Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Generator

The angular-momentum-budget generator

Who holds the mass, and who holds the spin
Who holds the mass, and who holds the spin. The solar system's two ledgers on one logarithmic axis, each row a body or a group of them, with the pale bar its share of the mass and the dark bar its share of the angular momentum. Both columns are computed rather than quoted: the Sun's spin from 0.07 M R² Ω at a 25.38-day rotation, each planet's orbit from M √(GM☉ a (1 − e²)) with its own semi-major axis and eccentricity, and both sums are required to close to one part in a billion. The Sun holds 99.866 per cent of the mass and 0.61 per cent of the angular momentum. Jupiter holds 0.095 per cent of the mass and 61.1 per cent of the angular momentum, so a body a thousandth of the system by weight carries most of its rotation. The four inner planets together account for 0.0016 of it. A cloud collapsing to make this system had to move nearly all of its spin outward onto a small fraction of its mass, and the ledger is what that operation looks like when it is finished. What the figure cannot show is where the transfer happened, because everything that carried it away has either fallen in or left.

The solar system's two ledgers on one logarithmic axis, each row a body or a group of them, with the pale bar its share of the mass and the dark bar its share of the angular momentum. Both columns are computed rather than quoted: the Sun's spin from 0.07 M R² Ω at a 25.38-day rotation, each planet's orbit from M √(GM☉ a (1 − e²)) with its own semi-major axis and eccentricity, and both sums are required to close to one part in a billion. The Sun holds 99.866 per cent of the mass and 0.61 per cent of the angular momentum. Jupiter holds 0.095 per cent of the mass and 61.1 per cent of the angular momentum, so a body a thousandth of the system by weight carries most of its rotation. The four inner planets together account for 0.0016 of it. A cloud collapsing to make this system had to move nearly all of its spin outward onto a small fraction of its mass, and the ledger is what that operation looks like when it is finished. What the figure cannot show is where the transfer happened, because everything that carried it away has either fallen in or left.

12 essays call angular-momentum-budget. The drawing above is what it returns with no arguments at all; every call below passes it something, because a placement that passes nothing draws whichever member of the family the generator happens to default to rather than the one its essay argues about.

Where it is called

Every figure listed here is the same construction drawn at different numbers, so a correction to one is a correction to all of them.

A halo is born with a spin of a few hundredths. The distribution of the dimensionless spin parameter λ = J|E|^½ ÷ (G M⁵ᐟ²) across dark matter haloes, drawn as a lognormal of median 0.035 and logarithmic width 0.5, with the disc scale length each λ implies printed along the lower axis. The distribution is required to integrate to one and to peak at 0.0272, which is the median times e raised to minus sigma squared, and is the signature of a lognormal rather than of a bell curve drawn to look like one. λ is small because a halo is supported by random motion rather than by rotation: a value of 0.035 means the halo turns at about three and a half per cent of the rate it would need to hold itself up centrifugally. It is also nearly independent of halo mass, which is what points at a common origin. Mapping it to a disc through R_d = λ R₂₀₀/√2 with all of the specific angular momentum retained, a 10¹²-solar-mass halo of radius 206 kiloparsecs gives 5.1 kiloparsecs at the median, against the 2.6 kiloparsecs the Milky Way's disc actually has. The gap is not a failure of the estimate; it is the measurement that the baryons arrived with less spin per unit mass than the halo they arrived in. Galaxies

A disc the size its halo was born with

A galaxy's mass says how much light it makes. It does not say how big it is. What sets a disc's size is a single dimensionless number describing how fast the dark halo around it happens to be turning — a number the disc had no part in choosing, distributed the same way for every halo mass in the universe.

 A torque that stops when the patch lets go. Left, the mechanism: a protogalactic patch drawn as an ellipsoid of axis ratios 1:0.72:0.5, with the principal axes of the surrounding tidal field drawn across it at 30 degrees to its own. The torque is proportional to the difference of the patch's principal moments times the sine of twice that angle, so it is exactly zero when the two sets of axes agree — checked at both alignments — and largest at forty-five degrees. A spherical patch takes no torque whatever the field around it does, which is why the spin of every galaxy begins as a statement about its shape. Right, the angular momentum against time in units of the turnaround time: in linear theory the torque acts on a patch still expanding with the universe and the angular momentum grows as the first power of time, measured off the drawn curve as t^1.000. At turnaround the patch detaches from the expansion, its quadrupole shrinks, and the torque switches off — so a galaxy's spin is fixed before it has collapsed at all, by neighbours it will never interact with again. What the figure cannot show is the sign: the same mechanism gives no preferred direction, and the observed near-absence of alignment between neighbouring galaxies' spins is the check on that. Cosmology

Spin acquired before there was anything to spin

Every galaxy turns, and nothing in a smooth expanding universe turns. The rotation was applied while the material was still a mildly overdense patch spread across megaparsecs — torqued by the tidal field of its neighbours, growing steadily with time, and switching off the moment the patch stopped expanding.

 Who holds the mass, and who holds the spin. The solar system's two ledgers on one logarithmic axis, each row a body or a group of them, with the pale bar its share of the mass and the dark bar its share of the angular momentum. Both columns are computed rather than quoted: the Sun's spin from 0.07 M R² Ω at a 25.38-day rotation, each planet's orbit from M √(GM☉ a (1 − e²)) with its own semi-major axis and eccentricity, and both sums are required to close to one part in a billion. The Sun holds 99.866 per cent of the mass and 0.61 per cent of the angular momentum. Jupiter holds 0.095 per cent of the mass and 61.1 per cent of the angular momentum, so a body a thousandth of the system by weight carries most of its rotation. The four inner planets together account for 0.0016 of it. A cloud collapsing to make this system had to move nearly all of its spin outward onto a small fraction of its mass, and the ledger is what that operation looks like when it is finished. What the figure cannot show is where the transfer happened, because everything that carried it away has either fallen in or left. Orbits

Ninety-nine per cent of the mass and none of the spin

The Sun holds 99.87 per cent of the solar system's mass and 0.6 per cent of its angular momentum. Jupiter holds a thousandth of the mass and three-fifths of the spin. That is not a curiosity of accounting — it is the record of the single operation that had to succeed before a star could form at all.

 A collapse that stops 29 astronomical units short. Equatorial rotation speed against radius for a collapsing cloud core of 1 solar mass, turning at 10⁻¹⁴ radians a second at a radius of 0.05 parsecs, compared with the Keplerian speed at the same radius. Both axes are logarithmic; both curves are computed from the same specific angular momentum, 2.4·10¹⁶ square metres a second, held fixed. The rotation speed rises as the reciprocal of the radius and the orbital speed only as its inverse square root, so they must cross, and the crossing is measured off the drawn curves at 4.27·10¹² metres — 29 astronomical units, or 6135 solar radii. Inside that radius the material is orbiting rather than falling, and no further collapse happens along the equator at all. To arrive at a star turning once in 25.38 days the core must dispose of a factor of 1.7·10⁴ in specific angular momentum, and nothing in the collapse itself removes any: it has to be handed to a magnetic field, to a disc, or to a companion. The figure assumes uniform rotation and a spherical core, both of which are simplifications a real core violates in the direction that makes the problem worse. Galaxies

A cloud that cannot become a star

A molecular cloud core turning once every twenty million years sounds like a body at rest. Conserve its angular momentum through a collapse by a factor of ten thousand and it stops at the orbit of Neptune, spinning, having failed to make anything at all.

 Stretched towards the mass, sheared across it. Two rings of galaxies around the same concentration of mass. Left, galaxies physically beside it: its tidal field stretches each one along the line to the centre, so their long axes point radially and their mean tangential ellipticity is −0.30. Right, galaxies far behind it: their light is deflected past the mass and each image is sheared tangentially, with mean tangential ellipticity +0.30. The two patterns are perpendicular. A weak-lensing survey correlates the shapes of foreground and background galaxies to measure the shear, and when a foreground galaxy was aligned by the very structure that lenses the background one, their product is negative — −0.090 here — and subtracts from the signal rather than adding noise to it. What the picture exaggerates is the size: real intrinsic alignments are a per cent or two in the mean, buried under a random shape scatter of about 0.3, and are found only statistically. Cosmology

The shape a galaxy was given before it was lensed

Weak lensing assumes that galaxies point in random directions, so that a coherent stretch can only have been put there by the light's journey. The tidal field that set every galaxy's spin also stretched its shape — towards the very mass that lenses the galaxies behind it — and the resulting error is not noise but a signal of the opposite sign.

 A spin that prefers the axis in the middle. Where the spin of a tidally torqued patch points, measured against the three principal axes of the tidal field acting on it: the distribution of the absolute cosine between the spin and each axis, from 20,000 patches with random shapes in one field of principal values −0.75, 0.09, 0.66. Principal values are those of the second derivative of the potential, so a positive one compresses. An isotropic spin would give three flat lines at one. The spin avoids the most compressive and the most stretching axes and prefers the intermediate one, because the torque about each axis is proportional to the difference of the field's principal values about the other two, and the intermediate axis is the one whose two neighbours differ most: squared, those weights are 0.11, 0.66, 0.24 of the total. Fitted as Lee and Pen's alignment parameter, the directions give a = 0.617. The preference is real and it is weak — the densest bin is 3.37 times the isotropic value — which is the whole difficulty of using spins to map a field. Cosmology

A spin that remembers the field and not its sign

Tidal torque theory says where a galaxy's spin should point, not only how large it should be. It points along the middle axis of the tidal field, it is exactly perpendicular to an ideal filament, and it is an even function of the field — so a map of spins can find the directions of the cosmic web and can never say which of them is collapsing.

 A disc galaxy walked down the plane by three dry mergers. Specific angular momentum against stellar mass, both logarithmic. The solid line is the relation disc galaxies follow, j proportional to M to the two-thirds, normalised to 1000 kpc km/s at 10¹¹ solar masses; the dashed line is the spheroids', a fifth as high. The points follow the median galaxy built from discs that start on the line at 2.51·10¹⁰ solar masses by successive equal-mass mergers, each between two galaxies with the same history as each other, adding spin vectors in random directions and keeping none of the orbital angular momentum. Each merger doubles the mass and moves the point right by 0.3 of a decade; the vector sum keeps on average only two thirds of the specific angular momentum while the line rises by the two-thirds power of two, so the point falls below it: to 0.45 of the line after one merger, 0.18 after two and 0.08 after three. Two dry major mergers carry a disc to where spheroids are measured. Galaxies

Two spins that cancel, and an orbit that leaves

Disc galaxies and ellipticals of the same stellar mass differ by a factor of five in how much angular momentum each gram of their stars carries. Adding spin vectors in random directions explains most of it — two mergers of equals, with the orbit's angular momentum handed to the dark halo, carry a disc down to where ellipticals sit — and whether a merger makes a spheroid or rebuilds a disc turns on one number the vectors do not supply.

 The plane a moon's orbit turns about, between equator and ecliptic. The inclination of the Laplace plane — the plane about which a satellite's orbit precesses — to the Earth's equator, against distance from the Earth in Earth radii, for an obliquity of 23.44°. Close in, the Earth's equatorial bulge dominates and the plane is the equator; far out, the Sun dominates and it is the ecliptic, 23.44° away. The dashed curve uses today's bulge, which makes the transition at 8.4 Earth radii. The solid curve lets the bulge grow with the faster spin the Earth had when the Moon was closer — a 5.3-hour day at 5 Earth radii, from the system's angular momentum alone — which moves the transition out to about 14. The Moon today, at 60.3 Earth radii, has a Laplace plane within 0.0022° of the ecliptic, so its 5.15° inclination is entirely free: nothing forces it. Orbits

A tilt the Moon should not have

A moon's orbit precesses about a plane that sits on its planet's equator close in and on the planet's own orbit far out. A Moon born in the Earth's equator and carried outward by the tides should have followed that plane all the way to the ecliptic, because the angle it keeps to it is an adiabatic invariant. It is inclined by five degrees instead, and slow recession cannot have put them there.

 The fraction of a spin alignment a disc can show. The ratio of a disc population's shape alignment — its mean ellipticity along the projected tidal template — to the Lee–Pen alignment of its spins, against the discs' thickness as a fraction of their diameter, each point from 30,000 discs in a field of shape 0.2. The thinnest disc drawn, 0.05 of its diameter, passes 0.204 per unit of spin alignment; a disc a fifth as thick, typical of a spiral's stellar disc, 0.171; a body as thick as it is wide passes nothing, because a sphere has no shape to align. The ratio is the conversion between what a spin survey measures and what a lensing survey fits, and it is small for two reasons that multiply: a spin alignment is a weak preference among directions, and a disc shows its direction only in proportion to how far it is tipped towards edge-on. Cosmology

An alignment a disc shows only when it is tipped

A disc galaxy's outline on the sky is its spin seen in projection, so the torque alignment of spins has to appear in shapes too. It does, multiplied by a factor near a sixth and carried almost entirely by the discs seen close to edge-on — which is how a lensing survey can fit the term and find nothing while a survey of spins finds it.

 A conversion read galaxy by galaxy, with or without an alignment. The mean ellipticity of disc galaxies along a tidal template, in bins of each galaxy's own spin estimator — the quantity whose population average is the Lee–Pen alignment — for 60,000 discs a fifth as thick as they are wide, in three samples: spins set by the torque (net alignment 0.36), 85% of them randomised (0.054), and all of them random (0.002). The points trace the same curve through the origin in every sample — not quite straight, flattening at both ends, because a disc's shape saturates when its spin lies in the sky's plane — and a straight line fitted through each sample (dashed) has slope 0.279, 0.290, 0.292. That slope is the projection factor, what a disc's shape shows of its spin, and it does not care whether the population is aligned. A sample with no alignment at all measures the conversion as well as one with a strong one; only the population's mean, where all its galaxies pile up, moves. Cosmology

A conversion measured without an alignment

The factor that turns a disc galaxy's spin alignment into the shape alignment a lensing survey fits looked like something only a sample with a detected alignment could test. It is not. It is a relation each galaxy obeys on its own, so it can be read off a few hundred discs with velocity maps whether or not their spins point anywhere in particular — and what is left for the hard measurement to test is only whether a disc's shape is anything more than its projected spin.

 The angular momentum a halo has and the angular momentum a disc needs. The fraction of the mass with specific angular momentum below j, against j in units of the mean, for a halo's material — the universal profile fitted to simulated haloes, with shape parameter μ of 1.1, 1.25, 1.5 — and for an exponential disc with a flat rotation curve (black). Both have the same mean, as a disc that kept its halo's angular momentum would. They do not have the same shape. Below a tenth of the mean a disc holds 2% of its mass; a halo with μ = 1.25 holds 11%, and one with μ = 1.1, 15%. The halo also stops at a largest j, 4.0 times the mean for μ = 1.25, beyond which the disc still has a thin tail. A disc built from a halo's gas without any exchange of angular momentum would be too concentrated at its centre and cut off at its edge. Galaxies

A halo with too much slow gas for a disc

A disc's size follows from its halo's average spin, and the average is all the simplest account of disc formation uses. The whole distribution does not match. A halo holds five times as much of its material at low angular momentum as an exponential disc can accommodate, so gas that kept its angular momentum exactly would build a dense centre, a thin body and a hard edge — and the bulgeless discs that are common in the nearby universe say that something removed a fifth to a quarter of the slowest gas before it settled.

 A tilt that wanders up, one passing body at a time. The inclination of the Moon's orbit to the plane it started in, against the number of lunar-mass bodies that have passed the Earth–Moon pair at 5 km/s within 300 Earth radii, with the Moon at 30 Earth radii, for four different sequences of passages. Each passage tilts the orbit by a fraction of a degree in a random direction, so the inclination performs a random walk and grows as the square root of the number of passages: after 1,000 the four runs stand at 3.8, 1.8, 3.9, 0.2 degrees. The dashed line is the Moon's present inclination, 5.145 degrees. Whether a given history reaches it is a matter of chance; how far a typical one gets is set by the passages' number, mass and speed. Orbits

A tilt built from a thousand near misses

The Moon's orbit is tilted five degrees to the ecliptic, and slow tidal recession cannot have done it. One candidate is the leftover debris of planet formation: bodies the size of the Moon, passing the young Earth–Moon pair, each giving its orbit a kick of a fifth of a degree in a random direction. A random walk of a few thousand such kicks reaches five degrees — and the bodies that would supply them are the same population whose impacts left the Earth's mantle its gold.

The whole library · All essays