Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Millisecond pulsar — where it appears

A neutron star spinning hundreds of times a second, spun up by accretion from a companion. Its pulse arrival times can be predicted years ahead to a few hundred nanoseconds, which makes it usable as a clock rather than merely as an object.

Named by 7 essays across 3 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Nothing visible in any pulsar, and a quadrupole in the angle between them. Above: 4 millisecond pulsars' timing residuals over 15 years, at the few hundred nanoseconds a good one reaches. Each wanders, and none of them shows anything a reader could call a signal; a gravitational-wave background of amplitude 2.4·10⁻¹⁵ at one cycle per year contributes a common part to all of them that is smaller than each pulsar's own red noise. Below: the correlation between pairs, against the angle on the sky between them. 2211 pairs out of 67 pulsars, binned into 15 angles, against three curves with no free parameters between them. A quadrupolar background gives the Hellings–Downs shape — positive for nearby pulsars, negative near 83°, and back up to exactly half its zero-separation value at 180° because a background looks the same in opposite directions. An error in the observatory clock would give a flat line, because it shifts every pulsar identically. An error in the solar-system ephemeris would give a cosine, because it moves the barycentre in one direction. The drawn points prefer the quadrupole over the flat line by Δχ² = 358. That is the detection: not a waveform, not an event, not a moment — a shape in an angle, accumulated over fifteen years, on data taken for another purpose entirely.

A detector the size of the galaxy

At a nanohertz no instrument can be built, so the clocks already in the sky are used instead. The signal is in no single pulsar's data — it is in the correlation between pairs as a function of the angle between them, and that curve has no free parameters at all.

gravitation · Gravitational waves Two measured numbers, and everything else on the page derived from them. 25 pulsars in the plane of period against period derivative, at their catalogued values. Only the two axes are measurements; the three families of contour are models. Constant surface field runs at slope −1 because B ∝ √(PṖ), constant characteristic age at slope +1 because τ = P/2Ṗ, and the two families cross the population at right angles — which is why a single dot fixes both. The Crab sits at 3.8·10¹² G and 1257 years, and its true age is 972; the millisecond pulsars at the lower left have fields ten thousand times weaker and characteristic ages of billions of years, because they were spun back up by a companion long after they died. The line at the lower right is the death line, B/P² below which the model says no pair production and therefore no radio emission — and J2144−3933 is drawn below it, an 8.5-second pulsar that is radiating anyway.

A clock that runs down and says what it is

A pulsar hands over two measured numbers, a period and its derivative. Everything else usually quoted about it — an age, a magnetic field, a luminosity — is derived from those two through a model, and the one measurement that tests the model refutes it.

stars · Pulsars A line nothing spun up by accretion can lie above, and the millisecond pulsars beneath it. The period–period-derivative diagram with the spin-up line drawn on it. An accreting neutron star is torqued by the disc until its magnetosphere turns at the same rate as the material arriving there, which fixes an equilibrium period as a function of the magnetic field and the accretion rate. Eliminating the field between that relation and the dipole formula that every point in this diagram is already read through leaves a straight line of slope 1.33, drawn here for accretion at the Eddington rate — the fastest a star can be pushed. The 7 recycled pulsars all sit below it, which is what the figure is for: none of them was spun up faster than the limit allows, and their positions are a record of how much mass each one received rather than of how old it is. The young pulsars are in the opposite corner, above the line and to the right, spinning down from birth. The two populations are not two stages of one life. A star that reaches the bottom left has been fed by a companion for a hundred million years, which is why almost every millisecond pulsar has one and almost no young pulsar does.

A corner of the diagram that has to be earned

A pulsar spinning a thousand times a second cannot have been born that way and stayed that way, because its own radiation would have slowed it in a few million years. It got there by being fed, and the line it cannot lie above is where the accretion torque balances the magnetic one.

stars · Pulsars Where the disc stops, and the spin that follows from it. Two radii against accretion rate, for a neutron star with a 10⁸-gauss field. The falling curve is the magnetospheric radius, where the field's stress on the disc matches the rate at which the flow carries angular momentum inward; it goes as the accretion rate to the minus two sevenths, which is a weak enough dependence that the factor of 1000 in supply drawn here moves the boundary by a factor of 7.2. The horizontal lines are corotation radii for three spin periods — the radius at which the disc orbits as fast as the star turns. Above corotation the field is spinning the gas faster than it wants to go and flings it out; below, the gas is faster and spins the star up. So the crossing is an attractor, and a star accreting steadily walks to the period where the two coincide. That period goes as the field to the six sevenths and the rate to the minus three sevenths — which is why a neutron star that has swallowed a tenth of a solar mass from a companion comes out at a few milliseconds, and why the millisecond pulsars have fields ten thousand times weaker than the young ones.

The period a star is pulled towards

A magnetised neutron star does not let a disc reach it. The disc stops where the field's stress wins, and if that radius lies inside the corotation radius the star is spun up while outside it the star is spun down — so there is one period at which nothing changes, and an accreting star walks to it.

gravitation · Accretion The stability of a pulsar clock against atomic clocks, over averaging times from a day to thirty years. Fractional frequency instability, on a logarithmic axis, against averaging time from a day to thirty years. A single millisecond pulsar timed to 300 nanoseconds every 14 days improves as τ^(−3/2) while its white timing noise averages down, and flattens where its slow spin noise, drawn at 10⁻¹⁵ at ten years, takes over. An ensemble of 20 such pulsars is 4.5 times better if their noises are independent. The atomic curves are representative: a hydrogen maser, excellent at hours and drifting at years, and a steered atomic time scale limited near 3·10⁻¹⁶ at long times. In this representative comparison the pulsar ensemble becomes the steadier of the two beyond about 3 years of averaging. At a day a pulsar is a billion times worse than an atomic clock; over decades it is competitive, because nothing inside a neutron star changes on the timescales on which laboratory clocks are rebuilt.

A clock made of neutron stars

The best atomic clocks are rebuilt every decade and averaged every month. A millisecond pulsar has kept its own time for a billion years. Averaged over years, an ensemble of pulsars is as steady as the world's atomic time scale — steady enough to find its errors — but it can never say how fast that time scale runs.

sky · Timescales One hot spot, seen through more and more gravity. The X-ray flux from a small hot spot at colatitude 60° on a rotating neutron star seen from inclination 60°, over one rotation, each curve divided by its own mean, for no bending, 2GM/Rc² = 0.20, 2GM/Rc² = 0.34, 2GM/Rc² = 0.48 — the last two are a 1.4 M☉ star of 12 km and a 2.0 M☉ star of 12.4 km. Light bending is computed exactly; Doppler effects are left out. With no bending the spot is behind the star for 39 per cent of the turn and the pulsed fraction is 1.00. As the compactness rises the star's gravity bends light from the far side into view: the dark interval shrinks to 27 per cent, then vanishes, and the pulsed fraction falls to 1.00, 0.99, 0.64. The more compact the star, the more of its own back it shows and the smoother its pulse.

The pulse that shows the back of the star

A hot spot on a spinning neutron star flashes once a turn, and the flash is weaker than it would be on an ordinary star because the star's gravity bends light from its far side into view. How much weaker measures the ratio of mass to radius. But on its own the flash cannot tell a compact star from a tilted one — the two trade exactly — and what separates them is the lean the spin puts into the pulse, which measures the radius directly.

stars · Degeneracy One pulsar's stability, limited by the background every pulsar shares. The cubic-fit stability of a single millisecond pulsar, on logarithmic axes, against averaging time from 0.3 to 40 years. White timing noise of 100 ns every 14 days averages down as τ^(−3/2) (falling dashed line). The gravitational-wave background at the amplitude the timing arrays reported in 2023, A = 2.4·10⁻¹⁵, raises the curve as τ^(2/3) (rising dashed line). Their sum (solid) is lowest at 2.8 years, at 2.8·10⁻¹⁵; averaging longer than that makes this pulsar a worse clock, not a better one, because the background grows faster in the residuals than the white noise shrinks. At ten years the background alone is 5.5·10⁻¹⁵.

A clock whose best interval is three years

A pulsar time scale was expected to improve for as long as anyone kept timing it. The background the timing arrays found in 2023 says otherwise — a single pulsar is steadiest over about three years and worse over every longer interval, and how far an array of them can push that floor down depends less on how many pulsars it holds than on how evenly they cover the sky.

sky · Timescales

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Gravitational-wave backgroundNeutron starAccretionAllan deviationAngular momentumClock ensembleHellings downs curvePulsarPulsar time scaleA pulsar timing arrayRed noiseSpin-down

All concepts