Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Tip of the red giant branch — where it appears

The sharp upper edge of the giant branch, where helium ignites at very nearly one luminosity, which makes the edge a standard candle. It is measurable in any galaxy whose stars can be resolved, and it is the main rival to Cepheids as the calibrating rung of the distance ladder.

Named by 3 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The mirror: an envelope 62 times larger around a core 1.48 times smaller. Envelope radius and core radius against helium-core mass for a 1 solar-mass star, both in solar radii on one logarithmic axis. Two curves with opposite slopes at every point: the envelope grows from 2.0 to 122 solar radii — 0.57 astronomical units — while the degenerate core contracts from 13,848 to 9,368 kilometres, and the two are separated by a factor of 364 in the middle of the range. The figure is drawn from two stated relations rather than from a stellar model: a core-mass–luminosity law of the sixth power, calibrated to 2,500 solar luminosities at 0.48 solar masses of core, and a Hayashi temperature falling from 5000 to 3700 kelvin across the range. Everything else follows exactly — the radius by the Stefan–Boltzmann law, the core radius by the cold degenerate relation R ∝ M⁻¹ᐟ³. Note what the tip radius is and is not: it is the red-giant branch, and the later asymptotic-giant tip is a different and larger number.

The star that swells because its centre shrank

A helium core contracts, and the envelope around it expands by a factor of sixty. The central density rises at the same time as the radius, which is the opposite of what a self-gravitating body is expected to do, and a burning shell between the two is the whole reason it happens.

stars · Stellar evolution H₀: nine determinations in two families. Published determinations of H₀, each with its quoted one-sigma interval, sorted into two families — measured locally, in the late universe, against inferred from z ≈ 1100 through a model. The shaded band behind each family is that family's inverse-variance weighted mean: 72.66 ± 0.75 across 5 of them, against 67.40 ± 0.41 across 4. The difference is 5.26 ± 0.85 km/s/Mpc, which is 6.2 standard deviations, computed here from the quoted errors alone. That number is an upper bound on the significance rather than the significance: the determinations within each family share calibrations, samples and in two cases the same supernovae, so they are not independent, and a correlated pair combines to something wider than the formula used here gives. What the figure does establish is that the split is not one discrepant measurement against a consensus — it is two internally consistent groups, and the grouping is by method rather than by result.

The same constant, measured twice, five sigma apart

Cepheids and supernovae give an expansion rate of about 73 kilometres per second per megaparsec. The microwave background gives 67.4. Both quote errors near one per cent, both have been rebuilt from scratch by rival teams, and the gap between them has grown as the measurements have improved.

cosmology · Hubble constant The end of the red giant branch, found as an edge. The luminosity function of a synthetic galaxy halo — the number of red giants against apparent magnitude in the I band, smoothed — and its derivative, which is what the edge detector computes, searched over the magnitudes brighter than the branch's crowded lower part, as every application of the method does. 1582 stars are drawn: red giants rising in number towards fainter magnitudes as ten to the 0.3 times the magnitude, ending at the tip at magnitude 24, with a sixth as many asymptotic giants thinning out above it, all measured with errors of 0.08 magnitudes. The derivative peaks sharply where the counts jump, here at 24.09 — 0.09 from the true tip. The red giant branch ends where helium ignites in a degenerate core of almost fixed mass, so the tip's absolute magnitude is close to −4.05 for old, metal-poor stars, and the edge's apparent magnitude is a distance.

An edge that needs no pulsation

The local measurement of the expansion rate rests on a calibration step, and for decades that step was the Cepheid variables. The tip of the red giant branch replaces it with an edge — the brightness at which old stars ignite helium, nearly the same in every galaxy — found by counting stars rather than modelling them. It gives a slightly lower expansion rate, and whether the difference is a flaw in one calibration or in both is the local half of the Hubble tension.

cosmology · Hubble constant

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Degeneracy pressureHelium flashHubble constantCepheid variableColour magnitude diagramDistance ladderEarly dark energyEffective temperatureEvolutionary trackGiant branchHubble tensionHydrostatic equilibrium

All concepts