Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Turning point — where it appears

The depth at which an acoustic mode travelling into a star is refracted back, where its horizontal phase speed matches the local sound speed. It moves outward with angular degree, so a radial mode passes through the centre and a mode of degree 300 is confined to the outer two per cent.

Named by 4 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The effective potential, for three angular momenta. The radial motion of an orbiting body is one-dimensional motion in an effective potential: the attraction −GM/r plus the centrifugal term L²/2r² that the angular momentum contributes. The barrier at small radius is what stops a body with any angular momentum at all from reaching the centre, and the bottom of each well is the circular orbit.

The wall that angular momentum builds

A body falling toward a star almost never arrives. Sideways motion, which looks like a detail of the initial conditions, turns the attraction into a well with a wall around the middle of it — and the wall is why it costs more fuel to hit the Sun than to leave the solar system.

orbits · Effective potential Where each mode turns back: ℓ = 0 through the centre, ℓ = 300 in the outer 2 per cent. Why a set of frequencies is a depth profile and a single frequency is not. An acoustic wave travelling into a star meets a rising sound speed and is refracted back; it turns where its horizontal phase speed matches the local sound speed, which happens at c(r)/r = 2πν/√(ℓ(ℓ+1)). The horizontal axis is the angular degree on a logarithmic scale and the vertical axis is the fractional radius of that turning point, drawn at 2000, 3090, 4000 microhertz. The ordering is the content. A radial mode, ℓ = 0, has no horizontal phase speed at all and passes straight through the centre. Degrees one and two turn deep in the core. By ℓ = 300 the mode is trapped in the outer 2 per cent and knows nothing about anything below. So a frequency measured to a part in ten thousand constrains an average of the interior weighted in a way the mode itself decides, and measuring thousands of modes of different degree gives thousands of differently weighted averages — which is a solvable inverse problem, and is how the base of the convection zone was located at 0.713 of the radius rather than assumed. The sound speed here is a polytrope's rather than a tabulated solar model's, so the curve is the right shape and the wrong star in its outer tenth, where the real Sun is convective and this one is not. What the picture cannot show is the frequency dependence at fixed degree, which is weaker but not negligible: a higher-frequency mode of the same degree turns slightly deeper, and the three curves separating toward the right is that effect.

Every note turns back at its own depth

A sound wave heading into a star is refracted by the rising sound speed and turns around before it reaches the middle. Where it turns depends on which mode it is — so a list of frequencies is not one average of the interior but thousands of differently weighted ones, and that is a solvable problem.

stars · Asteroseismology The same well after the primary has lost 45 per cent of its mass. Two effective potentials for one body: the solid curve before the primary loses mass and the faint one after, both at the same angular momentum, because a central force of any strength exerts no torque. The well shallows and its floor moves out from r = 1.00 to 1.82. The body's own level moves with it — from E = -0.420 to -0.127 — and the two horizontal lines are drawn where the radial action is conserved, which puts the turning points at 0.71–1.67 before and 1.30–3.03 after. The ratio between them is 2.3333 in both, so the orbit is the same shape at a larger size: everything about the body's path has scaled and its eccentricity of 0.4 has not moved. That is what a slow change leaves behind, and it is not what a sudden one leaves.

The well moves, and the body keeps its share of it

When the Sun becomes a white dwarf it will throw away half its mass, and every planet's orbit will swell by the same factor. Their eccentricities will not change at all — provided the loss is slow, and the only meaning "slow" has here is slow compared with one orbital period.

orbits · Effective potential Ridges that bend where the model's surface is wrong. An échelle diagram of a Sun-like star's oscillation frequencies — each mode's frequency against its remainder after dividing by the large separation of 135.1 µHz — for radial, dipole and quadrupole modes (red, green, blue), as a one-dimensional model predicts them (open) and as the star produces them (filled), if the model's outer layers are wrong in the way the Sun's models are. Low in the diagram the two coincide. With increasing frequency the star's modes fall behind the model's, by an amount that grows steeply and is the same for every degree, so all three ridges bend to the left together: by 19.3 µHz at 4104 µHz. The bend is the surface effect, and it is larger than the uncertainty of any measured frequency by a factor of a hundred.

A correction that grows as the fifth power of the frequency

Every model of a star gets its outermost layers wrong, because one-dimensional models cannot follow the turbulent convection that fills them. The error shows up in the star's oscillations as an offset that is nothing at low frequency and twenty microhertz at high, two hundred times a frequency's measurement error. It is corrected with a power law nobody can derive, and the correction recovers the star only when its shape happens to be right — which is why the ages of stars are fitted not to their frequencies but to ratios of differences the surface cannot reach.

stars · Asteroseismology

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Acoustic cavityAngular momentumAsteroseismologyConvectionEffective potentialSpecific orbital energyAdiabatic invariantApoapsisCentrifugal barrierCircular orbitConditioningHelioseismology

All concepts