the same way for a neutron star, and in the last tenth of a second before two of them merge it changes the shape of the gravitational wave they emit. What the wave measures is mostly not the Love number itself but the star's size, raised to the sixth power — which makes a faint tidal signal into one of the few direct measurements of how large matter at nuclear density lets a star be.

gravitation · Love numbers Precession cycles grow as the inverse of the lowest frequency heard. The number of times the orbital plane precesses between a detector's lowest frequency and the last stable orbit, against that lowest frequency, both on logarithmic scales, for pairs of 36 + 29 solar masses, 10 + 8 solar masses, 8 + 1.4 solar masses with spins tilted into the orbital plane. The count grows as the inverse of the lowest frequency — the slopes are −1.07, −1.02, −1.01. Above 20 Hz, the limit of the ground-based detectors that have heard every merger so far, the heaviest pair precesses 0.9 times, the middle 4.4 and the lightest 6.2. Above 5 Hz the counts are 4.9, 18.7, 25.5; above 1 Hz, 26, 95, 129.

Precessions bought one hertz at a time

A merging pair of black holes whose spins are tilted makes its orbital plane wobble, and the wobble is the only part of the signal that separates one hole's spin from the other's. How many wobbles a detector records is a simple formula: two plus three halves of the mass ratio, divided by the total mass and by the lowest frequency the detector can hear. The detectors that have heard every merger so far stop at twenty hertz, where a typical heavy pair wobbles less than once.

gravitation · Black hole spin

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

InspiralMatched filteringAngular momentumGravitational wavesLuminosity distanceStandard sirenBinary black holeBlack hole spinCharacteristic strainCircularisationCoalescenceCompact binary

All concepts