Concept

Solar abundance problem — where it appears

The mismatch between the Sun's interior as sounded by helioseismology and models built with the lower heavy-element abundances of newer spectral analyses. The older, higher abundances fit the interior better.

Named by 2 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

$A better measurement that made the model worse: 0.9 per cent in the sound speed. The fractional difference between the Sun's sound speed as its own oscillations measure it and as a structural model predicts it, against fractional radius. Zero would be agreement. The lower curve is the model built on the solar abundances used until the mid-2000s, and it hugs the axis: a part in a thousand across most of the interior, which was for a long time the best-tested piece of stellar physics anybody had. The upper curve is the same model with the abundances re-measured using three-dimensional atmospheres and without assuming local thermodynamic equilibrium — better measurements by every methodological standard, which lowered carbon, nitrogen and oxygen by around thirty per cent. The disagreement grows to 0.9 per cent, and it is not spread through the star: it peaks at 0.683 of the radius, just beneath the base of the convection zone at 0.713. The same substitution moves the model's own convection-zone base from 0.715 to 0.729, against a seismic value known to about a thousandth. What is being tested here is not really the abundances but what converts a composition into a structure, which is the opacity: the metals whose abundances fell are exactly the ones whose bound–free absorption dominates at those temperatures, and an opacity larger by some fifteen per cent near that boundary would restore the agreement. Laboratory measurements of iron at those conditions have since come in high by about that much, which is a satisfying result to have arrived at by way of a discrepancy in the sound speed of the Sun. The curves are published inversions and model differences rather than anything computed here; what the figure adds is where they peak and by how much.$

A better measurement that made the model worse

The Sun's composition was re-measured with better atmospheres and better physics, and the carbon, nitrogen and oxygen abundances fell by about thirty per cent. The improved model then disagreed with the Sun's own oscillations by ten times as much as the model it replaced, and it still does.

starlight · Opacity

A synthetic spectrum fitted with a line list that is missing the weak lines. Four ångströms of a simulated metal-line spectrum near 5000 Å at resolving power 20,000 and a signal-to-noise ratio of 200 (thin, noisy line), and the best-fitting synthesis (heavy line) computed from a line list that omits every line with a central optical depth below 0.15 — 137 of the 160 lines in the ten-ångström window, carrying 32 per cent of its total absorption. The fit adjusts one abundance for all the listed lines, with the continuum held at its true level; it returns an abundance 0.188 dex too high: the missing lines' absorption has nowhere to go but into the parameters the synthesis has. The residuals (below, offset) show the missing lines as dips that no parameter of the synthesis can fill — which is how an incomplete list announces itself at high resolution, and why it does not at low.

The lines a synthesis keeps pay for the ones it lacks

Modern abundance work fits a computed spectrum to a whole stretch of the observed one rather than measuring lines one at a time, and it averages away the errors in each line's laboratory data as it does so. It cannot average away a line that is not in its list. The absorption of the missing lines has to be put somewhere, and the fit puts it into the parameters it has — the abundance of the lines it knows, or the level of the continuum — in a direction set by which of the two it was allowed to move.

starlight · Line formation

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Abundance Equivalent width Systematic error Blending Bound-free absorption Continuum normalisation Convection Helioseismology Line list Local thermodynamic equilibrium Metallicity Opacity

All concepts