Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Helioseismology — where it appears

The inversion of the Sun's millions of acoustic mode frequencies into a sound speed at every depth, and so into the base of its convection zone. It fixed the depth of the convection zone at 0.713 solar radii and the helium abundance of the envelope, neither of which is measurable in any other way.

Named by 10 essays across 4 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Which gradient is steeper, and where. The temperature gradient radiation would need in order to carry the whole luminosity, against the gradient a rising blob of gas follows, through an n = 3 polytrope with a Kramers opacity and an energy generation going as ρT^4. Wherever the first exceeds the second the layer is unstable and convects. This model puts the outer boundary at 89 per cent of the radius; helioseismology measures the base of the Sun's convection zone at 71.3 per cent, and the gap between the two numbers is the price of a polytrope with one opacity law rather than a solar model. The curve also rises above the adiabatic value inside 4 per cent of the radius, which is a convective core — it appears when the energy generation is concentrated enough, and it is the structure a star burning by the CNO cycle has.

The part of a star that boils

Energy leaves a star's interior either by radiation or by bulk motion, and which one happens is settled by comparing two temperature gradients. The comparison decides that the Sun's outer third churns and its core does not, and that a massive star does exactly the opposite.

stars · Energy transport 14 radial orders of the Sun, at 135.1 μHz apart. The p-mode spectrum of the Sun — 1 solar mass in 1 solar radius — from the asymptotic relation with its second-order term, drawn as 14 radial orders of ℓ = 0, 1 and 2 under a Gaussian envelope centred on ν_max = 3,090 μHz. Two numbers are marked and they do very different work. The large separation, 135.1 μHz, is the spacing between consecutive ℓ = 0 modes and fixes the mean density. The small separation, 9.00 μHz, is 2.7 pixels on this axis — it fixes the age, and it is why the échelle diagram exists rather than being a convenience. The vertical axis is the measurement: each mode moves the surface by about 20.0 cm s⁻¹ at the peak, and brightens it by a few parts per million, which is why this was impossible before a decade-long velocity series. Each mode is one line: its true width is set by its lifetime and is far below a pixel here.

The interior read from a comb of frequencies

A star's surface moves by about twenty centimetres a second, in thousands of overlapping sound modes at once. Two numbers off that spectrum give a mass and a radius with almost no stellar model in the chain, and a third gives an age.

stars · Asteroseismology Seven sources over twelve decades of flux, and one threshold below the one that matters. The Sun's neutrino spectrum at the Earth, with the continua drawn per unit energy and the two monoenergetic lines as spikes at their own energies. The pp reaction supplies 91 per cent of all of them and its endpoint is at 0.4233 MeV. The vertical lines are experimental thresholds, and they are the figure's argument: only gallium sits below that endpoint. Chlorine, which produced the deficit and held it for twenty years, could not see a single pp neutrino — it counted ⁷Be and ⁸B, which are a rare branch of a rare branch, together under a per cent of the total — and the water detectors that followed were higher still. So the discrepancy that eventually turned out to be a property of the neutrino was measured, for two decades, using the least representative one per cent of the flux available. The total drawn here is 6.54·10¹⁰ cm⁻² s⁻¹, and it is checkable without any stellar model at all: every completed chain turns four protons into helium, releases 26.73 MeV of which 0.59 leaves as neutrinos, and emits two neutrinos — so the solar constant of 1361 W m⁻² fixes the number at 6.5·10¹⁰ cm⁻² s⁻¹, within 0.6 per cent of the sum of the model's own branches. The dominant flux is a consequence of the Sun shining and of nothing else.

The only thing that leaves the centre

A photon made in the Sun's core takes a hundred thousand years to get out and arrives thermalised past recognition. A neutrino takes 2.3 seconds and arrives unchanged, so its flux is the fusion rate now — which is why a factor of three could not be absorbed by any adjustment to the Sun.

stars · Solar neutrinos The Sun's internal rotation: differential above 0.693 R, rigid below, and the 15 nHz between two modes. Angular velocity against fractional radius, in nanohertz, from the inversion of hundreds of thousands of measured rotational splittings. Two features had to be discovered rather than deduced. The convection zone rotates differentially in latitude — 473 nanohertz at the equator, 330 at sixty degrees — and that latitude dependence persists all the way down through it, in surfaces that are very nearly radial rather than the cylinders a rotating convective fluid was expected to produce. And below about 0.693 of the radius the latitude dependence stops: the radiative interior turns as a single rigid body at 430 nanohertz, which is a remarkable thing for a fluid with no strength to do, and requires something — most likely a weak internal magnetic field — to be enforcing it. The two regimes are joined by a shear layer a few per cent of the radius thick, the tachocline, and it is where the solar magnetic cycle is generally thought to be generated, because it is the only place in the Sun with the shear a dynamo of that strength needs. The horizontal marks are what individual modes would report: the rotation averaged over the cavity each one occupies, weighted by the time the wave spends at each radius. A mode of degree 100 is trapped near the surface and reports 473 nanohertz; one of degree 1 passes through the deep interior and reports 458. The 15-nanohertz difference between them is the measurement, and splittings are measured to about a nanohertz — which is why the profile can be resolved at all. The kernels used here have the right support and the right sense; a real inversion uses computed eigenfunctions, and its resolution below 0.2 R is poor for the reason the previous figure gives.

A fluid that turns as one piece

The Sun's surface turns faster at its equator than at its poles, and everyone expected the inside to do something similar. Below seven-tenths of the way down it does not — the radiative interior rotates as rigidly as a bell, and nothing in hydrodynamics makes a fluid do that.

stars · Internal rotation Where each mode turns back: ℓ = 0 through the centre, ℓ = 300 in the outer 2 per cent. Why a set of frequencies is a depth profile and a single frequency is not. An acoustic wave travelling into a star meets a rising sound speed and is refracted back; it turns where its horizontal phase speed matches the local sound speed, which happens at c(r)/r = 2πν/√(ℓ(ℓ+1)). The horizontal axis is the angular degree on a logarithmic scale and the vertical axis is the fractional radius of that turning point, drawn at 2000, 3090, 4000 microhertz. The ordering is the content. A radial mode, ℓ = 0, has no horizontal phase speed at all and passes straight through the centre. Degrees one and two turn deep in the core. By ℓ = 300 the mode is trapped in the outer 2 per cent and knows nothing about anything below. So a frequency measured to a part in ten thousand constrains an average of the interior weighted in a way the mode itself decides, and measuring thousands of modes of different degree gives thousands of differently weighted averages — which is a solvable inverse problem, and is how the base of the convection zone was located at 0.713 of the radius rather than assumed. The sound speed here is a polytrope's rather than a tabulated solar model's, so the curve is the right shape and the wrong star in its outer tenth, where the real Sun is convective and this one is not. What the picture cannot show is the frequency dependence at fixed degree, which is weaker but not negligible: a higher-frequency mode of the same degree turns slightly deeper, and the three curves separating toward the right is that effect.

Every note turns back at its own depth

A sound wave heading into a star is refracted by the rising sound speed and turns around before it reaches the middle. Where it turns depends on which mode it is — so a list of frequencies is not one average of the interior but thousands of differently weighted ones, and that is a solvable problem.

stars · Asteroseismology A better measurement that made the model worse: 0.9 per cent in the sound speed. The fractional difference between the Sun's sound speed as its own oscillations measure it and as a structural model predicts it, against fractional radius. Zero would be agreement. The lower curve is the model built on the solar abundances used until the mid-2000s, and it hugs the axis: a part in a thousand across most of the interior, which was for a long time the best-tested piece of stellar physics anybody had. The upper curve is the same model with the abundances re-measured using three-dimensional atmospheres and without assuming local thermodynamic equilibrium — better measurements by every methodological standard, which lowered carbon, nitrogen and oxygen by around thirty per cent. The disagreement grows to 0.9 per cent, and it is not spread through the star: it peaks at 0.683 of the radius, just beneath the base of the convection zone at 0.713. The same substitution moves the model's own convection-zone base from 0.715 to 0.729, against a seismic value known to about a thousandth. What is being tested here is not really the abundances but what converts a composition into a structure, which is the opacity: the metals whose abundances fell are exactly the ones whose bound–free absorption dominates at those temperatures, and an opacity larger by some fifteen per cent near that boundary would restore the agreement. Laboratory measurements of iron at those conditions have since come in high by about that much, which is a satisfying result to have arrived at by way of a discrepancy in the sound speed of the Sun. The curves are published inversions and model differences rather than anything computed here; what the figure adds is where they peak and by how much.

A better measurement that made the model worse

The Sun's composition was re-measured with better atmospheres and better physics, and the carbon, nitrogen and oxygen abundances fell by about thirty per cent. The improved model then disagreed with the Sun's own oscillations by ten times as much as the model it replaced, and it still does.

starlight · Opacity The Sun's internal rotation: differential above 0.693 R, rigid below, and the 15 nHz between two modes. Angular velocity against fractional radius, in nanohertz, from the inversion of hundreds of thousands of measured rotational splittings. Two features had to be discovered rather than deduced. The convection zone rotates differentially in latitude — 473 nanohertz at the equator, 330 at sixty degrees — and that latitude dependence persists all the way down through it, in surfaces that are very nearly radial rather than the cylinders a rotating convective fluid was expected to produce. And below about 0.693 of the radius the latitude dependence stops: the radiative interior turns as a single rigid body at 430 nanohertz, which is a remarkable thing for a fluid with no strength to do, and requires something — most likely a weak internal magnetic field — to be enforcing it. The two regimes are joined by a shear layer a few per cent of the radius thick, the tachocline, and it is where the solar magnetic cycle is generally thought to be generated, because it is the only place in the Sun with the shear a dynamo of that strength needs. The horizontal marks are what individual modes would report: the rotation averaged over the cavity each one occupies, weighted by the time the wave spends at each radius. A mode of degree 100 is trapped near the surface and reports 473 nanohertz; one of degree 1 passes through the deep interior and reports 458. The 15-nanohertz difference between them is the measurement, and splittings are measured to about a nanohertz — which is why the profile can be resolved at all. The kernels used here have the right support and the right sense; a real inversion uses computed eigenfunctions, and its resolution below 0.2 R is poor for the reason the previous figure gives.

A shear layer that should have spread

The Sun's convection zone turns differentially — its equator laps its poles about once every three months — and the radiative interior below turns as one rigid piece. Between them is a transition four per cent of the radius thick. Nothing in hydrodynamics keeps a velocity discontinuity that thin for four and a half billion years.

stars · Internal rotation A flux that measures a temperature to 0.12 per cent. Neutrino flux against central temperature, in units of the standard model's, for the three main solar channels. The exponents are not arbitrary: each reflects how far up the Gamow peak the reaction has to reach, so the channel with the largest Coulomb barrier is the steepest. The boron-8 flux goes as roughly the twenty-fourth power, which means a measurement good to 3 per cent constrains the Sun's central temperature to 0.12 per cent — better than any other technique by an order of magnitude. The same steepness is why the flux is useless as a check on anything else: a stellar model whose central temperature is uncertain at the half-per-cent level predicts this flux to within a factor, and the disagreement between two model families is far larger than the measurement.

A flux that is a thermometer to a tenth of a per cent

The boron-8 neutrino flux from the Sun's core rises as roughly the twenty-fourth power of the central temperature. That makes it the sharpest thermometer in astrophysics and simultaneously the most fragile prediction — a model uncertain in its central temperature by half a per cent predicts the flux to within a factor.

stars · Solar neutrinos The edge of the Sun, computed. The brightness of the Sun at 500 nanometres across its limb, as a fraction of the brightness at the centre of the disc, against height above the level where the photosphere's radial optical depth is one, from the radiative transfer along each line of sight through a grey model atmosphere. Inside the disc the brightness falls gently with limb darkening; at the edge it falls to nothing over about two hundred kilometres. The steepest point of the fall — the inflection point, which is what a solar radius conventionally means — is 335 km above the radial τ = 1 level, because a ray grazing the limb passes through 270 times more atmosphere than a vertical one and becomes opaque that much higher up, at about 336 km. The brightness falls to one per cent 555 km above the τ = 1 level and to a thousandth at 694.

The Sun is three hundred kilometres larger seen edge-on

The radius of the Sun measured from images and eclipses and the radius measured from its oscillations disagree by about three hundred kilometres, and neither is wrong. A line of sight grazing the limb passes through hundreds of times more atmosphere than a vertical one and becomes opaque higher up — so the edge a telescope sees sits above the surface the waves feel, and every other definition of the edge, from the detector's threshold to the colour of the light, moves it again.

sky · Phases and eclipses Oceans that a changing G would have boiled. The Earth's surface temperature in a crude climate — equilibrium temperature for a fixed albedo, scaled as the received flux to the quarter power, plus a fixed greenhouse warming of 33 K — against time before the present, if the Sun's luminosity goes as G⁷ and the Earth's orbit as 1/G, so the flux goes as G⁹, on top of the Sun's own brightening. With Dirac's G ∝ 1/t and an age of 13.8 Gyr, the oceans boil 1.9 Gyr ago; with G falling by 10⁻¹¹ of itself a year, the surface is 292 K at 3.8 Gyr. Rocks of that age were laid down in water. Constant G gives the faint young Sun's cooling, 270 K in this climate — a separate problem, which the real atmosphere solved.

A constant bounded by the oceans

In 1937 Dirac proposed that the gravitational constant falls as the universe ages. Eleven years later Teller pointed out what that would have done to the Earth: a star's luminosity depends on G to about the seventh power, the Earth's orbit shrinks as G grows, and the sunlight reaching the Earth goes as the ninth power. Run backwards, Dirac's G boils the oceans less than two billion years ago. The rocks were laid down in water, so G cannot have changed that fast — the first bound on a changing constant came from geology.

gravitation · Gravitational constant

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

ConvectionOpacityAsteroseismologyRotational splittingAngular momentum transportDifferential rotationGranulationInversionStandard solar modelSystematic errorTachoclineAbundance

All concepts