Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Protoplanetary disc — where it appears

The rotating disc of gas and dust around a young star, from which planets are assembled. It is heated by starlight and by its own accretion, and it disperses within a few million years, which sets a deadline every formation mechanism has to meet.

Named by 16 essays across 3 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Everything close in is circular, and nothing else has to be. Orbital eccentricity against period for fifteen real planets, with the tidal circularisation boundary computed from τ_e = (2/21)(Q′/n)(M_p/M⋆)(a/R_p)⁵ for a Jupiter with Q′ = 1e+6 and an age of 3 billion years. It falls at 4.5 days, and the reason it is a wall rather than a slope is the fifth power: at half the period the timescale is 91 times shorter. Nothing inside it has a measurable eccentricity, and outside it eccentricities run to 0.95 — which is the number to hold on to, because a planet on a 0.93 orbit at 111 days comes within 0.030 AU of its star at periastron, closer than Mercury, and is being circularised as it is observed.

A planet where one cannot form

A Jupiter at four days orbits inside a region that was too hot to hold ice and too small to hold the material. It did not form there — and the distribution of eccentricities says which of two journeys brought it in.

exoplanets · Planet migration The ice line at 2.7 AU, and the 3.4-fold jump in solid material across it. Two temperature thresholds turned into radii, against stellar mass, both axes logarithmic. The shaded band is the habitable zone, where water can be liquid on a planet's surface. The heavy line is the snow line of the disc the planets formed in — the distance at which a passively heated disc, whose temperature falls as the inverse square root of radius, reaches 170 K and water freezes. For a solar-luminosity star it sits at 2.71 AU, just outside the asteroid belt, and it is 1.6 times further out than the outer edge of the habitable zone; around a 0.15 solar-mass star both have moved inwards and the ratio is 5.5. What makes the line matter is what happens as it is crossed. Water is by far the most abundant condensable material after hydrogen and helium, so freezing it raises the surface density of solids by roughly 3.4 times in one step. Everything about the architecture of a planetary system follows from that step: a core massive enough to capture gas can be assembled outside the line and not inside it, which is why the solar system has small rocky planets in and giant ones out, and why a giant planet found at 0.05 AU is a statement about migration rather than about formation. The line is drawn where a mature disc puts it; a young, accreting disc is hotter and its line is several times further out, sweeping inwards as the disc drains.

The line beyond which ice counts as rock

A disc of gas around a young star gets colder outwards, and at about a hundred and seventy kelvin water stops being vapour and becomes a building material. Crossing that one line multiplies the solid mass available by roughly three and a half, in a single step, and the architecture of every planetary system is downstream of it.

exoplanets · The snow line A resonance keeps what convergence brings it and releases what divergence takes away. The resonant angle of a body inside a resonance whose strength is changing, for the two signs of that change. The angle obeys a pendulum, and the strength of the pendulum is set by how close the two orbits are; migration changes it slowly compared with the swing, which is the condition under which the area a trajectory encloses is conserved. Convergent migration strengthens the resonance, so the separatrix grows around a trajectory of fixed area and the swing narrows — from 1.05 radians to 0.77 across the figure, the body ending more deeply locked than it began. Divergent migration weakens it, the separatrix shrinks, and it eventually passes inside the trajectory: the angle stops oscillating and begins to run, 37.5π in the last quarter of the drawing alone, and the lock is gone for good. Nothing here is dissipative and nothing is random. The whole asymmetry is the sign of one derivative, which is why a chain of planets in resonance is direct evidence that they migrated toward one another, and why a chain cannot survive a phase in which they moved apart.

Capture is a direction, not a strength

A resonance holds a body that drifts into it from one side and lets go of one that drifts out the other way, and the asymmetry is not about how strong the resonance is. It is the sign of a derivative — whether the trapped region is growing or shrinking — which is why a chain of planets in resonance is direct evidence that they migrated toward each other.

exoplanets · Resonance An edge where two torques balance, 21 kilometres from the shepherd. Two torques on the edge of a ring, against distance from a shepherding moon, both axes logarithmic and both scaled by the same combination of surface density, radius and orbital rate so that only their shapes are being compared. The flat line is the viscous torque, which comes from collisions between ring particles and does not care how far away anything is; it is drawn for a kinematic viscosity of 12 square centimetres a second, within the range ring seismology gives. The falling line is the moon's, summed over the first-order resonances that crowd together as the gap narrows, which makes it an inverse cube. A flat curve and an inverse cube cross once, and the crossing is where an edge can sit: closer in the moon wins and pushes the material back, further out viscosity wins and the ring spreads. For Daphnis and the Keeler gap the balance lands 20.8 kilometres out against a measured half-width of 21, which is agreement to well inside the uncertainty on the viscosity — and it is the only handle anybody has on that viscosity, since the quantity being inferred is the collision rate among particles a metre across, a billion kilometres away.

A torque that nearly cancels

A planet embedded in a gas disc pulls on the material inside its orbit and outside it, and the two torques are almost equal and opposite. What survives the subtraction is a per cent of either, and it is still enough to carry a planet from where it formed to its star in less time than the disc lasts.

exoplanets · Planet migration Who holds the mass, and who holds the spin. The solar system's two ledgers on one logarithmic axis, each row a body or a group of them, with the pale bar its share of the mass and the dark bar its share of the angular momentum. Both columns are computed rather than quoted: the Sun's spin from 0.07 M R² Ω at a 25.38-day rotation, each planet's orbit from M √(GM☉ a (1 − e²)) with its own semi-major axis and eccentricity, and both sums are required to close to one part in a billion. The Sun holds 99.866 per cent of the mass and 0.61 per cent of the angular momentum. Jupiter holds 0.095 per cent of the mass and 61.1 per cent of the angular momentum, so a body a thousandth of the system by weight carries most of its rotation. The four inner planets together account for 0.0016 of it. A cloud collapsing to make this system had to move nearly all of its spin outward onto a small fraction of its mass, and the ledger is what that operation looks like when it is finished. What the figure cannot show is where the transfer happened, because everything that carried it away has either fallen in or left.

Ninety-nine per cent of the mass and none of the spin

The Sun holds 99.87 per cent of the solar system's mass and 0.6 per cent of its angular momentum. Jupiter holds a thousandth of the mass and three-fifths of the spin. That is not a curiosity of accounting — it is the record of the single operation that had to succeed before a star could form at all.

orbits · Angular momentum The solid mass available, as a staircase of 5 fronts. The share of the condensable material that is solid, against distance from a 1 solar-mass star, on a logarithmic radius axis. Each riser is one species freezing out, at the radius where the disc's temperature — falling as the inverse square root of the distance — reaches that species' condensation point. silicates and iron at 1400 K and 0.04 AU; water ice at 170 K and 2.71 AU; carbon dioxide at 70 K and 16.00 AU; methane and ammonia at 30 K and 87.11 AU; carbon monoxide at 20 K and 196.00 AU. Inside every front the solid surface density is 22 per cent of what is available, which is the refractories alone; water alone contributes 53 per cent, more than twice everything else combined, which is why one of these steps is called the snow line and the others are not. A body's composition is decided by which pair of risers it formed between, and the steps are narrow because a vapour pressure is exponential in the inverse temperature.

There is not one line, there is a staircase

Water freezing is the biggest step in a protoplanetary disc and it is one of five. Each condensable species has its own temperature and therefore its own radius, and what a body is made of is decided not by which side of a line it formed on but by which pair of risers it formed between.

exoplanets · The snow line The ice line sweeps from 6.4 to 2.7 AU while the disc drains. The radius at which a disc around a 1 solar-mass star reaches 170 K, against the disc's age, both axes logarithmic. The temperature is the fourth root of the sum of two fluxes: starlight, which does not change, and the disc's own accretion, which releases gravitational energy at a rate set by how fast material is flowing inward. The accretion rate decays as the disc drains — taken here as 5e-5 solar masses a year falling off as t^(−3/2) beyond 0.1 million years — so the viscous term fades and the line sweeps in. It starts at 6.38 AU and ends at 2.73, the passive value the closed form gives. A body at three astronomical units formed dry if it formed early and icy if it formed late, so a composition dates a formation rather than locating one, and the dating is only as good as the accretion history assumed.

A composition that dates a formation rather than placing it

The ice line in a young disc starts six astronomical units out and sweeps inward to under three as the disc drains. A body at four astronomical units therefore formed dry or wet depending only on when — so what it is made of is a clock, and reading it as a map is the mistake the moving line makes easy.

exoplanets · The snow line Where a disc pushes a planet outward. The sign of the total torque on a low-mass planet, as a function of the power-law indices of the disc's surface density (Σ ∝ r^−α, horizontal) and temperature (T ∝ r^−β, vertical), from the fitting formulae of Paardekooper and collaborators for an adiabatic disc with γ = 1.4 and the horseshoe torque unsaturated. Above the line the total is positive and the planet migrates outward; below it the planet migrates inward. The line is straight because every part of the torque is linear in the two indices, and it is steep in α because a shallow density profile strengthens the vortensity part and weakens nothing. The minimum-mass nebula (α = 1.50, β = 0.50) sits at a total of −3.76 in units of Γ₀/γ; The viscously heated inner disc (α = 0.60, β = 0.90) sits at a total of +0.74 in units of Γ₀/γ; The irradiated outer disc (α = 1.07, β = 0.43) sits at a total of −2.65 in units of Γ₀/γ. The minimum-mass nebula every textbook starts from is on the inward side by a wide margin, and a disc heated by its own accretion is on the outward side: the same planet can migrate either way depending on how the gas is heated, which the Lindblad torque alone could never say.

The gas that turns round beside the planet

The two spiral wakes a planet raises nearly cancel, and what decides the direction it drifts is a third, smaller torque from the gas sharing its orbit. That gas makes a U-turn in front of the planet and behind it, and whether the turn pushes the planet outward depends on how the disc was heated and on a viscosity nobody has measured.

exoplanets · Planet migration A bead on a rotating wire: when gas is flung off a disc. The effective potential — gravity plus the centrifugal potential in the frame rotating with the footpoint — for gas sliding along a rigid magnetic field line that leaves a Keplerian disc at 20°, 30°, 40° from the vertical, in units of GM over the footpoint radius, against distance along the line in units of that radius. The field line corotates with the disc where it is anchored, like a wire whipped round, and gas on it behaves like a bead. Close to vertical the potential rises away from the disc and the gas is bound to its footpoint. Inclined by more than 30° it falls, and gas is flung outward along the line with nothing but the rotation to drive it. The 30° threshold is exact for a Keplerian disc — the second derivative of the potential at the footpoint changes sign there — and it was the result that made magnetised disc winds a mechanism rather than a speculation.

A disc that throws its spin upward

A disc does not need turbulence to accrete. A magnetic field threading it can fling gas off its surface along field lines tilted more than thirty degrees from the vertical, and each gram flung out leaves with several times the angular momentum it had — so a wind carrying a few per cent of the inflow can drive the rest onto the star. Because it pulls on the disc's faces rather than across its edge, a wind outpulls the turbulence as soon as the field's pressure is a few ten-thousandths of the gas's.

gravitation · Magnetorotational instability How planet occurrence rises with the host star's iron, by kind of planet. Planet occurrence relative to its value at solar metallicity, on a logarithmic axis, against the host star's iron abundance [Fe/H] (zero is the Sun; one unit is a factor of ten). Each class is a power law, occurrence ∝ 10^(β[Fe/H]). Giant planets within a few astronomical units follow β = 2, the relation found in the first large radial-velocity survey to measure it: 12 per cent of stars at [Fe/H] = +0.3 have one, against 3 per cent at solar and under 0.3 per cent at −0.5 — a factor of 158 across the range drawn. The small planets found by transits rise far more gently; the slopes drawn, β = 0.5 for sub-Neptunes and 0.2 for super-Earths, are representative of published fits, which range from nearly flat to about a doubling across this interval depending on orbital period.

A threshold that makes iron matter only to giants

A star with twice the Sun's iron is four times as likely to have a giant planet, and barely more likely to have a small one. The steep law and the flat one look like two mechanisms. A core racing its disc, run over a spread of discs, produces both — steep where winning is rare, flat where it is common.

exoplanets · Occurrence rates Small planets and giant planets per star, against the mass of the star. Planets per star against the host star's mass, both on logarithmic axes, for small planets (one to four Earth radii, orbital periods under 200 days) and giant planets (above a third of Jupiter's mass, within 2.5 astronomical units). The small-planet rate is drawn as 1.1 per star at one solar mass rising as M^−0.6; the giant rate as 7 per cent at one solar mass falling towards small stars as M^1. Both are representative of published fits, not fits of their own. At 0.3 solar masses a star has 2.3 small planets and a 2.1 per cent chance of a giant; at one solar mass 1.1 and 7 per cent. The ratio of small planets to giants changes by a factor of 7 between the two, so a statement about how common planets are depends on which star it is about as much as on which planet.

More small planets round smaller stars

A red dwarf has about twice as many small planets as the Sun's kind of star and a third as many giants. The two populations move in opposite directions along the same axis, and the small planets were built from discs several times poorer.

exoplanets · Occurrence rates How far a turbulent disc bends the field it drags. The tangent of the angle by which an accretion flow bends a vertical magnetic field at the disc's surface, against the magnetic Prandtl number Pm — the ratio of the turbulent viscosity that drives the inflow to the turbulent resistivity that lets the field slip — for discs of aspect ratio 0.03, 0.05, 0.1. In a steady state the inflow drags the field in at exactly the rate it diffuses back, and that balance sets tan i = (3/2) Pm H/R. The dashed line is 30° from the vertical, the inclination a field needs before gas is flung off along it. Turbulence whose own Prandtl number is of order one bends the field by about the disc's aspect ratio, a few degrees; reaching 30° needs Pm of 13, 8, 4. The same turbulence that carries the gas in lets the field out almost as fast, because both are the same eddies.

A field the turbulence will not let in

A disc that accretes through its own turbulence drags its magnetic field inward, and the same eddies let the field slip back out almost as fast. A disc of ordinary thickness bends its field by a few degrees instead of the thirty a wind needs, so a turbulent disc cannot gather the flux that would let it stop being turbulent.

gravitation · Magnetorotational instability A star fed in bursts by a disc that cannot pass its supply on. The accretion rate onto a 0.5 M☉ protostar over 100 thousand years, for a steady supply of 10⁻⁶ M☉ a year into a disc whose active layer can carry only 10⁻⁸ M☉ a year at 1 AU. The excess fills the dead zone until the column inside 1 AU reaches 4.4·10⁴ grams per square centimetre — 0.016 M☉, the column at which it becomes gravitationally unstable and its spiral arms heat it to ignition — and then drains on the hot disc's viscous time of 189 years, at 8.3·10⁻⁵ M☉ a year. The cycle repeats every 16,083 years, 6 times in the span drawn. The star spends 1.2 per cent of its time in outburst and gains 99 per cent of its mass there: a census at a random moment finds almost every protostar faint, while almost all of the mass arrives during events nobody happens to be watching.

A disc that stores its inflow and spends it in a century

Where only a thin ionised skin of a young disc can transport angular momentum, the gas arriving from the cloud cannot be passed on, and it piles up in the dead midplane until gravity stirs it and the whole column ignites. The star then gains most of its mass in bursts of a century every ten thousand years — which is why almost every protostar ever observed is fainter than its growth requires.

gravitation · Magnetorotational instability The deuterium in the solar system's water, body by body. The ratio of deuterium to ordinary hydrogen in water, on a logarithmic axis, for the Earth's oceans and for the bodies it has been measured in, with the protosolar hydrogen and the water around young protostars as the two ends of the range. The oceans, 1.6·10⁻⁴, are 7.8 times the protosolar value; the carbonaceous and enstatite chondrites sit within ten per cent of them, as do two comets from the Jupiter family. The comets from the Oort cloud, and 67P from the Jupiter family, are two to three and a half times richer. Water made in a cold molecular cloud is richer still, near 0.001. The ratio is fixed when the water forms or last exchanges with hydrogen gas, and is not changed by anything that happens afterwards except escape, so it is a label that each body's water carries from wherever it was made.

Water that remembers how cold it was

Every water molecule in the solar system carries a label: the share of its hydrogen that is deuterium, fixed when the water last exchanged with hydrogen gas. Water made in the cold cloud the Sun formed from is rich in it; water that passed through the hot inner disc is poor. The Earth's oceans sit within ten per cent of the carbonaceous meteorites and twice below most comets — a record of where the water was assembled, and of how much of it had ever been hot.

exoplanets · The snow line The mass at which a growing core cuts off the pebbles drifting past it. The pebble-isolation mass — the mass at which a core perturbs the gas around it enough to raise a pressure maximum outside its orbit, where drifting solids stop — against distance from the Sun, for a passively heated disc whose thickness grows as the distance to the 2/7, with α = 10⁻³. The mass goes as the cube of the disc's aspect ratio, because a planet has to push the gas by a fraction of its own pressure, and so it grows outward: 7 Earth masses at 1 AU, 30 at 5 AU where Jupiter's core formed, 138 at 30. A core reaching this mass stops growing from pebbles, starts accreting gas, and becomes a dam: everything drifting inward from outside its orbit is held there.

A core that shut the door on the pebbles

Solids in a gas disc drift inward, and a growing planet eats them as they pass until it is heavy enough to bend the gas around it. Then a pressure maximum forms outside its orbit, the drift stops there, and everything beyond is cut off from everything within. Jupiter's core reached that mass early, and the solar system's meteorites still fall into two families that never mixed.

exoplanets · The snow line An envelope that boils away in a million years, or keeps for longer than the universe. The time a 5-Earth-mass planet takes to lose an envelope of 5.0% of its mass through an isothermal wind driven by its own heat and the star's light, against the escape parameter Λ at the envelope's outer edge — the ratio of the gravitational binding of a molecule there to its thermal energy — for equilibrium temperatures of 500, 800, 1200 K, on a logarithmic time axis. The rate is exponential in Λ, so the time grows by a factor of e for every unit: each step of ten in Λ is more than four decades of time. The envelope goes in under a million years below Λ ≈ 19, 18, 18 and lasts longer than a billion years above Λ ≈ 26, 26, 26. The window between a million and a billion years is a band only about seven units of Λ wide, so a planet is either boiling or effectively sealed.

An envelope that boils down before the starlight strips it

The usual story of how small planets lose their hydrogen starts with the star's ultraviolet light and runs for a hundred million years. It skips the first million. When the gas disc that fed a young planet disappears, an envelope that was swollen and held in by the disc's pressure is suddenly exposed, and it pours off as a wind powered by ordinary heat — until it has shrunk to the size at which the same number near thirty that governs every escaping atmosphere shuts the flow off.

exoplanets · Atmospheric escape

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

The snow linePlanet migrationAngular momentumAngular momentum transportCondensation sequenceDead zoneDisc evolutionDisc windEquilibrium temperatureMagnetorotational instabilityPlanetesimalAccretion disc

All concepts