Astronomy & Celestial Mechanics
the sky, computed
Concept

Optimal control — where it appears

The mathematics of choosing a control history, such as a thrust direction or throttle setting, that minimises a cost while obeying the equations of motion. In astrodynamics it gives the best way to steer a burn or to arrange a sequence of them.

Named by 3 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Two ways out of a transfer orbit. The eccentricity against the semi-major axis of a spacecraft spiralling out from a geostationary transfer orbit — perigee 300 km up, apogee at geostationary height — under a continuous thrust of 0.2 millimetres a second squared, integrated through hundreds of revolutions, for two steering laws. Thrust always along the velocity (red) raises the orbit efficiently but leaves its shape almost unchanged, reaching the geostationary semi-major axis after 64 days still with an eccentricity of 0.59 — an orbit swinging between 17,000 and 67,000 km. A law that points the thrust to reduce a weighted distance from the target in both elements (blue) circularises as it raises, and reaches a circular geostationary orbit in 129 days.

The thrust that rounds an orbit turns once a revolution

An electric engine pushes gently for months, and the obvious way to point it — along the velocity — raises an orbit as fast as possible and leaves its shape almost untouched. Starting from an elongated transfer orbit, that is the wrong job. Rounding the orbit off needs the thrust forward at apogee, backward at perigee and sideways in between, a full turn of the thrust vector every revolution, and the law that does it can be written down from the equations for how each element changes.

spaceflight · Low-thrust transfer The propellant a long departure burn wastes, under three ways of pointing it. The gravity loss of a departure from a 300-km orbit to a hyperbolic excess speed of 3 km/s with an exhaust speed of 4.41 km/s, against the stage's initial thrust-to-weight ratio, both logarithmic, for thrust held along the velocity (orange), held fixed in space at the best direction (gold) and turned at the best constant rate (blue). At a thrust-to-weight of 0.05: 1264 m/s, 3597 m/s and 1521 m/s. At 0.2: 166 m/s, 328 m/s and 154 m/s. At 0.8: 12 m/s, 20 m/s and 10 m/s. No one of the three is best everywhere. For burns of a few minutes to half an hour the constant-rate turn beats following the velocity by up to a tenth; for the longest burns, which sweep most of an orbit, following the velocity wins, because the direction that does most good turns faster as the vehicle gains speed and no constant rate keeps up. A fixed attitude, the simplest to fly, costs 88 per cent more than the best turn even for the strongest stage drawn, and several times more for weak ones. The true optimum, which no simple family contains, lies below all three and is computed numerically for each mission.

No single way to point a long burn

A departure burn that lasts tens of minutes wastes propellant because it cannot all happen at the lowest, fastest point of the orbit, and how much it wastes depends on where the engine points while it runs. Three simple rules — follow the velocity, hold one direction in space, turn at a steady rate — are each best somewhere and none everywhere. A steady turn saves up to a tenth for burns of minutes; following the velocity wins for burns that last most of an orbit; holding still costs twice as much as either.

spaceflight · Orbital transfer A thrust that leans out of the plane at the nodes. The yaw of the thrust — its angle out of the orbit's plane — against the argument of latitude round one revolution, at the start, half-way through and near the end of a low-thrust transfer from a 7.726 km/s orbit to geostationary speed (3.075 km/s) that also removes 28.5° of inclination. Edelbaum's law (dashed) holds the yaw at one size through each revolution, switching sign at the antinodes. The optimal law (solid) has tan β proportional to |cos u|: the thrust lies in the plane at the antinodes, where out-of-plane thrust would mostly swing the node, and leans out furthest at the nodes, where it turns the plane best — 44° half-way through the transfer, against Edelbaum's 34° all round. Raising the orbit is equally efficient anywhere, so the thrust never needs to coast: the in-plane share fills exactly the parts of the orbit where turning is poor.

A turn spread where the climb leaves room

An electric spacecraft spiralling from low orbit to geostationary has to remove its launch inclination on the way, and the classic steering law tilts its thrust out of the plane by the same angle all the way round each orbit. But out-of-plane thrust turns the plane only near the nodes, while in-plane thrust raises the orbit equally well everywhere. Letting the tilt follow the nodes — leaning hard where turning works and lying flat where it does not — saves 150 metres a second on a transfer from Cape Canaveral, with no coasting, because the climb fills exactly the parts of each orbit where the turn would be wasted.

spaceflight · Plane change

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

ΔvElectric propulsionGeostationary orbitLow-thrust transferPrimer vectorSteering lawArgument of latitudeAscending nodeEccentricityEscape velocityFinite-burnGauss's variational equations

All concepts