Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Young sun — where it appears

The Sun during its first few hundred million years, fainter in visible light than now but spinning faster and far more active. Its much stronger ultraviolet and X-ray output drove the early loss of planetary atmospheres.

Named by 3 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The XUV energy that reached one astronomical unit, for three young Suns. The cumulative X-ray and extreme-ultraviolet energy delivered per square metre at the Earth's distance from the Sun, against age, for three histories that differ only in how long the young Sun stayed magnetically saturated: 20 Myr for a slow rotator, 100 Myr for a medium rotator, 300 Myr for a fast rotator. After saturation each declines to a common track by 1 Gyr, as rotation histories are observed to converge. By 4.5 Gyr the totals are 2.06·10¹⁵ J/m² for the slow rotator, 3.66·10¹⁵ J/m² for the medium rotator, 6.47·10¹⁵ J/m² for the fast rotator: the fast rotator delivered 3.1 times as much as the slow rotator, nearly all of it in the first few hundred million years. The Sun's own rotation at that age is not measured; it is inferred from the spread of rotation periods in young clusters, and all three histories are consistent with a Sun that ends up rotating as it does now.

The young Sun's spin decides what the Earth kept

The calculation that strips sub-Neptunes applies just as well to a planet with a trace of hydrogen. An Earth that captured a few hundredths of a per cent of its mass from the gas it formed in — several times the hydrogen now in its oceans — would have lost all of it, or kept most of it, depending on something nobody has measured — how fast the Sun was spinning in its first few hundred million years.

exoplanets · Radius valley The heaviest atom a hydrogen wind can carry, against the strength of the wind. The crossover mass — the heaviest atom an escaping hydrogen flow drags out with it — against the hydrogen flux at the base of the flow, on a logarithmic axis, for the Earth's gravity and gas at 1000 K. Atoms lighter than the crossover leave with the hydrogen; heavier ones stay. The crossover rises in proportion to the flux: lifting neon takes 9.7·10¹² hydrogen atoms per square centimetre per second, argon 1.8·10¹³, krypton 4.3·10¹³ and xenon 6.6·10¹³. The Earth loses about 3·10⁸ today, which lifts nothing heavier than hydrogen. Driven by a young Sun at its saturated X-ray and ultraviolet output, an energy-limited flow would reach 2.2·10¹³ on Mars, a crossover of 114; 2.3·10¹³ on Venus, a crossover of 50; 10¹³ on the Earth, a crossover of 21 — the smaller planet's weaker gravity both raises the flux per unit area and lowers the force holding the heavy atoms back.

The heaviest atom a hydrogen wind can lift

A planet losing hydrogen fast enough to blow off as a wind drags other gases with it, but only those lighter than a crossover mass set by how strong the wind is. Below it every gas leaves in proportion to its distance from the limit and its isotopes are sorted by the same amount per mass unit; above it nothing goes. The Earth's xenon is sorted and its krypton is not, which no wind of neutral atoms can arrange.

exoplanets · Radius valley Whether a field helped, depending on what limits the escape. The ratio of the atmospheric loss of a magnetised Earth to that of the same Earth without a field, against the Sun's age, both on logarithmic scales, set at 2 today — the magnetised planet losing more — for two ways an unmagnetised planet's loss can scale. If both planets lose atmosphere in proportion to the solar-wind power they intercept (blue), the magnetosphere's cross-section shrinks as the young Sun's denser wind compresses it while the bare planet's does not, and the ratio falls to 0.46 at 0.7 billion years: the field protected the young Earth, on balance from before 1.9 billion years. If instead the bare planet's loss is set by the ions the Sun's ultraviolet makes above it (orange), the ultraviolet rises more slowly into the past than the wind's pressure does, and the ratio grows to 3.7: the field cost the young Earth more than it saves today. The answer to whether a magnetic field protects an atmosphere is not a property of fields; it is a statement about which process limits the escape, and the young Sun amplifies the difference.

A shield that depends on what limits the leak

Today the Earth, with its magnetic field, loses ions to space about as fast as Venus and Mars without one — a little faster, by most measures. Whether that was also true under the young Sun, whose wind pressed eighty times harder, depends on something no measurement of the present can settle. If escape is limited by the wind's power, the field protected the young Earth; if it is limited by the ions the Sun's ultraviolet makes, the field cost it more than it does now. The young Sun does not decide the question. It amplifies whichever answer is right.

sky · Magnetosphere

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Energy-limited escapePhotoevaporationPrimordial atmosphereTerrestrial planetsXUV fluxAtmospheric escapeExtreme-ultravioletHydrodynamic escapeIon outflowIsotopic fractionationMagnetopauseMagnetosphere

All concepts