Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Light-travel time — where it appears

The interval light spends in flight across a separation, which is what a timing measurement records and only afterwards becomes a distance. It is what a pulsar timing solution measures across a binary orbit, and it must be removed from every radial velocity before the star's own motion can be read.

Named by 7 essays across 5 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

PSR B1913+16: 45 years of periastron arriving 88 seconds early. The cumulative shift of periastron passage for PSR B1913+16, Δt = ½(Ṗ_b/P_b)T², over 45 years from its discovery in 1975. The orbital period is 0.322997449 days and is measured to be shortening at 2.423e-12 seconds per second — a change in the twelfth decimal place, which over a career accumulates to 87.5 seconds. That is the whole reason the effect is measurable. Ṗ_b is taken here as a measured quantity and no radiated power is derived from it; the parabola is the general-relativistic prediction as published, and the points are that prediction scaled by the published ratio of observed to predicted decay, 0.997 ± 0.002 (Hulse & Taylor 1975; Weisberg & Huckins 2016), which is how the agreement is quoted. The error bars are drawn: at the last point the bar is 1.25 px tall against a dot 9 pixels across, so they are invisible, and their invisibility is the result. The campaign has run 45 years.

An orbit measured to be shrinking

A 7.75-hour orbital period that shortens by 68 nanoseconds each turn is beyond any single measurement, and unmissable after fifty thousand of them, because the shift accumulates as the square of the elapsed time. Forty-five years of pulse arrival times have made it 87.5 seconds, which is why the rate is a measured quantity rather than an inferred one.

gravitation · Relativistic orbits A 20-day delay, recovered at 20 days from two curves that share no wavelength. Above: a quasar's continuum, drawn as a damped random walk with a 90-day damping time, and the broad emission line responding to it. The line curve is the continuum convolved with a top-hat response of half-width 20 days, so it is later and smoother — it varies only 51 per cent as much, because at any instant it is an average of the continuum over a range of light-travel times. Below: the cross-correlation of the two, which peaks at 20 days. That number is a length: 20 light-days is 5.2·10¹⁴ metres, or 3463 astronomical units, and it has been measured for an object that subtends 3.5·10⁻⁵ arcseconds at a hundred megaparsecs — some thirty times finer than the best optical interferometry has ever resolved anything, and reached here with a photometer and a clock. The irregularity of the continuum is what makes this work. A periodic source would give a cross-correlation with many equal peaks and no way to choose; a random one gives a single peak, and the whole method rests on active nuclei being erratic.

A size measured from a delay

An active nucleus at redshift two is a point source in every telescope ever built, and its central mass is measured anyway. The continuum varies, the broad lines follow days later, and the lag is a light-travel time — which is a length, recovered from two light curves that share no wavelength.

galaxies · Quasars Four distances to the same galaxy. Four quantities all called "the distance", against redshift, at a Hubble constant of 67.36 km/s/Mpc, a matter density parameter of 0.3153 and a dark-energy parameter of 0.6847. They agree below z ≈ 0.1 and then part company completely. Comoving distance is the separation now, and it is what a map of the universe is drawn in. Luminosity distance is what a brightness gives, and it is larger by (1+z) because the photons arrive both redshifted and spread out in time. Light-travel distance is the age difference times c, and it is bounded by the age of the universe. Angular-diameter distance is what an angle gives, and it is the odd one: it rises, turns over at z = 1.59 where it reaches 1.79 Gpc, and falls thereafter. Past that redshift a galaxy of fixed size looks bigger the further away it is, because the universe it is being seen across was smaller when the light left it. At z = 10 the four differ by a factor of 121 between the largest and the smallest, so a sentence quoting a cosmological distance without saying which one has not given a number.

Four distances to the same galaxy

Inside the Local Group the word "distance" has one meaning. Past a redshift of about a tenth it has four, they disagree by factors of a hundred by the time the light is old, and one of them stops increasing and starts coming back.

cosmology · Distance ladder Three causes, three shapes, one residual. An eclipse-timing residual: the observed minus the computed time of each eclipse, against cycle number, in days. Three effects are superposed and each has its own functional form. A slow change in the orbital period — from mass transfer or from magnetic braking — integrates to a parabola. A third body in a wide orbit moves the whole binary towards and away from the observer, so its light-travel time adds a sinusoid at the third body's period. And an eccentric orbit whose apsides are precessing moves the two eclipses in opposite directions, which is a sinusoid that changes sign between primary and secondary minima. The last is why both eclipses have to be timed: a third body moves them together and apsidal motion moves them apart, and a series of primary minima alone cannot tell the two apart at all.

Three causes with three shapes in one curve

The times of eclipse in a binary star are a clock, and the clock runs late and early. Three completely different things make it do so — a third body, a changing period, and a slowly turning orbit — and they are separable only because each imposes a different shape on the residual.

stars · Binary stars Io's eclipses, early at opposition and late at conjunction. The delay in the timing of Io's eclipses by Jupiter's shadow caused by the changing distance between the Earth and Jupiter, against days from an opposition, for circular orbits at 1 and 5.2026 AU. At opposition the two planets are closest and the eclipses arrive 8.3 minutes early against the average; 199 days later, near conjunction, they are furthest apart and arrive 8.3 minutes late. The whole swing, 16.6 minutes, is the time light takes to cross the diameter of the Earth's orbit, and the pattern repeats every 399 days, the synodic period. This is transit timing done on a moon in 1676, with a clock that ran on Io's 42.5-hour orbit and a residual that had nothing to do with Io.

A transit late by the width of an orbit

A transiting planet's clock can run fast and slow for a reason that has nothing to do with gravity acting on the planet. If its star is itself in orbit about a distant companion, each transit's light has further or less far to travel, and the timing wanders by the light-travel time across the star's orbit. It is the measurement that first showed light has a speed, made again on a different kind of clock.

exoplanets · Transit timing Three arrangements of gas, three velocity–delay maps. The response of a broad emission line to a flash of the continuum, as the density of emitting gas in delay (up, days) and line-of-sight velocity (across, km/s; positive is receding), for gas between 10 and 30 light-days from a hundred-million-solar-mass black hole in three kinematic states, 6,000 clouds each. Left: a rotating disc inclined at 30° with orbits tilted up to 15° from its plane — an ellipse symmetric in velocity, with the fastest gas, nearest the hole, responding soonest. Middle: gas falling in at the free-fall speed — the near side is moving away from the observer and responds first, so the red side leads and the blue side lags, by 27 days on average beyond 1,500 km/s. Right: the same gas flowing out — the mirror image, the blue side leading and the red lagging by 27 days. The three maps are as different as maps can be; their projections onto either axis alone are not.

A delay that tells which way the gas is moving

A broad emission line echoes the continuum after a delay, and the delay is a radius. Measure it separately in the line's blue wing and its red wing and it becomes a map — symmetric for gas in orbit, lagging on the blue side for gas falling in, on the red side for gas blown out — and the one route to the geometry factor for an individual black hole.

galaxies · Quasars One parabola, two causes. Transit times of a planet on a 1.0914-day orbit over 12 years, minus the best straight-line ephemeris, with timing errors of 30 seconds — the shape a period shrinking by 29 milliseconds a year produces, a parabola 116 seconds deep. The curve is drawn once because it is the same curve for both explanations: an orbit decaying at that rate, or a star accelerating towards the observer at 2.9e-6 m/s², which shortens the light-travel time to each successive transit by the same steadily growing amount. Nothing in the transit times can tell them apart.

A clock that slows, or a star that falls

Transit times that curve away from a straight line can mean a planet's orbit is shrinking — the tides draining it into its star — or that the star itself is accelerating along the line of sight under a distant companion's pull. Both draw the same parabola, and the transit times cannot choose. The star's velocities can, but only for the shortest orbits: the acceleration that would fake a given decay grows as one over the period, and beyond a day or two an unseen Saturn can mimic more decay than the tides produce.

exoplanets · Transit timing

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Apsidal precessionBarycentreBroad-line regionEclipse timingEphemerisPulsar timingRadial-velocityReverberation mappingTransfer functionTransit timing variationVirial factorAccretion disc

All concepts